11/03/2023 I love this place! The pizza is absolutely delicious! Crew is friendly and the restaurant is comfortable! Absolutely delicious! Nice people and nice place. Ready quick. This is a double cheese and pepperoni, excellent!

I’ve ordered pizza from here a few times & they never let me down. Highly recommend.. 5stars

Eagles is a nice family pizza joint with a variety of options I didn’t love the pizza her but my family did it was very saucey but I loved everything else there it has a great atmosphere of war monuments. It’s a great place to head for dinner we got a pizza burger and salad and they were all delicious. Will definitely come back

I am a bit biased with this review as I understand the owner is a history buff, as I am. I appreciate those who preserve our history and share it. Because of this I went here with a friend to try the pizza. Ordered a large pepperoni and was very impressed with the taste. It was balanced and had great flavor. My buddy had a another dish that he said was very good as well. I have tried Eagles two times now and it is excellent pizza. El Pres would probably rate it a 7.9 but I would give it a solid 8.9. Very impressed.

This is our FAVORITE pizza! They even make fresh carryout "cold" (uncooked) pizzas that you can bake at home. We've never had anything that wasn't delicious. Food is prepared quickly, and the staff are super nice.

In the dull, boring, soulless corporate world of New Albany where seemingly the only new retail or restaurant development allowed are corporate chains that inspire no one stands The Eagles Villa Pizza. I've been going here for years and the food is good, the service is good and I've never had a bad meal. It's consistently good. Favorites include the shrimp dinner, Italian sub, baked spaghetti with meatballs, and of course pizza which is Columbus style.

Pleasantly surprised to say the least. We were in a hotel and looking for a quick fix. Other pizza places had a 55 min or longer delivery. We decided to try this location. I am a huge fan of thin crust and loaded pizzas. Folks argue over NY and Chicago style pizzas but I'm here to tell you, The Eagles Villa was top of the line. Not quite matched to St Louis but this was the second best pizza I've ever ate. 20 min time given for pickup and I was there on time even given snow. Staff were very friendly and I was out on a minute or two. Decor inside was a classic pizza joint. Would have been a great atmosphere. Back to the hotel, the whole family was pleased. My only regret was not taking a picture of the Pie. It was absolutely delicious. Would recommend this place to anyone. Who would have thought, you could find this amazing pizza in Ohio. Well worth it!!!! Great job to the Eagles Villa!!!!

I had a chance to try this place out the other day and I absolutely loved it. I am a big fan of this style of pizza which I would call regional to Ohio. Their sauce was on par and their crust was excellent. Overall the entire experience was wonderful and I will definitely go back. I did have a chance to try their spaghetti as well and was not impressed but to be fair I don't like spaghetti that well. The only time I eat it is when we make it at home and I make homemade sauce. They're sauce tasted like it was out of a can and it was really less desirable. I will say that their salads were good and they're fried mushrooms definitely tasted homemade.

I tried Eagles Pizza for the first time last night. Maybe I caught them on a bad night (Friday at 4:30 pm) as my pizza did NOT live up to the reviews. 1. Crust: no flavor and the texture was hard/crunchy like it wasn't fresh. 2. Sauce (as shown in my picture) I ordered extra sauce and it was fairly bland and disappointing. 3. Toppings: the sausage is the same non-Italian tasting, ground into little pieces of bland balls you can get at most Central Ohio Pizza joints. The pepperoni was good and probably the only redeeming quality on the entire pie. Chicken wings: I wanted to try their bone-in chicken wings but they were out. So I asked for their boneless chicken wings but they were out as well. To be out of wings at 4:30 pm early on a Friday evening either indicates poor inventory management, that the menu options are not very popular with customers or they might be the most amazing wings and they sold out before the Friday dinner rush. I do not know. Either way I had to drive to another pizza place to buy wings for my wife. Ordering: phone order and timely pickup was very good and the gentleman who served me at the counter was exceptionally friendly. There's too many pizza options in the surrounding area for me to rush back. It was disappointing as I've heard such stellar reviews.

Fantastic pizza my first trip here was the taco pizza, the third (in the picture the BBQ chicken with extra chicken). The pizza is awesome and the people have been super friendly in my three visits. Eagles is a must go to, if you like pizza!

