Interior View of The Italian Kitchen

The Italian Kitchen

Restaurant

πŸ‘πŸ‘ We had dinner here twice, while staying at Morritts. Both visits we arrived after 8pm and food and service was great. Prices are reasonable and food was delicious. We had: Lobster and shrimp risotto , Chicken parmigiana, Lobster fettuccine, chicken Marsala with angel hair pasta, and the Pasta... People often mention pizza, family, good, recommend, meal, great, Italian, decided, Cayman, service,


Address

Queens Hwy, Cayman Islands

Website

www.italiankitchencayman.com

Contact

+1 345-949-8210

Price rating

$$ $$

Rating on Google Maps

4.50
(423199 reviews)


Working Hours

  • Thursday: 4 to 9β€―PM
  • Friday: 4 to 9β€―PM
  • Saturday: 4 to 9β€―PM
  • Sunday: 4 to 9β€―PM
  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 4 to 9β€―PM
  • Wednesday: 4 to 9β€―PM

Visitor Reviews


Frequently mentioned in reviews: pizza (12) family (12) good (11) recommend (10) meal (10) great (8) Italian (8) decided (8) Cayman (8) service (7)
Reviews are sorted by relevance, prioritizing the most helpful and insightful feedback at the top for easier reference.
  • 5/5 Alan M. 1 year ago on Google β€’ 56 reviews
    {"0":"We had dinner here twice, while staying at Morritts. Both visits we arrived after 8pm and food and service was great. Prices are reasonable and food was delicious. We had: Lobster and shrimp risotto , Chicken parmigiana, Lobster fettuccine, chicken Marsala with angel hair pasta, and the Pasta primavera. We recommend all of these dishes.","2":["0","338"]}
    2 people found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 4/5 Brook F. 7 years ago on Google
    Pretty good Italian Restaurant across the street from the Wyndham Reef Resort. The staff were all friendly and efficient, and not overbearing. Food was great, although maybe a tad salty. I ordered a Supreme Pizza as pictured here and it was fairly tasty - maybe not the best pizza I've ever had, but certainly a solid quality pizza. Prices were about average for the location. Save some of your leftovers for the poor feral cats that hang out outside!
    2 people found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 3/5 Aileen L. 1 year ago on Google β€’ 277 reviews
    {"0":"I read so many mixed reviews but still decided to check this place out. And I found the reviews to be true \u2026 food was fantastic. We ordered the Hawaiian pizza and the shrimp pesto pizza. For dessert we had the sticky toffee pudding and the tiramisu. Loved the thin crust on the pizza. And the warm sauce for the pudding was heavenly. The unfortunate part of the experience was the service. The reviews were correct in saying the food took a long time to come AND the server was quite rude. So even though the food was delicious, I only gave a 3 star due to the bad service, it really left a bad taste in my mouth.","2":["0","239"]}
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 3/5 Russell K. 1 year ago on Google β€’ 160 reviews
    {"0":"Pizza was a good 6\/10. Chicken Parmesan was 3\/10. Service by our waitress was ok but she was nothing other than serving us. The owner was behind the bar and greeted us rudely when entered. It seemed that they did not want kids there. If you are in the hospitality industry you should treat your guests right. This place would not survive in another part of the island. It is only just because of its location to the local hotels. Not family friendly with young ones.","2":["0","240"]}
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 4/5 Tyler J. 2 years ago on Google β€’ 84 reviews
    {"0":"Environment was great and servers were very friendly. From the outside it looks kinda rundown but inside it is very nice! The food was pretty good however the focaccia was probably my favorite. Would definitely recommend!!","2":["0","223"]}
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 1/5 Chris Van A. 7 months ago on Google β€’ 13 reviews
    We were charged 19 US dollars for a kids pasta with butter, they overcharged for a dessert drink, and it was 7 bucks for a Shirley temple. This place is a rip off! There is zero ambience here, it's definitely worth the 5 minute drive down to Tukka. Much better food, it's on the water and not in a mall, and they aren't trying to scam you.
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 5/5 Bicky N. 6 months ago on Google β€’ 366 reviews
    {"0":"Amazing food. HIGHLY recommend the Lamb Shank & GF Pizza. The crust is homemade & deliciously chewy. Good amount of menu options for Gluten-Free. Drinks contain a LOT of ice. Tiramisu was very good! I HIGHLY recommend this restaurant. $$$","2":["0","238"]}

