Best pizza around. I'm from NY and this is by far the closest pizza place around that reminds me of home! The staff is amazing. Everyone is extremely friendly!

Boy did we have a feast! The pizzas are huge and 5-6 people could easily have eaten off the appetizer and entree shown. The sauces and breads were flavorful and classic. This is comfort food for sure. Reheats well in the oven and for such authentic cuisine, a very reasonable price. Great for families, not for fitness lol

Not a horrible neighborhood, but certainly not the best either. I grabbed a slice and added pepperoni and banana peppers. The toppings were 75 cents each and the slice was $3, so a total of $4.50 for one slice wasn't too bad, but I feel like the first one should be free. The bottom ended up pretty burnt after being cooked twice and a good to-go container shouldn't cause a pizza slice to be bent.

Pizza is still good but it was unevenly cooked. They were obviously having issues as we got there at 4:30 on a Friday and it took 1.25 hours to get our food, one medium pizza. Only one other group eating in waiting on food. The pick up orders were also all waiting extra for their food. When we finally got our order it was the wrong size pizza. Barely got a sorry. I understand being understaffed but be more apologetic with you customers. We love the pizza but it will be a long time before we go back. If the pizza wasn't good we would definitely never go back.

The pizza here was delicious! The crust was crispy but the pizza itself was chewy and amazing. We got a large and boy was it large! The staff was friendly and the atmosphere was chill and cozy. I recommend this place for groups, families, kids, and people who love pizza. It was really good and I loved the toppings we got. We also got the bread and balsamic dip, a a basic bread and dip, and it was good! A great small neighborhood place.

We were welcomed so nicely, whole staff is sweet, funny and helpful. Pizza is amazing, we got the 20in and my husband was in heaven. The crust is buttery, pieces are huge and the toppings are fresh. The owner Roz is so sweet, checked in on us many times and introduced himself and had a nice chat. It is a very welcoming and yummy experience.

Borgata’s has THE best sausage stuffed cubanelle peppers in the city! Served with a spicy marinara and melted cheese. Mmmmm… The crusty Italian bread makes this a delightful meal or appetizer to share. The homemade pastas are huge and pizzas are so good, too. Try them out!

Best gluten free pizza I’ve ever had - and I’ve had a lot. Best is that after eating here three separate times, I’ve never been sick. I will say, the ambiance is lacking. But the GF pizza is too good.

Sooo good!! We have been on the hunt for the best pizza and so far Borgata's takes the pie! They also have pretty good gluten free crust which can be tough to find. The staff is not the friendliest and it's about a 20min drive to them but it's worth it when you've got a hankering for something better than donatos. We did try the pesto pizza and honestly the flavor wasn't there for us. Pretty bland but the pizza dough was still tasty and now we know not to order that again lol We tried the white pizza and while it had mild flavor it was delicious! Definitely recommend them to others looking for a classic pizza slice!

You may have a little trouble finding this place but the food is absolutely worth it. My family and I ordered the garlic cheese bread, buffalo wings, and two pepperoni pizzas. Everything was excellent! The layout is open with a view into the kitchen so you're able to watch your pizza being made while you wait. The pizza is made with quality ingredients and it shows. 👍🏻 Sidenote: They're wheelchair accessible and they have highchairs.

It's an ok pizza. It's by far one of the best NY stlye pizza around as described by other reviewers. It looks really good but lacks something. The cheese is super salty and the crust under cooked in the center. I'll give it the overnight in the fridge/ reheat in the toaster over test,but I'm not sure it's worth another shot after this. But pizza is sometimes good even when it's bad.

First and foremost, the food is always awesome. 5 star food. 2 stars because they won't serve you without a mask. Vaxxed? Doesn't matter. If you love good food, go here, but I won't be giving them business until their mask policy gets lifted. 2 weeks to stop the spread, 2 years later. Done with supporting businesses that continue to uphold this nonesense.

Forgot to take a picture because we were hungry and everything was so delicious! We went earlier this week and were greeted by the owner/chef who was incredibly friendly and welcoming. He made us feel comfortable and answered every question we had about the food (the chicken wings were top notch, cooked and spiced perfectly- didn't even need the sauce on the side). I always love a good NY style pizza and the pizza we got with extra cheese, mushrooms, and pepperoni was exceptional. The sauce, made in-house, was superb and the overall experience was very warm. The restaurant was clean, comfortable, and the personal engagement was a welcome touch. I look forward to going back and trying so many other dishes on the menu.

It was good. It reminded me of pizzas east/northeast of Central Ohio. The toppings were tasty and the canned mushrooms were good as well as the cheese. It was cooked perfectly and browned evenly. Had they reminded me about the dessert cannoli while cashing out out I probably would have tried that. The staff is friendly and the open kitchen concept is always nice. Not my personal favorite style but they did it as well as I have seen it and I can easily see others rating this place higher.

we arrived around 5pm, not too busy we sat and were greeted by our waitress, who was super friendly by the way. we ordered a couple of drafts and some wings, half a beer later the wings came to us and we were pleasantly surprised at our order. these wings are super great, large and tender, we’ll be back for sure.

Delish as always! You just can't get crust like that anywhere else! Meatball sub was ginormous and amazing, all rolled into one.

This place is amazing! The food was fantastic! Everything was perfectly seasoned. The staff was wonderful, seemed like everyone there loved their job. Might be considered pricey to some but it is well worth the money. If we had known the subs were as big as they were, we would not have gotten an appetizer.

Pizza in Columbus is so hit and miss. If you don’t care for the square cut round pizza thing, you really don’t have many options. Borgata delivers what I think is probably the best pizza in Columbus. Dough is really well made, sauce perfectly applied, ovens hot enough so you get real yeast bubbles on the pie after it comes out. Just a great product by people who know what they are doing. Great job Borgata, thanks for giving me pizza hope in Columbus!

Ordered a Margherita from here, it was the saddest looking pizza I had ever seen. The photos attached are after I had to grate my own cheese on it to make it something other than just baked dough. There's basically no sauce on it, the rest of the toppings are very slim. I don't know if you were just having a bad day because honestly the dough is good and the other photos posted here look tasty. But what I received is not worth the 23 dollars I wasted tonight.