This is one of those "diamond in the rough" type of places. It's not pretty to look at, but the quality product that comes out is exactly what the flavor experience is supposed to be like. I'm not happy that you have to order 12 to get it unbaked, but it's cool that they still have it as an option. The toppings they offer are pretty awesome, I was surprised to see bacon! They told me to leave in 5 minutes to pick up my order and when I got there, I waited at least 20 minutes; seemed silly to me. This place is typically busy, so if it looks slow, hit them up while you can!

This place is different but I like different. The crust was crunchy heaven. You order and pay, but then you must tell a pizza assembly person your exact toppings again. Different, but I didn't mind. Sauce was plain. I would have preferred to taste garlic and oregano and the sausage to be spicier, but I still enjoyed it. Next time, I will get it uncooked and jazz it up at home. I am still thinking about that delicious crust though.

So good. Everyone in town calls it Police Station Pizza (I think because it's in an old police station building/location, not sure.) Definitely get unmelted cheese on top. It sounds weird, but it's delicious. Leave the box lid shut and it's perfectly slightly melted when you get home. It's awesome thick rectangular cut pizza available by the slice, topped immediately and ready to go. Ideal for covid, because it's fast fresh takeout usually with no wait even though it's popular.

Fresh dough, not dried out, an abundance of ingredients when added. Good sauce! When all the dough they make for the day is sold, they close it down. The pizza is always fresh! The guy behind the counter remembers six or seven orders in his head at one time, amazing.

1st time in. Fun experience ordering. Good pizza!

TAKE-OUT ONLY. The pizza, is very good. They sell by the slice (Sicilian style, square), you pick your toppings, or they have a 12-cut, grab-n-go pizza that you assemble and cook at home. It's wonderful! PLENTY of everything, they don't skimp on ingredients/toppings. Prices are fair. On street parking. No public restrooms. NOT accessible. There is a step to get in.

Heavy dough. Cheese is piled on generously. If you want a good slice of pizza to fill you up. This is the joint. Looking for fancy ambiance and quick service at the dinner hour… you might want to look elsewhere and come back when it’s not crowded.

I wanted to let everyone know. That this is the best pizza around, They went out of there way to have it delivered to me in. Detroit. It only took 1 day. I called one day they returned the call the next day. They set it up & wouldn't charge my card till he knew. I received the Pizza. Now thats a class act. You guys are amazing. Keep it up. And thanks again. All.of you ROCK .

PTL had a pizza contest for the best pizza in the pizza area and Police Station Pizza won over 16 others pizza shops and after going there today with my husband, we agree!!! The crust was crunchy, the sauce delicious and it had just the right amount of cheese. We also tasted the pepperoni rolls and they were sooo good, we bought 2 to take home. We drove about an hour but the pizza was worth the trip. The employees were friendly, especially Roy. There is no seating but a half a block away, was a very nice park with a gazebo for us to sit down and enjoy our pizza that Roy told us about.

Excellent pizza worth it every time. Just a heads up, the google search is showing they open at 11. While that is true they don't start selling cooked pizza until 5 I think. From what I understand you can order uncooked pizza kits and cook it yourself.

Best Pizza. Ever. We drive over 3 hours every each way.....yea it's THAY good.

Great pizza, been eating here since I was a child well worth the wait! Best pizza in beaver county!

Really good pizza, and those guys don’t need a computer to take order, they are verte smart and remember how many pizza to each customer and the total for pay, I can’t remember my wife birthday!!

My parents took me here since I was a kid and I still love the pizza to this day. The crust is nice and thick, the toppings are plentiful, and the pizza is just the best in my opinion.

I have been going to Police Station Pizza for years. It has been serving constantly delicious pizza for years. If you have not tried their pizza, please do, you won't be disappointed.

Called ahead to have 2 slices of pizza ready for 10 min. Got there and they totally had forgotten about my order so I had to wait anyway. The pizza wasn't good. There was a foul taste. Idk if the cheese was bad but it didn't taste good. Disappointed overall.

A true landmark. Delicious pizza that has been consistent for many years. Another stop I make whenever I'm in the area. If you've never been, you need to stop in for a couple of cuts. This place NEVER disappoints!

Omg the pizza is amazing. It gets VERY busy so call ahead, and don't bother looking for a menu online. Very reasonably priced, easy to find and access. Customer service was good. ALSO, you order by the slice, not by size of pie. So try to figure out how hungry you are and then add a slice or two to that because it's SO delicious you're going to want more, or at least to have leftovers. There isn't in restarunt dining so plan to pick up and eat elsewhere.

Fantastic Ohio Valley Style Pizza at an Amazing Price! Get it with a mound of fresh mozarella placed on top. aka Cold Cheese and devour immediately! It will congeal if you wait too long, that's why this pizza is usually sold by the slice.

This style pizza may not be for everyone but it's worth getting periodically. Ask for extra cheese when it's fresh and allow it to melt on the way home before digging in. Atmosphere ordering on a busy day is almost like an auction house which again, may not be for everyone but worth experiencing.

We order every week and bake it at home. Staff remembers our name when we call in and always take care of us! Pizza is great rather they cook it or you get unbaked and cook at home. Always a consistent taste.

The best pizza ever. Been going here since I was a kid pizza still the same 40 years later. Great job guys

Still the same great pizza, minus the two pieces from previous tray that were cold. Newer staff, after old owner are sort of stepping all over each other and make you repeat order 4-5 times.

Best pizza I've ever had in my life. Used to drive to Ambridge from Youngstown, OH just to get it. Live closer now!