  • 5/5 Len B. 2 years ago on Google
    Came here more than once during our weeks stay. Everything we had, group of 4 all different dishes were Excellent. Especially the risotto.
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 1/5 Fa A. 2 years ago on Google
    Tired and jet lagged, my family member and I just arriving in the Grand Cayman Islands decided on take out rather than dining in. As we looked through numerous restaurants, my family member decided on Italian food. I forewarned her, Italian food in the Islands is high riskπŸ˜‚ She decided this restaurant was the closest. We place and order for eggplant and angel hair spaghetti (no other choices) and something else. I asked was the eggplant πŸ† fresh, with an affirmative that it was. After 15 minutes my family walked across the road from our hotel to pickup our delicious meal 🀨. My family member returned in shock😱 It cost us almost $80.00 US for 2 items. Okay, we had to accept it as a learning experience an began to eat our expensive meal. I put my fork through the mushed spaghetti, and realized the eggplant was rubberized. My family members food was enedible as well. I returned twice to the restaurant with the food with no results. The worst food experience by far!🀬
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 1/5 FABU O. 1 year ago on Google
    Tired and jet lagged, my family member and I had just arrived in the Grand Cayman Islands. We decided on takeout rather than dining in. As we looked through numerous restaurants, my family member decided on Italian food. I forewarned her, Italian food in the Islands was a gamble πŸ˜‚ based on my past experiences. She decided this restaurant was the closest. We place and order eggplant and angel hair spaghetti (no other choices) and artichoke hearts. I asked beforehand was the eggplant πŸ† fresh, with an affirmative that it was. After 15 minutes, my family walked across the road from our hotel to pick up our delicious meal 🀨. My family member returned in shock😱 It cost us almost $80.00 US for 2 items. Okay, we had to accept it as a learning experience and began to eat our expensive meal. I put my fork through the mushy spaghetti and realized the eggplant was rubberized and recycled for the meal. Definitely NOT fresh! It was like biting into a rubber tire. πŸš— My family members' food was enedible as well. I returned twice to the restaurant with the food for return for a refund with no success. I finally gave up and threw the platter in the trash at the end of my 7 day vacation. The worst food experience by far!🀬
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 2/5 Anabell's R. 2 years ago on Google
    The food is okay, nothing special. We waited an hour and a half for our food with no explanation or apology. The order was wrong, and we let them know. They charged us for the higher price of the wrong item. They prioritized the takeout orders over those dining in person. You're paying for convenience since it's so close to Morritt's, and they deliver free, but I do not recommend dining in.
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 5/5 Heather H. 2 months ago on Google β€’ 192 reviews New
    {"0":"The bar staff was absolutely amazing. The food was made to order and was so good. I had the pesto shrimp. This is a must eat place in Grand Cayman.","2":["0","149"]}

  • 4/5 Jesse T. 5 months ago on Google β€’ 92 reviews
    Great service and pasta options. However, the atmosphere is a bit hit and mess as it can get really loud there very quickly and therefore not my first pick with the other outstanding options in East End. Best pizza in East for sure.

  • 5/5 Devin H. 6 months ago on Google β€’ 53 reviews
    Customer service was great. We had a large group (10) we called and they allowed us to make a reservation. Our server was Angie and she did a great job taking care of our whole group, even chatting up the 5 & 7 year old that were with us. The garlic knots are amazing. Everyone enjoyed their meals, gluten free pasta was a hit with my sister who is GF. Some reviews we read were negative, but we don’t have a negative thing to say about this place. Go, eat, be happy. Something to remember, Cayman time or Island time is a real thing. Things on the island aren’t fast paced, go, go, go, like other areas of the world. (The food did come out pretty quick though).

