Wonderful and delicious experience - highlight of our visit. After a long day of drenching rain and failed Cedar Point park plans, we found Mimi’s by chance on the way back to our hotel. We couldn’t have found a more welcoming and wonderful meal to end the day. We ordered the Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza - amazing!!! Garlic knots - perfectly garlicky, buttery, and chewy. House salad was enough to share with the entire family and we highly recommend the house dressing - white balsamic vinaigrette. Boys (3) each enjoyed a pasta special and the portion was perfect. Each pasta dish came with homemade garlic bread to soak up the yummy sauce. The homemade vodka and spicy pasta sauces should be bottled!!! Highly recommend this local treasure and encourage everyone to stop in and enjoy the delicious food, wonderful service and friendly family!

First time coming here. They have been open for 6 months now and make a very good New York style pizza. As I walked in I was greeted by Nick who went over the different pizzas and sizes. He was very helpful and gave me recommendations for when I come in next. The pizza was very good. Tried the Hot Honey Pepperoni that had Ricotta on it. The combo of the saltiness. The sweet. And the creaminess was the perfect combination. Everything is made fresh in house and cannot wait to go back. Yes it is more expensive than your main chains but what you are not going to find is the flavor and the fresh ingredients. Highly recommend giving this pizza place a shot! Worth every penny! And they also serve pizza by the slice and have combo deals. So if you need a slice for lunch or need an easy go to dinner. Stop by this place. You won't be disappointed. And thanks Nick for being so nice to me and talking about the place and the product. They also have a dine in option.

While I’m not a professional pizza reviewer, I will say after purchasing pizzas all across Cuyahoga County, Mimi’s Pizza is a top five and definitely closes pizza to the NY style. The pizza was nothing short of perfection; my wife and I enjoyed every crumb of it. We ordered the White Margarita Pizza (added mushrooms and onions). The people working there were great, and the overall location is great as well. Definitely will be returning 👏 EDIT 11.04.23 Mimi’s did it again! I added a new photo; the pizza, cheese sticks and garlic knots were 💯🔥😋!

Looks like there is a new pizza shop in town! They make thin crust New York style pizzas. Great chew! Sauce was not over powering and they use canned mushroom (my personal favorite). I personally I would have preferred more cheese on my pizza but I will definitely come back and try them again. Pricing was pretty decent (lower than most) and the size of a large pizza is bigger than most other pizza restaurants in the area. Keep up the Good work!

Excellent NY style pies! Cheese, topping and sauce ratio is perfect. Great spot if you're looking for some reliable and delicious comfort pizza. Hot Honey Pepperoni is pictured and I highly recommend it! Could always use more hot honey heh Edit: Can confirm this has become my favorite pizza place. Exploring more of the menu and we tried a calzone and HOLY COW it's massive. Pictured next to my arm for scale. If you're looking for a kick, try the spicy sauce on your next pizza or get a cup to dip your calzone or garlic knots in - it has a salsa-y taste with marinara consistency, very good! Haven't snapped a pic yet but if you stop in for a slice, the Sicilian style slice is also a delight. If you're a fan of Jets deep dish, this will be right up your alley. Have them leave it in the oven an extra few mins for some extra crunch in each bite. Much like the NY style they make, the Sicilian has the perfect amount of cheese, sauce and pepperoni. First time in get yourself a combo - 2 slices to try one of each style, a bag of chips and a bottle of soda for 10 bucks, spend the extra buck and some change on a garlic knot and ask for a cup of spicy sauce to try with it.

I would say this is THE BEST pizza in town! pizza slices were super big and delicious, it had a nice homemade taste. I don’t really know anything about new york pizzas but workers were really nice and patient towards that. 100% recommend this place. 🍕

5 stars isn’t high enough for the experience and amazing food at Mimi’s. Our pizza and cheese sticks were amazing. The marinara was the best my wife and I have ever had!! We got to personally chat with the owners and tell them why we were in town. Then, when we were getting ready to leave they actually asked to pray with us that the doctors we were in town to see at Mayo would be able to find answers. We had awesome food but even more amazing service. Can’t say enough good things about this place. Love, Shoals ☺️

I have drien by here a few time and kept saying I want to stop in and try there pizza. Being from NY I'm always looking for a great pizza that reminds me of back home, I can say that to me I believe this is the best place not just because every bite taste better than the last and the smell of the fresh pie when you open up the box is fantastic, it the owners they are very friendly if it's not busy you can sit down and have a conversation with them while they make your food they treat with respect and appreciation and that will go along way with people they want customers make memories here and keep making memories here for generations to come. It's more than just food it's about what bring people together that enjoy the simple things in life. So please support this newly opened family owned business believe me you won't regret .