We stop by quite often to get their pepperoni pizza. Just this most recent time I decided to try their fried pickles… was not disappointed! Love this place. Food is always hot, take-out doesn’t take too long at all, and decent employees! 🍕❤️

I have had the chicken parm dinner many times. To the owner or chef. Your thick part of the sauce is good but it doesn’t stick to the spaghetti and more than half is water. Probably because it’s frozen and the ice is not poured out before serving. You would have a fantastic restaurant if you fixed this sauce since it’s probably served on all ur plates. Thank you

My boyfriend and I love this place, it is always good and the staff is always nice. Pizza never disappoints. I totally recommend this place.

The pizza is fabulous! They offer several daily specials. If you dine in they give you 4 garlic knots with dipping oil and they are so good! Beverages are self-serve and bottomless. Service is very quick. Seating is limited inside. It is our favorite pizza place!

Great pizza lunch special every day until 4pm. Two slices, a fountain drink, and some delicious garlic knots. They always have some interesting special slices. Today I had Mango Kahuna, and Mintonian, which lit me on fire. This place is worth the drive.

The best pizza I've ever eaten. The garlic knots alone will bring you back and the soft drinks are ice cold. The staff are like family. I love this place.

They don't deliver until after 4:00 p.m. because they can't find any employees to deliver food. Then when you order online it says it'll be there in about an hour and 15 minutes. Not true it takes almost 2 hours because they put together everybody's order because of the lack of drivers. The quality of food that you get is not worth the waste of time trying to get it delivered. We ordered salads at 6:00 p.m., and at 8:00 p.m. we had to cancel the order and eat whatever we had in the house because it still hadn't arrived. We live less than 10 Mi away for crying out loud.

I gotta say, this place is legit for NY style thin crust pizza. I’m from South Jersey so I know what it should be like and they nail it. Thin, crispy crust. A slightly sweet tomato sauce and what appears to be freshly grated mozzarella. If it was me I’d add a little more cheese and a generous sprinkle of olive oil. But if yous are down thisaway and craving some back home thin crust NY style pizza, yous can’t go wrong with this place. Pick up a slice and fold it and there is no droop. Just how it should be. Fagetaboutit…

Really bad this time. We love Pepperoni Grill, both locations. Usually BSL is better than the oak island location but today they really dropped the ball. Lots of bubbles in the pizza, excessive flour on the bottom. Wings were hard and mozzarella sticks were burnt. $100 order pretty much wasted. Not mad, just disappointed. Probably gonna take a break for a while.

I came in got a menu and ordered a quick pizza for my granddaughter. She had some time between classes. Molly was so pleasant and was on top of it with a plate and napkins for her. Then I called and placed an order and one again. Molly was so pleasant taking the order and making sure she had the proper order and pick up time were correct. I came in and picked up dinner and I just can’t say enough about the crew and the food is amazing! Every time I come to see the grands I make sure I get food from there. Not only is the pizza on point but the salads are fresh and delish. Keep up the good work

Got 2 single slices of a specialty pizza the budda it is so good and fresh love this place. And the workers and so nice and amazing. No matter how busy you still get your stuff quick and it's always so good.

This is our go to local pizza / Italian restaurant! They have a good variety on the menu of pizzas, sandwiches, and salads. We have pretty much had everything on the menu and it's delicious! The Italian stallion sub is my favorite and they let me switch the ham for turkey. Also and probably most important their ranch dressing is the best in town!

The food is delicious but every time you call the girl sounds like you are inconveniencing her by calling and ordering. Better tips when you have more joyful people who like their job answering phones Needs improvement and customer service lessons Hi came in today two weeks later. And still had every employee with a scowl on their face. They hate their jobs. Find people who enjoy serving other people because the girl at the front desk and the guy on the phone none of them like their job and I’m gonna go somewhere else next time. I don’t care how much I like the food. It’s not worth the atmosphere and leaving with a bad attitude.