The best jeweler around! They helped my fiance find the perfect ring and later helped both of us find stunning bands. They excel in customer service and are phenomenal people to work with. I could not recommend them enough!

Always friendly and helpful. First came to this jeweler about 6 months ago for an appraisal and have been coming back for other needs and purchases as they are timely, reasonably priced and offer good service. Their jewelry is lovely! Plus, we like to support local and family-owned businesses like this one.

My family has been going to Edward Warren Jewelers for generations. My first experience purchasing a gold chain and crucifix pendent was so easy. I was able to describe exactly what I wanted & he made it happen! I’m so beyond impressed with the process and will continue to follow in my family’s tradition of using this jeweler!

We love Edward Warren’s jewelry!! This is where I got my engagement ring (along with other jewelry), and it is still sooo perfect. Great, friendly service every time. I highly recommend!!

My daughter found a stone that looked like a Diamond so we took it in to find out if it was real (turned out to be CZ). Anyway, we showed up two minutes before closing and the gemologist checked it out. He was extremely knowledgeable and friendly. He showed the kids how to tell it was fake under magnification and gave them a little lesson about diamonds. Then, as we were leaving, he game them a little opal and a blue sapphire. I was impressed with the time and attention he gave us when we weren’t in there to buy anything. The next time I’m shopping for jewelry, this is the first place I’m going. Thanks for giving my kids such a positive experience especially since they were disappointed in not finding a real Diamond.

I have been going to Edward Warren Jewelers for years and they just keep delivering! Recently had multiple pieces repaired, appraised and redesigned and I’m in LOVE with everything. The whole team always gives the best service and attention to detail. They turned my recent redesign around so fast so that I was able to wear my mother’s jewelry at her funeral - so thoughtful and caring! They understood how much it would mean to me. I will keep coming back, again and again. Thank you Cory & Warren and the team for always being the best of the best!

Cory and the team are amazing! They took great care of making our custom engagement ring using family diamonds. Very professional in every step of the process and communicates any updates to the customer. A great family business and our favorite for all jewelry needs!

Buying a ring is one of the truly scariest financial things I've ever done in my life and Cory and his dad made it really insightful, fun and interesting. Instead of feeling like I was just another customer, Cory texted me throughout the weeks we were working together, he made sure that I was involved in every aspect and now my girl is going to be wearing something that I had a hand in creating, forever. That's such a cool feeling that I didn't even know was possible. Not only are they a much, much better service than buying online, or going to the mall or big chain store...they truly care about you. I will never go anywhere else for anything jewelry related, even if I move out of state.

I had an idea for me and my husband’s wedding bands but was struggling to find quality pre-made options that fit my vision. We decided that going the custom route was probably best and ultimately decided on Edward Warren as the best option for us. Corey was a delight to work with and helped me fine tune my vision which was difficult for me to articulate. During the process we received 3D renderings of the designs for both rings before being asked to make a payment which gave us peace of mind that we were committing to rings that we actually loved. Corey explained the entire process in detail and communicated well with us during the different stages of production. I’m so grateful that we chose Edward Warren. Making the rings was a wonderful creative outlet, and my husband and I both feel they’re the perfect representation of our marriage. We’ve been married for a few months now and we’ve not only gotten so many huge compliments but we’re also still in awe of our rings when we look at them.

I bought my wife’s engagement ring while we were residents in Ohio and it was an amazing experience. Nothing like buying from a family owned business and having a great customer experience. We since have moved to Florida and needed to buy a wedding band. The process, even though being in a different state, was just as smooth! They were communicative and were able to show pictures and descriptions while not being physically there. I received exactly what we discussed and the ring size was perfect! It has been a great experience and I will continue to buy jewelry from this family for future anniversaries!

EWJ recently repaired two markers on a high end Tag Heuer watch. The staff was nothing but kind and professional during the entire process. The watch was repair was reasonably priced and completed in a timely manner. Can't thank you enough for the wonderful trustworthy service. A big thank you to Edward Warren Jewelers!

This jeweler is trustworthy, professional, and they treat you like family. They have a very nice selection and catalog of jewelry. We go here for all of our fine jewelry needs and repairs. If you are looking for a good jeweler in the Pickerington area, go to Edward Warren Jewelers today. You won't be disappointed.

