This place was referred to us for some good Italian food which is hard to find in the JCP area. A little bit out of the way but we’ll worth the trip if your out & about in STARKE. The staff was very friendly & prompt. Best of all , very reasonably priced ! I will be back for round 2 !

I ordered a supreme calzone. It was very good. Definitely recommend it. It was a little bit of a wait. Due to it was a little bit busy when we got there. But all in all a good experience. It's a nice local sit-down restaurant. The staff was very accommodating and polite. Wasn't a long wait to get seated as well

We always have the best food when we come. One of the best places in town! Today we got bruschetta with shrimp, ravioli carbonara and I had pasta Siciliano. Never disappoints!.

Wonderful meal! Waitress was attentive even though they were very busy! Our appetizer came out quickly.. the calamari was the best I've had in a Vermont time! First time I've ever had garlic knots that were cheese stuffed.. did not disappoint 😋 Next time I'll ask for more garlic. All of us enjoyed our main courses! Looking forward to returning!

I walked in believing this was just another small town "Tony's" but was blown away by the smiles, service and quickness of this place at lunchtime. The waitress was full of smiles, the line cook was accommodating as I waited on my order, the whole experience on my to go order was fantastic. On this day I had the Italian Sub, and let me tell you, the bread and dressing made this sandwich the best I've had in a very long time!! In the age where everyone seems to be dropping quality bread to save a penny, I was happy to see this place hasn't yet. I'll definitely put this place on my lunch rotation, even if it is 45 min round trip from the office!!

The prices are amazing. The food is amazing. Love the staff. The pizza is to DIE FOR. Everything is so fresh and they’ll have a to-go order out the door in 20 mins. I refuse to get pizza anywhere else. GO HERE.

The food here is delicious! We got the Chicken Parm with meatballs & sausage. For an appetizer we got the bruschetta which was the best I've had in a long time. That alone will keep us coming back. And a must-have is their garlic knots stuffed with mozzarella. You will fall in love with those! The service was fast and friendly.

Hostess was also waitress and buser! Awesome job! The food was AMAZING! Ordered an pizza and have to say it was one of the best I have had. My wife had a chicken salad which she also enjoyed very much! Restaurant is packed! Aways a good sign of good food!

Passing through. Seems like a great small-town pizza place! They were popping on a Monday evening. My kids loved it! The special that day was 2 large pizzas for $16. I'd return to taste other menu items.

My wife and I have been here a couple of times. We realized today that we have never left a review. So here it is! The food here has been delicious everytime we visited! Today we both got the Chicken Parm with meatballs & sausage. For an appetizer we got the bruschetta which was very, very good. That alone will keep us coming back. And a must-have is their garlic knots stuffed with mozzarella. You will fall in love with those! The service was fast and friendly.

Food was absolutely delicious and is served fresh and hot. The stuffed garlic knots are served with a red sauce. We got a side of Alfredo sauce, and I feel that kicked it up to another level. The pizza was delicious as my son ate over half a large by himself. The eggplant parmigian, lasagna, Italian sub, and chicken wrap were also delicious. Depending on the size of your party, you will definitely need to order more than 1 order of the bruschetta and garlic knots. The staff was friendly and quick to check on us throughout our dining experience. This being said, we were there between lunch and dinner time. The dining area is small, so it can be tight when busy. This place is also located on the main street in town so parking could be tough at certain times of the day, but it's worth it for the food.

We love Tony and Al's so much! The food is always great, the staff are all very friendly. Try the stuffed Salmon, we love it so much we can't order anything else now. They make amazing garlic knots, and the stuffed (with cheese) garlic knots are very popular in our family.

Supernfriendly waitstaff, food comes out hot and fresh. Spaghetti was great, eggplant rollatini superb, and the garlic knots are excellent.

I've never had soggy crust before. But the toppings were good.

Service was great. Server and trainee was very helpful and always checking on us. Food came out in a reasonable time and was delicious. Great amount of options to choose from and it was fresh and tasty. The place is smaller but nice. Clean and just enough to get a small group of 5-8 people in and not be too crowded. Will definitely be back to try the whole menu. Good job.

My husband and I were in Stark and were looking for a good place to eat dinner. Ratings were good for Tony and Al's deli so we thought we would give it a try. We will definitely come back if we are in the area. Our friendly server Taylor was very knowledgeable of the menu and checked in on us often. Check out was fast. It was a friendly laid-back atmosphere. It was a positive dining experience for us.

We came hungry but definitely needed to-go boxes! The food we ordered was hot, fresh, & delicious! Our server was great! She was by herself but was hustling the whole time. Excellent experience!

This little Italian restaurant was a pleasant surprise. I had the personal pepperoni pizza and the crust was crisp with ever so slight char to it that augmented the flavor. The cheese and sauce were both quite tasty and made for a very good pizza.

Cute little place with delicious food😋 They were popping for lunch but wait times were not bad. I got the pepperoni calzone.... The cheese🤤🧀

Their pizza is better than Pizza Hut, Domino's, or Little Caesars! Every meal we've had from their extensive menu has been fantastic in flavor, the portions generous, and the value for the dollar spent, excellent! All this couldn't happen without the team of friendly and awesome employees! There's something for everyone at Tony and Al's!

Nov. 2021 What a great find in Starke. Old world charm, excellent service, great food and reasonable prices. You see them making the food with smiling faces as soon as you walk in. We tried Garlic Knots - OMGoodness! Pizza was sort of thin crust and amazing sauce (gone too quick for photo). A small for 2 of us was plenty with the knots. You must try!!!!

This was our first time at Tony and Al's. It has a quaint small dining room which filled up quickly and we noticed a brisk take out. I had the lasagna with garlic bread and a side salad. Hub had a calzone. The portions are very generous and the flavor of my red sauce was exceptional. Everything is ala carte but the prices are reasonable for the amount of food. We will definitely be going back to try more dishes.