I had given up on finding good pizza in Jacksonville. I tried all the recommended spots and was disappointed every time! I’m so surprised nobody recommended this spot… THIS is amazing pizza! Hands down the best I’ve had in years! Great work guys! Keep up the quality and positive vibes!

Pie 95 is by far my number one go to spot for pizza. The style and taste of this pie is unique and packed with flavor. They combine fresh quality toppings with a custom crafted pizza dough that is different from any other pizza joint in town. Once again they delivered and exceeded my high expectation.

The owner is awesome! I love this place. I highly recommend this place for good pizza! I’m from Chicago and I opened a pizza restaurant in tampa. This is no doubt one of the best pizza joints I’ve ever been to. The owner Evan let me come back there and make a pizza with him. Great culture there and this is the place to eat great pizza

I’m from Chicago so I’m very picky when it comes to my pizza and I was blown away with how yummy and authentic my Margherita was. My family and I also had their meatballs and it was so flavourful and soft. I ate the entire pie by myself (no shame bout it 😂) and I was so impressed by the service. Maiya tended to us hand and foot and you could tell the chef takes pride in what he does. Stellar pizza, 10/10 recommend. And worth the 40 minute drive!!

I will happily drive 45 minutes for this pizza! I’m a sucker for wood fired oven pizza, and this always hits the spot. I’m a traditional girl so it’s Margherita or pepperoni for me, but they’re all really good. And don’t sleep on Chef’s specials! He creates delicious plates showcasing seasonal locally grown ingredients, and his incredible talent in the kitchen.

Great pizza. Tasty wings. Too bad they didn’t use the rosemary in front of the pizzeria to make potato pizza. I highly recommend this place.

I can't have pizza but the group I was with said that it we really good. The wings were really good, the outdoor seating/atmosphere was nice and the staff were so friendly. Definitely a great experience.

The people inside were so friendly & welcoming! They recommended some food items to us & let us sample the meatballs. It’s all super fresh, I’d highly recommend coming by!

The food is great—the best pizza and meatballs I have had in a long time. The Girl at the counter went over the menu, gave us suggestions, and was great. The food was piping hot, fresh, handmade dough, and homemade. Sitting inside was limited and the chairs seemed a bit odd. Overall a great local eatery.

I searched for the highest rated pizza on Google in Jacksonville and Pie95 in historic Riverside won. It certainly didn’t disappoint. We ate there tonight and it was fantastic. 5 star in my book. We had the wood fired pepperoni pizza, garlic bread and topped it off with Tiramisu for desert. The marinara sauce was a great addition to dip the garlic bread and pizza crust with.

Such yummy pizza, friendly staff & good vibes. The burrata was DELICIOUS! We got The Fungi pie and it was also amazing. 10/10

First time trying this restaurant. The pizza is very good. If you like wood fire pizza, this is the place. The dough is baked thin and the bite and chew is soft and good.

During a time where staff attitude and customer service is all over the place, I really appreciate that the staff here were extremely friendly and took the time to answer my questions and make order recommendations without making you feel stupid for asking. Pizza was actually pretty good and the pizzas are perfect individual sizes. For me, I wish the pepperoni had more flavor, but my wife loved her pizza bianca and began fussing about how much better it was with a gentle squeeze of lemon. The kids really enjoyed the appetizer garlic bread and their cheese pizza. Inherent with wood fire pizza, there was a small bit of burnt on the bottom off the pizzas and one of my kids wasn't into the taste it gave the pizza, just keep that in mind if you have sensory kids. The portions are indeed small. My 3 kids inhaled the garlic bread, my wife and I got a small bite each to try it. It's really good but you get a piece about half the size of the plate it's served on and marinara sauce on the other half. It's the perfect size for two adults to share. They offer canned drinks, beer, and wine. No fountain drinks. Not a deal breaker but at $2 a can you don't get much. Water is free, ice cold, and available without bothering staff which is nice. Overall my family enjoyed it, the atmosphere was fun with the subtle ninja turtles theme and local artistry on the walls. There isn't a lot of seating so be aware of that if you have a large group. Overall I'd love to come back as a couple, but probably not with the kids.