A family ran business who treat you like family too. I have been a customer of Edward Warren's for the last decade and knew they would be my first choice to find wedding bands for my future husband and myself. It's always a pleasure to shop there.

I had a Tiffany bracelet that needed repaired. They were so reasonable than sending it to Tiffany. It looks amazing too. Very pleased with how it turned out.

Cory was personable, accommodating, and genuine. He had all of the characteristics you’d when trusting someone with a meaningful purchase. Their prices are fair, and he recognized and appreciated our budget to help us find exactly what we were looking for!

Absolutely impeccable service with the highest quality custom jewelry available. This was my third time trusting Warren with an extremely important purchase for my wife. He came through in a big way. I always feel important when I’m working with him, receiving his full attention. The ring I purchase from him literally brought my wife to tears. She couldn’t be happier, which means I couldn’t be happier. Thanks for all that you do at Edward Warren Jewlers. I will always come to you for exquisite jewelry for the ones I love.

My fiancé and I are absolutely thrilled with our experience buying our wedding bands here. The selection was great at all price ranges, and the jeweler took the time to understand what exactly we were looking for and our timeline. He showed us all options and made recommendations on what looked good, but didn’t try to upsell us into something that felt uncomfortable or out of our price range. We ended up with great wedding bands and a plan for custom piece down the line. We will absolutely be back, and recommend Edward Warren to anyone looking for jewelry!

They did an amazing job with my fiancé’s beautiful engagement ring. The stones were reset into a new band that turned out exactly as promised. We’re getting our wedding bands with Edward Warren Jewelers and will definitely be back in the future!

My Fiancé and I bought our engagement and wedding rings from Edward Warren Jewelers and the process was easy and relaxing. You will find knowledgeable, friendly staff to guide you through the process. Considering engagement and wedding rings are among the largest purchases of your life this is important to have. There is only one place to shop for fine jewelry in Central Ohio and it’s at Edward Warren Jewelers.

They were fabulous. . Had a custom ring and band made of my moms jewelry she left me. They are upfront & honest. Family business. Really great experience. I would highly recommend them too anyone. So opposite of walking into other jewelry store experiences. .

Edward Warren Jewelers was amazing! The staff was so friendly and took amazing care of us. My fiance and I picked out my engagement ring here and our wedding bands here and I'm in love with our choices. They have so many options and every piece of jewelry is beautiful! I couldn't imagine a better buying experience. I would highly recommend them to any couple considering an engagement or even an anniversary gift!

My experience with Edward Warren has been nothing short of excellence. Cory helped design my wedding band as well as putting together a matching set for my wife. Their entire staff gives you a welcoming feel that never makes you feel pressured or rushed to buy anything. They have a great selection in store but if you don’t see something there, they will find what your looking for. Maybe something better. Definitely recommend. You won’t be disappointed.

We went to Edward Warren Jewelers to get one of my old rings fix. It had to have new prong's put on. As it was soon to be our 50th wedding anniversary we looked at a new ring for my husband. He found one he liked they were very helpful with sizing and ordering. As we were out of town when it came in they even sent a couple of pictures. Great customer service.

It was truly an amazing experience. Cory spent the time to assist my wife in picking out the perfect ring. He threw a free battery in for my watch which they were the only place that had the right tool to get the job done. I will bring all my stuff to them from now on and will make sure to tell everyone I know.

Every step that my fiancé and I took with Cory and Warren could not have been more simple and as smooth as possible. Their friendly welcoming and professionalism was second to none. We were recommended by multiple people to visit here and we will always do the same for anyone in the future. If there is something that you want and they don't have it, they are able to accommodate anything and make exactly what you are looking for. Edward Warren will always be our first recommendation for anything jewelry related. Thank you again!

Edward Warren Jewelers is always a great experience. My family has been shopping here for years and is always very pleased. My fiancé and I recently purchased our wedding bands and the customer service was great. The employees are helpful, update you along the entire process, and willing to offer suggestions to make sure your jewelry is exactly the way you want it. Highly recommend!

Cory was great in helping me pick out the best diamond for an engagement ring! Easy to chat with and when I reached out to see if the band was in stock, they were quick to respond and I had the ring within two days. I’d definitely recommend Edward Warren!

