This location is permanently closed.

Featured Reviews


Frequently mentioned in reviews: pizza (35) good (13) Great (12) service (9) nice (8) fresh (6) order (6) Italian (6) crust (6)
Reviews are sorted by relevance, prioritizing the most helpful and insightful feedback at the top for easier reference.
  • 4/5 J F. 4 years ago on Google • 123 reviews
    The garlic twists were amazing, just perfect. The spaghetti and meatballs while very aesthetically pleasing was nothing special if you ask me, the meatballs as well I think were nothing to write home about. However my fiance loved it so maybe you will too. Service was fine.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Amel H. 2 years ago on Google • 33 reviews
    Great pizza!! Their mushrooms are fresh and marinated, they are delicious! Come here for good pizza
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 Niki N. 4 years ago on Google
    If I could give this place negative stars I would we drove 4 hours to the science center n our son wanted pizza he is 4 and after one bite said mommy this pizza is terrible not only was it not New York style as advertised it was gross and hurt my stomach after I ate it was sick all night we got cheese sticks that were also terrible and in a clump that you could tell were boxes like that not from the delivery when I called to talk to someone they said ya someone will call u back tomorrow the owner called me back the next morning and was extremely rude n said there’s nothing she can do refuses to refund me money and did nothing not even an apology I would not ever recommend this place ever unless u want terrible pizza and a stomach ache!!!
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 The Honeyest G. 4 years ago on Google
    I love this place! I had so much pizza it lasted me 2 days! 100% recommend going here!
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 Kendra w. 4 years ago on Google
    I called and placed a to go order, walked in and no one said anything to me as I walk in (no greet). Didn’t know the price before I came in, wasn’t sure if I was suppose to be responsible for asking? And 18 dollars for a small portion of food was not what I was expecting. The people were emotionless and said nothing to me. I guess it’s not a place I’d wanna walk back into but it might be for you. I’d probably have someone else order me the food and pay for it with their money bc id wanna avoid that experience again.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 rachelle t. 2 years ago on Google • 3 reviews
    Went on a Thursday eve. First time! Food was absolutely delicious. We ordered garlic knots and meatballs 😍 and pep, sausage, onion, banana peppers, & green onions pizza. Everything was super fresh and the chef also made us some homemade buffalo dip👌🏾Waitor was a 10! Very polite and attentive.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 2/5 Sophie 5 years ago on Google • 513 reviews
    We went during happy hour. Waiter was nice but didn't tell us that specialty pizzas weren'f included in happy hour pricing, despite knowing that we were clearly there for happy hour.. we didn't appreciate that. The pizza was good but we would have appreciated a heads up about happy hour deals since they weren't clearly listed anywhere.

  • 4/5 Monica G. 6 years ago on Google • 261 reviews
    Delicious Italian food with nice staff. I had the Rosa gnocchi and really enjoyed it. There is also a bar in back.

  • 5/5 J G. 3 years ago on Google • 137 reviews
    The supreme pizza was delicious and there's a couple local beers on tap. Friendly service and the food was ready pretty quickly. 10/10 would recommend

  • 5/5 Luis V. 5 years ago on Google • 74 reviews
    Nice sit down and friendly bar atmosphere in the heart of downtown. They have nice low lit lights that hang from the ceiling adding to the ambiance. The staff is really friendly and drinking at the bar in a mason jar gave it a nice touch.

  • 5/5 Geoff G. 4 years ago on Google • 26 reviews
    Quaint little Italian joint with a distinguished bar. Menu is not huge but has what you'd want/expect and that's a good thing. Has nice advertised happy hour deals on pizza and drinks. I was a few minutes late for that so I ordered the chicken parmigiana and oh my lordie was it heavenly. Very good portion for price but the better-than-home taste was more than worth; really liked the knot roll too! Best part of the experience besides atmosphere however was the service. The bartender especially was kind and made me feel welcome as a new face in a downtown bar! I very much appreciated that tonight. Definitely returning.

  • 5/5 David 3 years ago on Google • 13 reviews
    Still the best. Ray's on Times Square NYC can't even touch Cafe Napolitana. Dont get me wrong. Doing a Ray's Pizza near Times Square is close to heaven. I would say the two pizzas run neck and neck. *** BUT *** Columbus has Cafe Napoletana on High Street, just a few doors up from Broad, right here in Columbus Ohio. Cafe Napoletana. They hand toss and bake New York style crust. All of the toppings are fresh. They even buy fresh mushrooms and marinate them instead of getting them out of a can, unlike most of the competition. Even the bell peppers get the marinade. everything here is terrific. Palmo remembered me after nearly a year. And that was when he was just starting out twenty years ago. It was a walk up counter and he didn't even have a bar and liquor license yet. It's still a walk up, order and pay, but they bring pizza to the table. They also have a full menu of traditional Italian favorites. Someday I will give them a try but I just can't seem to get around that pizza !

