Great place for an authentic Italian, family style cuisine. Such good people. My mother is 100% Sicilian, and very hard to impress... she was amazed gave everything a HARD five stars.... do yourself, and your loved ones, a favor.... eat at Mama Santinas!!

Absolutely consistent & outstanding food & service. Long Island is over saturated with bars & restaurants but the welcoming staff at Mamma Santina’s makes you want to come back, especially the bartenders Jen & Alexa. The bar & dining room is completely renovated which really enhances the guest experience. Plus they have their own parking lot which makes it such an accessible & convenient spot in the heart of Brightwaters.

I was excited about the alfredo, however, it was horrible tasted old and rancid! and then a homeless man came in and started begging was told to leave then started yelling at people and banging on the windows. my boyfriend liked his food though, seems great depending on what you get. the garlic bread was also tasty. waitress alexis didnt really tend to our table and had an attitude when we asked for the alfredo to be taken off the bill since it was inedible.

Ever since Mammas did their major renovation, dining is an absolutely delightful experience. The dining area is beautiful, the bar is plentiful, and the menu has something for everyone. My favorite option is that you can choose a salad or pasta with your proteins. Our regular date night spot.

I really enjoy eating here especially since they redid the location. Their vodka chicken Parmesan is unbelievable. I have updated my review On here because charging $28 for a regular pie and $40 for a special pie is criminal!!!! Places like this is the reason why inflation is so high stil.

Been meaning to share my opinion for many years there. Lasagna has been one of my favorites but I feel it's not the exact same as it was just before remodeling their location. I'm also very disappointed that they no longer have French dressing which was my always go to with the lasagna I would get a salad with French dressing. They stopped carrying French dressing since they remodeled the place. The place does look beautiful. I just wish they bring back French dressing and make the lasagna exactly the way they used to make it. They also should give you classic Italian bread for dipping instead of those fancy rolls. That's another disappointment.

My family and I had great meal. Everything was was exceptional. Appetizers: stuffed mushrooms and their mussels marinara (wow) then we had soup: white bean & escarole (the best) next we had their chicken special (fantastic) but the best part of our meal was the dessert. John our waiter (nicest guy) suggested this fried wonton cannoli paired with caramel Gelato and fresh cream special (exceptional) PLEASE put this on your menu so that we may have this every time we come back!!

The Buffalo Chicken slice is perfect! And great job on the renovation. The atmosphere is awesome!

Mammas is the best pizza anywhere near, with the new layout inside. Eating in you can not go wrong

Food is consistently delicious!

This place recently made a major transition and it has become one of my favorite spots. The staff is amazing. They remember us and always make us feel welcomed. The food is consistent and very good! I love going there. It’s warm and inviting. Great spot!!

Food is great, but If you order delivery on the website for a specific time they are consistently 45min-1hr late delivering

Ordered online, said 20 mins, got there 20 minutes they said wait a min, got rung up, asked 5 times “i’ll keep checking for you” waited another 50 minutes and got the same response so i just left and left my money there too. Poverty place needs the money to hire competent workers. Wasted over an hour of my time.

I’ve been coming to this place even before the renovations,, though the atmosphere was just like a old fashioned pizzeria! The food was definitely better than most of the so called fancy restaurants I’ve encountered. The renovation is definitely a improvement and more classy! The quality and portions of food for the price, is in my opinion still better than the five star restaurants !!