  • 4/5 Christy G. 8 months ago on Google β€’ 52 reviews
    We decided to give this spot a try one of the days that we wanted to eat "off resort" but didn't want to make a long drive after a busy day of snorkeling and diving. We're glad we tried The Italian Kitchen! The pizza was tasty (although nothing extraordinary) and the garlic knots were top notch. We love that they proudly admit to putting garlic on everything, because we too love garlic! The prices were reasonable and the staff were very nice. We ended up with enough pizza that we took home leftovers to enjoy the next day.

  • 5/5 Brian T. 7 months ago on Google β€’ 29 reviews
    Every time I visit the caymans I have to swing by this gem

  • 5/5 Angie A. 6 months ago on Google β€’ 29 reviews
    Food was good and good service.

  • 4/5 Tonya W. 3 months ago on Google β€’ 8 reviews New
    The food was fantastic and the waitress top notch.

  • 5/5 Kathy K. 7 months ago on Google β€’ 6 reviews
    Six of us spent our last night on the island at this wonderful restaurant! We all had different things, so the range was great, and everyone loved their meal. We will definitely be back on our next trip to Grand Cayman!

  • 5/5 Jennifer S. 2 years ago on Google
    Really great pizza and pasta and they had GF alternatives for both as well which made my sister soooo happy. We really like the fried artichoke starter. The hubby enjoyed the Cayman lime pie at the end (like a key lime cheesecake). Really great food and we would definitely recommend!

  • 2/5 ryan h. 2 years ago on Google
    Decent main course, terrible veg, employees dont seem to care about parties drunkenly screaming karaoke, insulting other parties, and generally causing a disturbance to other guest if theyre a decent size, $$$ ig, overall terrible service and atmosphere order out or not at all

  • 5/5 Don J. 2 years ago on Google
    Great little Italian spot right across the street from Wyndham Reef Resort. Daily seafood special (I had snapper) and the pizzas are top notch and travel well. Small wine list has good variety.

  • 5/5 Ronald M. 2 years ago on Google
    Who would think you'd find excellent Italian food on Grand Cayman but this place is as good as any I've had in New York. Chicken marsala and eggplant parmigiana we're excellent as well as fried artichoke and bruschetta as starters. Very reasonable prices for the Caymans.

  • 5/5 Mallory R. 1 year ago on Google
    We had a wonderful evening here! Service was prompt, everyone’s meal was delicious, and it’s right down the road from our resort, making it very convenient. Portions are large, which is nice to have leftovers, when staying weeks at a time. We would absolutely return here for another meal, and highly recommend it to others!

  • 4/5 Bryan W. 2 years ago on Google
    Had a meal here during my stay across the street. Food was alright but it was stuff I could mostly get at home. Id still go back for a meal on my next trip of course since I wasn't disappointed. A little taste of home is nice in a more relaxing place after all.

  • 5/5 bianca z. 1 year ago on Google
    Delicious food- worth the drive! Yummy Bellinis too!

  • 2/5 Kellie H. 2 years ago on Google
    Dinner was okay, lasagna seemed to have been heated in the microwave and not much sauce. Brushetta was delicious.

  • 5/5 Daniel S. 2 years ago on Google
    Enjoyable. Nothing crazy. We.had pizzas and shrimp alfredo (lobster is out of season). We might be back for for pizza..

  • 5/5 Fred G. 2 years ago on Google
    Wait staff was very friendly and responsive. Took order and food arrived quickly. Interior is nice and comfortable. Food portions just fine. Food was not spectacular but very tasty. Prices similar to other restaurants in the area, Cayman prices. But hey you are on vacation so enjoy. Highly recommend. Pizza is VERY good.

  • 5/5 Abby M. 7 months ago on Google β€’ 2 reviews
    Our family got take away for dinner last night, and it was so good we ordered it again tonight! Both nights our food arrived within the hour. We tried pizzas yesterday and pastas tonight!! Highly recommend the meatball pizza, lobster risotto, and lasagna! Add this to your take away rotation!! Cannot recommend this place enough!

  • 5/5 ains g. 7 months ago on Google β€’ 2 reviews
    Good pizza, even better pasta.


Trends


See how the number of reviews and average review scores have changed over time.

Similar Restaurants nearby

Last updated:
()