Went in to get help finding our sizes for custom rings we were ordering, Cory was super friendly and happy to help even knowing we weren't buying that day. He showed us an incredible selection of unique custom pieces and stones that could only be picked out by such a trained eye. We will continue to come back for any and all our needs and love that there's a local family business around that cares!

Cory and everyone at Edward Warren Jewelers have been amazing from start to finish! They've worked with my fiance and I every step of the way as we navigated engagement rings and wedding bands. They've been patient while we figure out what we want and their prices haven't felt outrageous by any means. I'd recommend them to anyone in the Columbus area.

Cannot recommend enough. Huge variety and genuinely good people. We worked with Cory for !ll engagement and band needs. He was so friendly, saw I was overwhelmed with the selection and was patient and gave variety and recommendations. So excited for us and wanted to find us our perfect rings, not just highest price or what he wanted but listened and supported us!

My entire family have been customers of Edward Warren Jewelers for more than 30 years. They are honest and and trustworthy (truly!), and provide great value and selection for every budget. We wouldn't buy jewelry anywhere else!

I recommended EW to others before ever purchasing anything here - that’s how reputable they are! Only speaking from my experience, I had my engagement ring and wrap soldered together. My husband and I discussed a wedding band upgrade and I’d be eyeing EW’s selection for a while. We went in and they unsoldered my old ring, polished up my engagement ring and were so supportive in picking out a new wedding band. I got more than I could’ve dreamt up for an awesome price and my new set looks phenomenal. EW communicates well and makes it simple. I would recommend anyone to Edward Warren because of the personal touches they provide, how personable the people are, and how confident I am that they work to provide the best options and overall experience for their customers.

I grew up in Pickerington and am getting married next week! Corey remembered EXACTLY the diamond I wanted for my fiance over a year later. He had 3 diamonds lined up and ready to go. They remember my name every time I go in there AND are incredibly easy to work with. They had the perfect wedding band for my fiance as well, and just got my best man a necklace from them too! I will do business with them forever because of the family oriented nature of how they operate. Thanks guys!

Edward Warren jewelers quickly welcomed us when we arrived and asked what brought us in. We needed a repair on a chain purchased elsewhere. They inspected the chain and identified additional areas that were weak and were able to repair while we waited for a VERY reasonable price. I definitely will be back to purchase something from their beautiful selection.

Jeanie was very helpful in picking out my engagement ring. Selection was great and all of the rings were gorgeous. I'm very thrilled with my ring

I went in today to have a necklace clasp fixed. The customer service was amazing and they were able to fix it right in front of me without an appointment. At no cost because I brought my own clasp. They have a great selection in the store, and my family has used them for jewelry in the past and every piece has been phenomenal. This place is great!

Somehow My wedding band had become oval shaped instead of round. Not only were they able to straighten it, but they re-dipped it in a rhodium finish and the 10 karat white gold shines like platinum now. I would highly recommend this jeweler for any type of jewelry repair.

Purchased my fiancés engagement ring here last year, so naturally returned to do our wedding band shopping today. Corey was very knowledgeable and courteous throughout the process. He helped us decide what we really wanted and what would look best together. Then he gave us a pretty nice discount on top of it all. I ended up buying some extra jewelry I hadn’t even planned on because of the great service.

I had the greatest experience with Warren when bringing my grandmother’s heirloom engagement ring in to be resized for my daughter. Warren was an absolute delight; friendly, positive and a great listener. When I returned in less than a week to pick up the ring and an appraisal, I was overwhelmed with happiness. The ring was incredibly beautiful and looked brand new. It far exceeded my expectations. Gratitude is the inward feeling of kindness received. Thank you Warren for your kindness and taking such great care of us. Looking forward to seeing the wedding bands picked out and designed at your store.

This was my first time at Edward Warren Jewelers and I have nothing but great things to say about my experience. The price and customer service was amazing! My husband and I went on our anniversary and picked out a new setting for my engagement ring. The settings on the website are beautiful but more so in person. I was able to try on so many settings and found the perfect one. I can’t wait to pick it up when it is set and sized. I know when I want new jewelry I will be back!

