Amazing service! Delicious subs and pizzas. What a lovely place. On this visit, I bought a heart shaped pizza.

The bacon cheeseburger pizza is fantastic! I'd say the best I've had. The sauce has just the right amount of spices, not blah tomatoe paste tasting, and the cheese is so melty and good. So yummy! 😋 It's a take and bake place, if you haven't been there before but they have additional items for sale. Such as, bloody mary mix, spices, adult beverage veggies, even some tin signs for sale.

Vito sub was delicious. Every bite was bursting with flavors. Perfect temperature for a toasted sub. Ladies working there were very polite and informative. 1st time experience eating there. Definitely a new lunch or dinner routine. This place blows away any typical franchise sub restaurants. Thank you for understanding the value of our money and providing excellent service and food. I'll be back

I've had my share of cauliflower crust pizzas, probably at least 20 restaurants worth of different cauliflower crust pizza, and nothing compares to this restaurants. I got a 14" Cajun pizza w/ Cauliflower crust. Cooked it at 375° in a conventional oven for 18 minutes and checked it. Gave it a little bit more time and it was perfect. Undeniably the best pizza I've had in my life.

Great local place! Friendly, and just a cool little joint in Oshkosh. Grabbed a pizza and Jolly Good Cream Soda there. So good and made me happy to support local business.

Love the kids / single meal pizzas. Freezing them for a fast snack or meal is a great go to.

Very disappointing. At the prices charged, scrimping so hard on meat ingredients defies logic. The pizza had the wrong sauce on also. I was told to expect the red sauce. It came with the white creamy sauce which was not what was ordered. Papa Murphy's is a much better value and pizza

Lived in Neenah my whole life and never knew this place existed until recently. I'm addicted to this pizza!! Super fresh tasy ingredients, great pricing and friendly staff. I'm now a regular:)

You better call ahead they take orders over phone and do them while you are waiting and ordered in person lost my business. I was waiting 20 min on one 14 in pizza inside.I ordered waited 10 minutes guy comes in gets his pays takes 2 other peoples orders yup not a time sensitive place.

I discovered Eatons when I moved to Oshkosh - and I always have a great experience. I love pizza - and Eatons is in my top 3. They also have delicious subs and a lot of other great options. Both locations in Oshkosh have exceptional service and delicious food. Highly recommended!

Always a great experience. Absolutely spotless facility. You can see they take great pride in that. Great string cheese select amongst other things. It's well worth the visit.

Met the owner and she is very kind. This is the type of small business we need to support. They have another local small business owners product in store as well “OshPop”. Even the owners of Tipsy Otter were in the store with their kids buying some stuff. It’s great to see these businesses working together to build one another up. Their take n bake is the best.

Awesome place. Visiting family and happened to stop by. Top quality wraps (tried the Wisconsin Cheesteak and Mediterranean Chicken), and even better pizzas. Best part was that anything you wanted, they would make it for you.

Very pleasant customer service and pizza was made within a few minutes. I love Eatons pizza and feel the prices are very reasonable

Eaton's aroma is so nostalgic! The smell alone just takes me back to middle school walking home from school and stopping in to get a big dill pickle and a 3 inch sub. No matter how many years pass... the food is still excellent, great ingredients, wonderful and friendly staff and a full and happy tummy!

Staff was very helpful and kind. I always appreciate it when you make my pizza the way I want it. Keep up the amazing job!!!

This is a super friendly place to go to get some AMAZING food! Although the food tastes good on its own the people here is why I drive across Oshkosh for a sandwich. Thank you Eatons!!

Been going to Eaton's for over 20 years (fewer and further between with how far away I live now). Whenever I drive through Oshkosh, I gotta try and stop in. Where else can you get a 24" sub with as much as they put on it along with the softest sub bread, for only $20?! Eaton's, in my opinion, best subs in the Fox Cities. The pizzas are really good too, but I go for the subs

So friendly, great sandwiches. Take and bake pizza made fresh or frozen. Great partner for a lot of local organizations for fundraising. Great community member I support any time I can.

The staff was really hustling today to accommodate the rush hour. I frequent Eatons several times a month because we love their cauliflower crust pizzas. The employees there are by far some of the friendliest in Oshkosh, highly recommend!

Was in yesterday sharing some negative comments about another store the employees were amazing order was accurate and the selection was off the charts. After receiving my order I transported to my awaiting boat party and all ingredients and bread was fresh and delicious. I will recommend to everyone I know asking for a great sub in the area

This Eatons is one of my favorites, owners are kind and family oriented.. Definitely a reflection of their establishment. Pizza is fresh and toppings are as well. Never had something that wasn't absolutely great here! Their subs are also awesome!! If passing through thus area, an absolute must to stop here and bring home a few pizzas!!

One of the best pizzas around, always keep going back!!

Giving a 4 star because I didn't know they had a rewards card going on after ordering 2 party platters until a couple months later when I came in and overspent and then was asked if I was part of the rewards. Don't know if it's by price or order, but ouch either way. Also bought the frozen garlic bread sticks, I think I got a batch without garlic.

(Sub-sandwich review) Good... but not great. I love all the options provided for the subs and loved the meat but the cheese and bread, not so much. The cheese doesn't taste very fresh, and the bread is very soft/airy like subways bread but even more so which is a turn off for me. I prefer a little stiffer bread for a sub like Jimmy johns or jersey mikes, so if you like very soft, airy bread like subways, this is the place for you. Otherwise just stick to Jimmy johns and jersey mikes which are my favorite.

Great service and great pizza. Pizza was made very quickly.

Our favorite place to grab a quick dinner! Their subs, wraps and pizzas are all so good and a perfect variety for our family!

Ordered a pizza ahead for pickup and it was ready to go on time and correct. Everything I have ever gotten there has been exceptionally fresh with good ingredients and made with care. It’s awesome the management can train people to do a great job and take good care of customers. That’s why I chose to support small businesses like Eatons 9/10 times if I can.

I love coming in for not only pizza and tasty sub sandwiches but for other deli items, this visit was for corned beef… comes in nice little frozen packs that they sliced days ago… now I can make sandwiches at home or creamy Reuben soup!!