The pizza is really good and consistent but.... This is the last time I order from here. 2 of the 3 things we ordered were completely wrong. This happend the last time also. Just glad there is more options moving in the area. I ordered fish no fires and side of mushrooms the pic is what I got.

Pizza was decent. They seem to really load up the toppings. The crust really can support the toppings so it ends up being a mess with your toppings everywhere if you dont fold it. Im a sauce guy, and while there is sauce, you cant taste it because of all the toppings. In terms of service you kinda seat yourself and get your own drinks. They bring the pizza out to you but there isn't like table service. Not the worst but not the best i've had here.

Felt great from the moment I walked in, and the service was great as well. The prices seem to be a little less than the other top pizza places. The dinning area was nice, vintage artifacts on the wall. The pizza was about a 9 out of 10 which is great but I don't think it necessarily separated itself from other great pizzas in any major way. I think the sauce was a little more ordinary than I had hoped it would be

The pickup order experience was fine, but the Italian sub had no Italians dressing on it so we had to use our own at home. It was okay but nothing special and not crispy like how we like subs. The pizza smelled "off" like it had souring ham or something on it. We had the All The Way and even when reheating leftovers something just did not smell right. It had almost no sauce at all, and we tasted sauce only on a few pieces.I have never had an experience like that before and I have tried a lot of pizza from all over. Overall, a lackluster experience after reading great reviews from my FB pizza review site. Maybe some topping was marinated rather than fresh. Very strange.

Great crust with generous toppings. Good deal for the price. I just wish they served to go with the pizza. Family friendly place.

Honestly the Mexican Pizza is SO GOOD. We got it thinking it would be interesting.. but it exceeded our expectations. The flavors melted together beautifully, and for having all the toppings, it still help together well without falling apart. Must add the sour cream & hot sauce! Pepperoni pizza was wonderful too, as was the service and location.

This place has been on the top of our list for pizza and cheesy garlic bread. They also make tasty fried mushrooms. Either it's dine in or take out, they never disappoint.

Now, we all know the Taco Pizza is AMAZING.. but the best kept secret is their sugar cookies from the bake shop of heavenly goodness. If you went to St. Francis DeSales and remember the sugar cookies that they had to rationed out throughout the lunch periods?? Yeah, these are just as amazing and honestly taste pretty similar. I literally dream about these cookies.

Been meaning to try Eagles for a couple of years and finally did so tonight. The best pizza that I've had in a long time. My son has already declared it his favorite. Definitely the best meatball sub in town. Can't wait to order from here again.

Some of the best pizza around! I usually get the All the Way, and it never disappoints. There's something special about the crust. It gives a small crunch, but is also chewy. The toppings are so fresh, and I love the crumble sausage, not the big hunks. Just a great all around pie!

Having never lived near Eagles, I've only had it here and there, sparingly, over a 30 year span. Every time, the flavor is the same. And it's delicious! For my money, the best zaa in Columbus. Crisp, cracker crust, perfectly cooked. Rich, but not overly sauced marinara. You MUST try the crumbled sausage, it's a game-changer. If you want consistently excellent pizza, Eagles is THE spot.

THIS PLACE HAS IT!! Ya know, that perfect thin crust pizza?? If you're a lover of thin crust pizza(not the chewy kind that you find at those franchise chains), then you know it's so hard to find a place with that specific thin crust that has the perfect thickness, with just the right amount of crisp and slight tenderness in the right places. Their taco pizza is fantastic, I highly recommend it. The meat is perfectly textured with a fine crumble so its distributed equally throughout. The flavors blend together perfectly. If it's your traditional pep&cheese you're looking for, top notch over here y'all! Don't waste time reading reviews, go grab ya some of the best pizza in the city!

Eagles is an old favorite of ours. Happy to finally make it back. It's been years. Glad life is getting more and more like normal after COVID.

Stopped to pick up dinner for the family on my way home from work. Wanted to try something local and not a chain pizza. Placed my order when I got to the store and was told it would take about 30min. No problem. Went out to buy a tin of chocolate covered pretzels from the Boy Scouts, put it in my car, and went back into the pizza shop. Only waited about 15min when they called my name. Took dinner home and the pizzas were excellent. Crust was just right, amount of toppings was reasonable, and the flavor of the sauce and cheese was very good. Will definitely have to order for dinner again. Or maybe go there for lunch someday.