  • 5/5 Ed S. 3 years ago on Google • 4 reviews
    Finally stopped through for a meatball sub last night, and went back for slices today. I’m an east coast transplant and it’s so refreshing to have finally found a spot like this right down the street. The owners and employees CARE. Owner is such a sweet guy. Please give them your business.

  • 5/5 Karrie W. 4 years ago on Google
    Great place for lunch. They have awesome lunch specials and a slice card to get a free slice after so many. I really like the ny style pizza and the pasta, but looked over the menu and decided on the cheese sticks. They are like breadsticks with cheese and are addicting. This is my new favorite item. This place is now on my weekly lunch rotation... at least when the weather permits!

  • 5/5 Sally T. 2 years ago on Google
    Good Italian - tasty!

  • 4/5 Raymond C. 4 years ago on Google
    Pretty decent 🍕 pie. Fast service, a bit pricey. All around a good lunchtime spot.

  • 4/5 James M. 4 years ago on Google
    Always great pizza

  • 1/5 Eli B. 4 years ago on Google
    Waited for 45 minutes and got no food. When we finally managed to flag down a server (who seemed overworked and understaffed) she said they hadn’t even started our order yet. Maybe they’re lovely people but I won’t be back

  • 5/5 Vera B. 4 years ago on Google
    Family atmosphere...love Mrs. Dee and family!

  • 1/5 James E. 4 years ago on Google
    Would give 0 stars, was 10min til closing and they turned me away. If it closes at 9:50pm then update it to say closes at 9:50pm thab

  • 5/5 Brian J. 4 years ago on Google
    Service was excellent. Calzone was great.

  • 5/5 Jamey W. 4 years ago on Google
    Delicious by style pizza

  • 5/5 Sequoia H. 2 years ago on Google
    Indulged too fast for pics but the garlic knots and meatballs were amazing, the pizza was perfect, the sausage on the pizza was crumbly not huge chunks, everything was made from scratch including my side cup of Buffalo sauce which had a little creamy texture that you could tell was homemade sauce. Ordered two bottles of wine as well and a cannoli. All that authentic Italian food and the drinks below $70 and could have easily fed 4 but the two of us had leftovers and left stuffed. Highly recommended. Will go again.

  • 4/5 Matt F. 4 years ago on Google
    Great pizza, below average service. We had the pepperoni pizza, and the garlic knots.

  • 4/5 Jacqueline M. 4 years ago on Google
    Good NY slice pizza. Pleasant atmosphere. Pretty fast service.

  • 5/5 Mike B. 4 years ago on Google
    Delicious pizza crust.

  • 4/5 Scott C. 2 years ago on Google
    Very good thin crust pizza, lots of variety. Long while in line, but they did have a sign on the door looking for new employees. The people who were working were very friendly and hard-working. Overall I wouldn't mind going back and trying some of the other varieties of pizza they had available.

  • 4/5 Russ C. 2 years ago on Google
    This place is a whole lotta yum! It SERIOUSLY needs updated inside, but never mind, it's the food you want. Pizza was GOOOOD. I wanna go back soon and try their lasagna.

  • 5/5 Kymberlee M. 3 years ago on Google
    Delicious food and personal, friendly service. They always thank us for ordering! They also have a cauliflower crust for the keto folks!

  • 5/5 steve b. 3 years ago on Google
    My fav location for tasty American food. Went there on a Saturday. This place has a good feel to it. Kinda of like a restaurant in Los Angeles I liked to visit.

  • 3/5 Victoria K. 3 years ago on Google
    Very homey feel. Great place and food but slow service.

  • 5/5 Elena W. 3 years ago on Google
    My preferred place for tasty pizza. filled me up. this place has a cool design. i can see why they have a lot of good reviews.

  • 5/5 Sarah F. 3 years ago on Google
    Hubby and I wanted to help out a smaller business while also eating some good pizza. To say this place was good is an understatement. The garlic knots were by far the best we've had, and the pizza reminded of us true NY style. We will definitely be returning!

  • 5/5 Andres Z. 3 years ago on Google
    pizza, super yummy. The food was so savory. The service was helpful and kind. The place has an awesome feel to it.