Excellent experience. I was greeted when I walked in even though they were taking care of another customer. Very friendly service, listened too what I was looking for and helped me find the perfect jewelry that met my needs. I highly recommend and will be going back for future purchases. Keep up the great work!

Edward Warren always knocks it out of the park! My fiancée and I have been exclusively using them for all jewelry needs for years and have always been satisfied with the quality/quantity of products and services available. Excellent customer service - they remember their customers and make all of your service needs smooth and easy. Highly recommend!

Went there last week on Friday 12/30/2022 to drop off my wife’s wedding ring for repairs. The overall atmosphere was nice, and the displays were organized and tasteful. The man behind the counter however was giving less than stellar customer service. For starters he made it clear to us that we couldn’t re-coat the bottom of the ring…SEVERAL TIMES OVER. We understood that the ring was brass coated in silver, and that they didn’t have the facilities nor the materials to re-coat it. We heard you the first 4 times you had said it. The actual repairs we cared about on the ring were the replacing of 3 small synthetic ‘diamonds’ at the tail end of the pattern that had fallen off. We were well aware that they’re fake, but made it clear that the ring has sentimental value, and that we just wanted them replaced. We were told that that was doable and that they would order new synthetics to replace the ones that had fallen out. What we got was what you see in the photo below. I honestly can’t tell if it’s the poor luster of the new synthetics, or if it’s too much glue that was used in adhering them. We weren’t expecting a miracle or anything over the top, but this is just poor craftsmanship and poor attention to detail.

Edward Warren Jewelers is the only place that I shop for jewelry. My diamond engagement ring is beautiful! They special ordered a platinum band for my fiancé and it’s fabulous. I went back to order a gold gents bracelet for my fiancé to celebrate him finishing 7 weeks of radiation therapy and being cancer free. Jeanie worked with me to find exactly what I was looking for . I can’t wait to have her help me choose a wedding band next year!

Amazing experience. From the time I walked in the door the customer service and knowledge of staff was phenomenal! Cory went above and beyond to help me build a high quality custom piece of jewelry! Very prompt and professional! Will be a lifetime customer!

Really helpful. Straightforward. Not pushy.

Corey is great & they have have a beautiful selection of jewelry. He helped me find exactly what I wanted & it was so nice to work with someone so friendly & kind.

Love this place, no matter what I want to do they make it happen, and at the best price. Can’t beat working with a family owned business, because that’s exactly how you’ll be treated. Wouldn’t go anywhere else for jewelry needs.

The staff was super friendly and very very reasonable. I would highly recommend coming here for all your jewelry needs

Great experience! Helpful and friendly staff made shopping a pleasure.

Thank you to the entire staff of EWJ for making our Holiday Season so special by getting my Fiancé’s ring resized just in time. We are excited to continue the wedding band shopping experience with them and for many other occasions in the future. We know that any future customers will be just as happy as we are when they start shopping with EWJ.

I’ve been a customer of Edward Warren Jeweler for a long time. I will never buy jewelry anywhere else. They have a very friendly and knowledgeable staff. If you want quality jewelry at a fair price then I highly recommend Edward Warren Jewelers.

My first time here and I found just the ring I was hoping for! Super nice place, great service, good value.

Wonderful experience. I would highly recommend this jeweler.

We chose Edward Warren Jewelers to purchase my engagement! I had worked with Cory in the past to fix/replace batteries in my fiancé’s watch collection. Cory is very knowledgeable when it comes to jewelry. He truly listens to what you want and will continue to work with you until your satisfied. Cory truly made our ring shopping easy, joyful, and exciting. I cannot WAIT to wear the beautiful ring!

The Edward Warren team was amazing! Could not ask for a better experience buying an engagement ring.

This is one of our favorite jewelry places in all of Columbus. All of the staff are super friendly and have the most knowledge that I’ve experienced. Their prices are better than most and they stand by their work 100%. We brought in a couple of necklaces for repair and the prices were very fair for the work that needed to be done. This is definitely the place to go if you are looking for something nice for anyone. Rings, necklaces, custom made jewelry, and unique pieces are all over the store. You won’t be disappointed with a visit!

