The consensus among reviews is that this is the best deal Omakase you will find in Brooklyn, and that service isn’t great. Both points deserve more explanations. First, there are a few Omakase options: the regular nigiri Omakase for $55, and the sashimi + nigiri for $75. They also have an open style Omakase mixing seasonal fish with some of the regular pieces. This last option is available at market price, which was $108 in our case for 12 pieces. We took the open style Omakase and didn’t regret it. The fish was super fresh with a smooth texture, something we haven’t been used to on the East coast (sorry!). The seasoning in each sushi was also original (seaweed, yuzu, scallions), which was more in line with what we expected from an Omakase. Special mention to the sea urchin, which is always hit-or-miss. In this case, it was excellent. One disappointing note though: in almost every sushi, the seasoning was slightly overpowering the dish, making it hard to taste all the subtlety of the fish. This imbalance was a problem, but despite this issue, the overall menu was quite good, and 12 sushis was enough for a dinner. As for the service, it was actually fine. Our waiter was nice, and described every sushi with lots of details. In the end, was it the best sushi of our life? No, but who cares, it was really good sushi, and definitely as good, if not better than some pretentious options that charge twice as much in Manhattan (*ahem Yasuda*).

I went to Katsuei the other night. Pretty nice. The best sushi in Brooklyn they say. “If the fish was any fresher you will have to catch it with a hook.” I read. Very nice place. Sterile, I could probably operate on these tables…. service was ok. Was it the best sushi I ever had? At least the best I had in Brooklyn? Unfortunately I’ll have to say no, it wasn’t. It felt like the owner thought it is though. 🤷‍♂️

Celebrated my birthday here with the open omakase and it was excellent. Every piece was delicious and the service and experience were great without dropping as much money as some nice omakase places in the city. Can’t wait to do it again.

Amazing appetizers and sushi… black miso cod to rival nobu. Will definitely be back to try their omakase! I appreciate that they offer high quality sushi at various price points, with standard sushi entrees and more high end omakases - quality sushi at different price points.

Amazing sushi and super attentive service. I’ll definitely be returning.

Omakase was reasonably priced but more importantly, their fish selection is very good and very fresh. We got many fish from Japan and fish that is not normally served elsewhere. Their Saba, sawara are all house cured and prepared and it is so good. I can't wait to go back to this place!

This place is one of the best meals in the city. Go and pay for the highest quality omakase at the omakase bar and you will be thoroughly impressed.

My friends and I got the sushi omakase and the food was excellent! The only thing is the tables are pretty tight from each other, I would def come back regardless! Food: 5 stars Service: 4 stars Ambience: 3 stars

My friends and I enjoyed the open style omakase and were all very impressed. Wide variety of sushi pieces and all very high quality. One of the best prices for omakase in the NYC area.

After spending the day together in Park Slope, my mom and I were hungry but didn't have a specific place in mind for dinner. I did a quick search and settled on Sushi Katsuei, which had a decent rating and was close by. Upon entering the establishment, I asked the hostess for a table for 2. She asked if we had reservations, and I told her we did not. She picked up a menu and insisted that we look at it. I responded by saying that we didn't need to look at the menu before being seated. She continued insisting and added, "I am not sure if we serve what you are looking for. We serve sushi here. We don't have things like fried rice." It took me a minute to realize what she was actually saying. Essentially, since my mom and I are Black, she couldn't fathom that we would knowingly choose a Japanese restaurant that served Omakase, sushi, and sashimi. She ignorantly thought we would step into a Japanese restaurant wanting Asian food like fried rice. Long story short, do not eat here if you are Black or consider yourself an ally.

Extraordinarily good tasting sushi. Very unique flavors. But all reminds of Japan. Omakase shown in the photos.

I’ve enjoyed the place a lot in the past as the “high end sushi place in the neighborhood,” when you wanted to take friends out on an occasion. This time, they were out of a lot of stuff and the service was not on point; waitstaff was friendly but didn’t seem knowledgeable or able to describe things clearly. Hoping it was just an off night.

We really loved our meal here. The omakase is a steal given the quality of product and the care in preparation. Flavors and textures were on point. Really appreciated the simple, modest environment and the staff were warm and friendly. Looking forward to sampling other items from the menu

Really good quality sushi and the omakase menu provides great options. The service was great and hospitable. This is a great sushi spot if you don’t want to travel into the Manhattan and want to stay in Brooklyn. And the price is amazing. You can probably find cheaper, but the quality won’t be as good. Definitely recommend bringing family and friends here if they enjoy sushi at a good price.

Fantastic meal! Perhaps they've been reading these reviews and course corrected because we had excellent service, the waitstaff was very attentive and helpful, and they are also now serving tap water. The sushi and sashimi omakase included several heavenly pieces of otoro and the price was amazing for the quality.

Absolutely love Sushi Katsuei Brooklyn!!! Their omakase is my favorite meal in all of NYC!!! Every piece is prepared so originally (fish paired with plum paste and a shiso leaf, for example!) - It’s the only meal where I literally smile every bite!!! Also, we love the staff!! The server Q and sushi chef John and our favorites, but everyone is so wonderful, hardworking and kind!! Cannot recommend Sushi Katsuei more!!! 🤗

Had a kanpachi collar app, and multiple nigiri from chūtoro to kohada and unagi. Pieces are on the smaller side, but the fish is perfectly cut and exceedingly delicious, seasoned appropriately and sumptuous. My only regret is not having more time to taste more of the menu. It's been a few years since I visited Katsuei and I'm just as happy as I was on my first visit.

Great local sushi spot! Been here a few times and it has only been great. I think the prices are on point for the tastiness of the fish. The fried tofu appetizer really nice as well.

Best omakase in park slope! So nice to get quality fish in the neighborhood. Such a good steal for the quality. The fatty tuna, salmon, and mackerel are favorites!

The omakase is definitely worth it! Service is also great.