  • 4/5 Hayley M. 3 years ago on Google
    pizza and the scene at this place is great. Visited on a Wednesday I think. Definitely worth a return visit. The place has a cool feel to it.

  • 5/5 Mitchell K. 3 years ago on Google
    One of my favorite spots for pizza. food was so fresh. the staff was very kind and attentive.

  • 5/5 Juanita R. 3 years ago on Google
    Pizza and the scene at this place is excellent. Great location to meet with friends. Looking forward to coming back with my coworkers.

  • 5/5 Riley M. 3 years ago on Google
    Great Pizza!

  • 4/5 Jacquan J. 3 years ago on Google
    Good place to eat that fresh

  • 5/5 Sean S. 3 years ago on Google
    Great pizza!

  • 4/5 Michael M. 4 years ago on Google
    Love their food. Nice location downtown.

  • 1/5 Ashley G. 3 years ago on Google
    We tried to place an order, but no one answers the phone.

  • 2/5 KEVIN M. 3 years ago on Google
    Not sure what happened but this place went from on of the best around to just mediocre. The crust tasted like it was frozen. Very disappointed.

  • 5/5 Allgood17 T. 3 years ago on Google
    Great food

  • 5/5 Joyce H. 3 years ago on Google
    Delicious local pizzaria!! A must for downtown Columbus dining. Order in or take to go, both options you will not be disappointed!!

  • 5/5 Thomas B. 3 years ago on Google
    It's a real slice

  • 5/5 Joseph P. 3 years ago on Google
    Great place to get Italian food and the best pizza

  • 5/5 Alisha S. 3 years ago on Google
    My husband and I wanted to try a new pizza place. We were plesantly surprised with how close it is to NY pizza. We will definitely order from here again.

  • 5/5 Brooke 4 years ago on Google
    Great food and super nice employees

  • 5/5 Christopher L. 4 years ago on Google
    Classic pizza haunt - especially for lunch

  • 5/5 Mike M. 4 years ago on Google
    This place is the best place in town I come from New Jersey and this is the closest place to pizza taste in a way it does back home in the state it's phenomenal everything on the menu is good to people that work there are nice real just nice atmosphere Expresly good place to spend an evening I give it 3 thumbs up because it's so good I Eat their weekly

  • 5/5 Beth H. 4 years ago on Google
    Great food and Great service! Super cute and interesting decor. We visited before a show at the Palace Theatre less than a block away. They were playing music from the show when we sat down! The hostess and wait staff was so friendly and helpful. The crust on the calzones and stromboli was amazing in both taste and texture. My daughter had the chicken Alfredo pasta and loved it. My favorite thing was the meatball appetizer. Next time I will get that as my meal!


Open on Google Maps

Amenities


  • Payments
    • ✓️ NFC mobile payments
  • Offerings
    • ✓️ Beer
    • ✓️ Wine
    • ✓️ Alcohol
    • ✓️ Cocktails
    • ✓️ Happy-hour drinks
  • Dining options
    • ✓️ Lunch
    • ✓️ Dinner
    • ✓️ Seating
  • Service options
    • ✓️ Dine-in
    • ✓️ Delivery
    • ✓️ Takeaway
    • ✓️ No-contact delivery

Trends



Last updated:

Similar Restaurants nearby

Easton Town Center image
1
Easton Town Center
Shopping mall
Sprawling venue with lots of shops & restaurants, plus a theater, outdoor concerts & holiday events.
4.50 (23.5K reviews)
Schmidt’s Sausage Haus image
2
Schmidt’s Sausage Haus
German restaurant
Unpretentious, long-running German eatery in a historic livery stable with live oompah music.
$$ $$
4.70 (10.3K reviews)
The Spaghetti Warehouse image
3
The Spaghetti Warehouse
Italian restaurant
Pasta is the specialty of this casual Italian chain with a family-friendly vibe.
$$ $$
4.20 (6.6K reviews)
The National Infantry Museum image
4
The National Infantry Museum
Army museum
👍👍 One of the most impressive museums dedicated to the Infantry and maneuver. Check out the poppy fields art exhibit; has a theater with IMAX, third in the state, restaurant is not yet reopened but it is nice. Amazing exhibits. Very proud to work for the military
4.90 (6.1K reviews)
The Thurman Cafe image
5
The Thurman Cafe
Hamburger restaurant
Bustling, rustic American haunt with oversized, toppings-loaded burgers & a full bar.
$$ $$
4.60 (5.8K reviews)
Last updated:
()