Cory is amazing at what does. He works with you to find the perfect fit for you and truly makes the experience so laid back. We referred multiple friends to him after our experience and all rave about the customer service! -Jonny and Maranda

Beautiful jewelry and great customer service. I drove 40 mins to see a necklace they had custom made and advertised on their website. No pressure. No price games. Awesome quality. I bought it with little thought. Highly recommended business!

We used Edwards to identify quality of and to repair or resize heirloom jewelry. The work was not done on site but was completed promptly. Very helpful staff. They are conveniently located to me but I did not do any sort of price comparison before I had them do work for me. I will be using them again.

Nice clean store. Jeanie was very helpful and cleaned my jewelry while i looked at the jewelry case. She also put a new battery in my watch.

Highly recommend Edward Warren Jewelers. Coming into the engagement ring process, I really had no idea what I was doing. Cory and family helped me every step of the way and made this process a truly fun and educational experience! I couldn't have been happier with the results and my fiance absolutely loved the ring. If you want to impress, definitely check them out! Great prices and excellent customer service - will be a life long customer.

I absolutely love my Ohio State Block O pendant I ordered. I looked online for weeks and finally came across your jewelry website. 5 stars! I tried to add a picture of my pendant to show it off but it wont load. Kudos to Edward Warren Jewelers!

Chose to visit this place based on the reviews and the fact that this is a family owed business... Best decision I have ever made! I came with my friend to get ideas of what I liked in an engagement ring to steer my boyfriend in the right direction. There was an older woman working who literally looked me up and down before deciding if she wanted to greet me... Would not recommend her. HOWEVER, Cory more than double made up for her rudeness. He was very personable and took the time to show me different colors, styles, shapes, etc and explained things without making me feel dumb... All while knowing that we would not be making purchase this day. My boyfriend will definitely be returning here for our rings!! Cory even offered to clean my friends ring for free. Can you talk about great customer service. Even if I move, I will drive out of my way to come back here. So friendly and helpful. Prices are comparable.

I went to Edward Warren Jewelers to see if they might be able to check a couple stones in a pendant to determine if they were genuine. They were so nice and gracious to happily do it at no charge. I was so impressed with their expertise and generous service, that I also asked about work I would like to have done on my wedding ring set. They said they could help, and I will definitely be back. A wonderful experience!

Great Experience. Highly recommended for all your jewelry needs. Wonderful staff and ownership will keep me coming back for years. 5 stars all the way!

Corey is friendly, professional, and eager to help.

My ring looks great now. This company treats you more like family than a customer. They listen to your needs and give you recommendations on how they can help fix them at a great price. Unlike other well known jewelers I visited about repairing my wedding ring that the diamond fell out were more interested in selling a replacement ring than repairing it by giving a high estimate and a long return period.

Couldn’t thank Edward Warren Jewelers enough for all they’ve done helping make my engagement and wedding day wonderful! Affordable, honest, and always welcoming every time I visit, my fiancé and I decided to go get our wedding bands there as that was where he got my engagement ring. Their selection for both male and female was fantastic! Jeannie made my process so easy! Support local! You won’t regret going here for all your wedding needs, or anything else!

Had a great experience shopping here. The staff was very friendly and helped us every step of the way. I like that they do the work locally and don’t send the jewelry off to another city like most stores. Happy to support local businesses.

Edward Warren Jeweler's has exceeded my expectations every time I've needed them. They were able to size my Fiance's ring and help me pick out a ring in time for the big day. They are very pleasant to work with and seem genuinely interested in providing excellent customer service which seems in short supply these days. Their prices are reasonable and if you want an experience with personal touch you should definitely check them out.

Great experience with very friendly and helpful staff. I was educated during my visit! I strongly recommend this jeweler.

They were great! Friendly and fast! I got two rings resized and appraised that were my grandmothers. I plan to go bqck and eventually got something custom made with the stones.

A great jeweler that gave us wonderful personalized service. We wanted to upgrade our rings for our 1 year anniversary but we only had a slight idea of what we wanted. Jeanie was so great, she really worked with us and turned a ‘lose idea’ into the ring I have always wanted, along with one my husband loved. We both highly recommended.

Corey was such a big help with assisting me in the right direction. Definitely recommend great costumer service.