Pie95 is sooooo delicious 😋. Restaurant is clean, staff is awesome and the outside beer garden is so chill and relaxing. I love the pizza, but I STAN the lemon pepper curry chicken wings!! 🙌🏼🙌🏼

Really amazing food all around. Their pizza is even better than V's. The burrata salad is the best I've ever had. The meatball app was delicious but for the price seemed a little small (we spent $60 (!) on a pizza, salad, meatballs, and two drinks). I always get their margherita pizza and last time I added balsamic glaze which was really good. However, last time I went they clearly hadn't been brushing out the oven enough (I was a pizza cook in brick oven restaurants for many years), and all you could taste was the nasty burnt ash of old pizzas. We didn't finish our pizza, an employee happened to come by and ask us how the food was and we nicely told him the issue, and he was just like "oh yeah we got really busy tonight, sorry about that" and walked away. No offer to refund, no offer to remake the food. I can see they have been getting busier and hiring new people but they need to tell their new employees how to properly handle a complaint and brush the oven regularly—even when you're busy.

Everything I expected from Pie 95! Delicious food paired with great customer service and company. I ordered The Marinara (add mozzarella and s sausage). My drink of choice was a local cider (Farm Cider) great pairing. There’s seating inside, out front, and in the back. Plenty of room for everyone to enjoy some great food!

From the moment I arrived and could feel the warmth emanating from the stove I knew I was in for a special treat. Kind smiles were additionally welcoming from the employee staff and its owner. A private dinner event I was attending was being held in their spacious outdoor pavilion that was filled with picnic tables and umbrellas. The interior decor was inviting and displayed some lovely artwork. Very clean and comfy with great views of the pizza oven. From the salad and fresh mozzarella, tasty lemon pepper wings, onto a delicious meatball flatbread and amazing tasting Margherita pizza…I’m glad I saved my appetite all day to enjoy it all! You just have to stop in and try for yourself, cause I know I’ll be back soon for some more!

Great people make great food. First stop any time I’m in Jacksonville is Pie 95 and a place I wished I lived closer to. Although I’d be even fatter lol. Worth it. Evan and the crew do it right. Great Pizza! I’m craving their white pie all the time since I was last there. Thanks for all you guys do!

I’m a native Sicilian and this pizza really encapsulates all of the flavors that I know and have experienced in the years that I have from going to Sicily. Evan has a sophisticated understanding of flavor profile and the mixing and quality of ingredients. It’s truly a treat to eat here. The service is also exceptional and very welcoming! I can’t recommend this place enough. Do yourself a favor and eat here!

We went here for my birthday, out of all the pizza places in the adjacent Jacksonville area I have never experienced a pizzeria with such great hospitality and atmosphere. Being from New England I have obnoxious pizza standards that I cant shake no matter how hard I try, this restaurant, even though not a traditional New England pizza, was a fantastic combination of Brooklyn New York and New haven. Even though us New Englanders have a hard time finding comforting pizza here in the south, this restaurant is a great substitute and I am certain I will be coming here when ever i have the chance.

I’ve been a fan since the food truck days. I can confidently say the same passion is being input into this brick and mortar. The pizza is great and now I don’t have to go around tracking his truck to get some delicious pizza. Highly recommend checking it out and hanging out for a while.

You had me at burrata <3 So yummy and satisfying with fresh greens and tomatoes. I love the variety of fresh pizza ingredients- arugula, fresh mozzarella, balsalmic glaze, shaved parm, and my new fave: Mike's Hot Honey. There's no other pizza joint that can do pizza like you. Outside eating area is great space to chill with your pizza and beer. Oh, and thanks for carrying Mom's apple juice - Conagree and Penn Cider. Pie95, you're a 30 minute drive, but totally worth it!

I am a Connecticut native who moved to Jacksonville a year ago from NY, and I have been desperately seeking good pizza since I got here. Thanks to Pie95, my search is over. This is real deal pizza that would hold its own in the tri-state area. Excellent crust, quality ingredients, a sauce that strikes a perfect balance, and nice owners. Without question, this is the best pizza in Jacksonville. I give this place my highest and unqualified recommendation, and I grew up on Sally's Appiza in New Haven!

Been going to Pie95 weekly for over a year. By far the best Pizza I have tasted in Jacksonville and also well up to par with the best New York joints. The pizza has never disappointed in the 50+ times I have had it, and the service is always pleasant and accurate (they have yet to get an order wrong). I truly couldn’t recommend this place enough.