My 1st visit to Edward Warren Jewelers based on recommendations from social media. I took a load of jewelry to be sorted, assessed, and valued. The lady that helped me was very generous with her time and provided a wealth of information with what I had. Her valuation was fair and competitive. Everyone was welcoming and professional. I plan to make this establishment my "go to" for future jewelry needs...and wants.😉

I recently came to Edward Warren Jewelers in order to have a Diamond engagement ring resized and appraised. Upon entering, I was met by a woman who explained their services, fees and the like. As she inspected the ring itself she stopped without making eye contact, and with slight exasperation asked, “So you know these stones aren’t real, right?”. When I expressed that they were actually diamonds according to the original receipt/appraisal she re-examined the stones using a loupe and handheld diamond tester (out of my view). She clarified that the center diamond was, in fact, a diamond but that the rest were moissanite because “they just don’t look right, you know?”. I found that hard to believe considering the ring was purchased prior to the commercial availability of moissanite and had never been worked on post-purchase. So I kindly asked for my ring back and took it to a reputable jeweler who used significantly more measures to discern if any or all of the diamonds were real (without knowing my experience at this location), and also conducted the procedures to resize and appraise it. It turns out to be completely real in contrast to her determination. So that leaves me frustrated because I could have left my ring with this jeweler who either knew they were real, but for one reason or another told me they were fake (which I decline to elaborate on), or lacked quality discernment causing her to mistake them for moissanite. It might not happen to everyone, and others may have a great experience, but I sure won’t be coming back.

We loved working with Jeanie and the team at Edward Warren! It’s such a big decision, and she made sure to listen to what I thought I wanted, and then help us find the perfect ring. Jeanie was knowledgeable about all kinds of styles, metals, and diamond quality, which was so reassuring to know during the process. Thank you so much!!

Ed Warren Jewelers provides the highest quality, personalization and unique designs in all of his jewelry. Warren and his team focus on customer service and affordability. We have been customers of Ed Warren Jewelers over fifteen years. Thank You Warren !!

I went in on recommendation by friends. The staff was amazing and so helpful. I got my ring done in great time and so happy. I will be returning!

Amazing experience, talented team, great customer service. 5 stars.

Corey is so helpful and gives such great service! He ordered the bands I wanted and let me know as soon as they came in. I am so happy I found my perfect band! I will be back and refer all my friends and family here!

The staff was extremely knowledgeable and knew exactly what it was I needed. They repaired my wife’s ring and it looks better than the day I bought it! First time working with Edward Warren and I’ll be back!

Prompt and professional. Repeat customer 👍🏻

Came in for some jewelry repair, cleaning and to buy a new silver chain.

I took my vintage 1930’s engagement ring to Ed Warren Jewelers to have my wedding band’s soldered to it. Prior to my experience with them I had a hard time getting my ring and bands to go together exactly how we wanted them to look. I couldn’t be more pleased with the finish and work that they did. And it was done in the time promised. Thank you so much!

I have taken 2 pieces of jewelry to be repaired to Edward Warren. Everyone was so gracious and helpful. They treated me as a valuable client even though I was just having repairs done. Definitely will be back for any jewelry needs I would have in the future!

Thank you to Edward Warren Jewelers for making beautiful custom necklaces for my sons. Excellent service, I highly recommend Edward Warren Jewelers! We couldn’t be any happier with the amazing results! We truly appreciate all of your help with transforming something old into something new ❤️

Jeanie & all of the employees at Edward Warren were fantastic when searching for and finally creating my own wedding band using my mothers diamonds. Jeanie also helped us create a necklace for my mother and helped us find my husbands wedding band. They were kind, thorough and so knowledgeable! We will definitely be back to them for any of our jewelry needs.

Edward Warren has taken a couple of my hairbrained ideas and turned them into exquisite works of custom jewelry art. Their collection of jewelry is by far the best in the Columbus area whether you are looking for something timeless and classic or unique and modern. But honestly, what truly sets them apart are the people. From the time you walk in you are treated like family. Love love, love them. Save yourself time and disappointment and just go.

Warren Jewelers is a little “gem” in the heart of Pickerington and I always look forward to visiting their lovely store. I am always greeted and engaged in a warm friendly conversation…and of course they have beautiful, unique jewelry! Great customer service! Check them out!