We went in yesterday and were quoted by an employee, were told to check around and come back tomorrow and he would honor his quote. Needless to say that didn't happen. They offered over $100 less and refused to honor the price even after confirming what the previous gentleman had said. Be weary of this sketchy business.

Best experience one can have when looking for a fair and honest business. Most people frown at Jewelry stores; thinking that they're going to rip them off "somehow", such is not the case with Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry. Dominic was not only fair but extremely knowledgeable and helpful throughout the entire inspection and value of my items. I highly recommend Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry to anyone whom is seeking assistance with selling and/or purchasing from this establishment. If you want to SELL your personal valuables...Sell them to this honest establishment and NOT a pawn shop. You can rest assured that you've made the best decision and you won't be "taken for a ride". Dominic, you were outstanding and I'd like to thank you very much for your time and assistance! YOU ROCK!!!

High praise to Steve, Greg & Jason at/with Buckeye Gold. My experiences at the former Hilliard store & at the Dublin shop gave me confidence & peace of mind thanks to their honesty & depth of knowledge. I look forward to my next visit here soon & I highly recommend my favorite store, the Sawmill branch. Steve runs the show & he leads by example. We talked about life & had the most pleasant interaction while doing business. Talk about gaining an already loyal customer for the long haul. I really appreciate the guidance I received & the transparency. I even learned there is a diamond specialist I could meet via Steve, so I'm enthusiastic about my next return. Maybe I'll call ahead for the first time ever. The whole visit & experience is never rushed & never too lengthy; it's really an efficient & one-of-a-kind place. Many Thanks, Steve & Company!

Steve was so personable, and super friendly! I thought I was throwing away trash jewelry, but thought I should stop by and check beforehand. It turns out I was throwing away money! His store is also full of cool coins if you have a collector in the family! I'm gong to have my husband bring our son back when Steve's here to purchase some found! Thanks Steve for the great experience!

Wonderful customer service! If you want to sell unwanted coins, you should go to Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry. Steve was very patient, and provided great advice. Go there, you will not be disappointed. They are genuine and honest.

Best gold & coin shop in Columbus! Michael is wonderful to talk with and always help me pick out some neat coins. Would highly recommend to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Columbus area!

Thank you Dominic! All my experiences have been enjoyable and I have recommended the Buckeye Gold store to friends who have also had a positive experience. I have worked with Dominic at the Sawmill Rd store a few times and can tell you he is a man of integrity and knows this industry extremely well. This is an excellent place to sell gold, silver, coins and estate jewelry. I have been satisfied with the payouts and they are quick, fair and knowledgeable. Yes.. I received more $ than a jewelry store down the street offered.

I went in the store recently looking for some small pearl earrings. I spoke with Dominic who was very helpful and knowledgeable about the items i was interested in and was able to help me find exactly what i was looking for. I would recommend Dominic and Buckeye Gold to anyone.

I had been driving to the Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky area to get the best prices for my gold and jewelry. I had business nearby and brought some items to the Grove City store. Absolute top dollar offered and accepted. Mark, the store manager, is an outstanding professional; nothing doubtful about this operation. This will be a go-to resource for me. Thank you, Mark, for topping off a great day in the Columbus area!

Very nice and knowledgeable. 5 stars

Great experience! I met with Dominic to sell a gold chain and look at some of the rings in the store as well as the rare currency. Dominic was very knowledgable about every item i viewed. I would recommend him and buckeye gold to anyone.

Great Experience, Dominic was extremely friendly, and knowlegable of the coins he was selling. I also bought my girlfriend ear rings for her birthday, and he took the time to package, and prepare then in a very presentable way. All around great service, and will be back for sure.

I would like to say the Dublin location is by far my favorite and Dominic at this location is very knowledgeable and easy to due business with. Highly suggest you go see him best place in Columbus to get coins or bullion and also cash in your unwanted coins and bullion.

A fantastic experience! Dominic was super helpful in the identification of some of my foreign coins and was very knowledgeable about their corresponding values! I would highly recommend Buckeye Gold for any coin need you may have.

I had the pleasure of working with Steve Fagin. Steve is good vibes and seemed trustworthy and genuine. I would recommend Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry to anyone needing these services.

I was referred to the Dublin office to speak with Dominic about some numismatic items that I was interested in selling, and he did not disappoint. He was very informative, courteous and offered very fair rates for the items I was interested in selling. I will gladly refer anyone to this office if they are looking to sell their coins.

Had an awesome first time experience selling my old jewelry today! Dominic was very courteous, knowledgeable and made the process very quick and painless. I highly recommend and will be back with anything else in the future!

Best gold buying business in cbus! Mike has helped me over the last year selling my mother's items for her estate. Wouldn't put my trust in anyone else but Buckeye and they are amazing to work with. Will forsure be back to visit in the future!

I believe it was Mike and Jason who helped me today. I sold a platinum diamond wedding ring and was surprised that I got so much. I had recently sold two gold diamond rings somewhere else and didn’t get much. If I ever gave any any jewelry or coins I’ll take them to these guys. The whole process only took like ten minutes. Thanks again!

Stopped in today. Jason was fast and efficient. Gave me a very good price. Everything you hear about this place is true. If I've got any more gold or silver I will be definitely bringing it back to this place

The shop was really nice and the staff is really educated. Mike was very professional and helpful with the process since I didn't really know what I was doing. I would highly recommend to check them out and would work with Mike again.

Buckeye Gold is the best place to buy or sell gold and silver, along with any jewelry. Jason and Steve are the best people to work with, hands down! Thanks, Buckeye Gold!!!

Great place to sell and even expand your collection, whether it be silver, gold, or rare, collectible coins and currency. Mike is a pleasure to work with and goes above and beyond for his customers. I have been frequenting this location for a couple of years now and have had a positive experience every time. Prices are extremely fair and they buy at some of the highest rates I have seen around. You are in good hands here!

So knowledgeable and helpful throughout the entire buying process! Greg is the person to see here for all your needs & for whatever brings you into Buckeye Gold. I didn't end up selling my bracelet, but was informed with his to get the best price for it. I'm really appreciative of that!

Stopped in for a last minute precious metal themed white elephant gift, without any knowledge of coins at all. Dominick instantly walked through a few options within our price range, and we made our way out with a fun, unique gift. We'll be back!

These guys make it fast and easy to sell whatever you are looking to sell. They take the time to answer any and all questions you may have about the process. First time seller and I would 100% go back and also recommend. They offered over other quotes I got as well.

Visited the Dublin store with miscellaneous coins and other items. Michael was friendly, knowledgeable and explained all details regarding the sale of the items. I am not a coin collector but I felt confident that I had received the best price for my items. Highly recommend Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry.

Had a easy and comfortable sale with Anthony at the Sawmill Road location! Very knowledgeable and was in and out in less than 15 minutes!

I showed up today to the dublin location with low expectations due to experiences I’ve had with businesses in the past. I was nervous and worried that I would be taken advantage of. However I received the exact opposite experience. I had the pleasure of doing business with the owner Steve and If I could give him a 10 star review I would. Not only did he give me fair prices for the coins and jewelry I have, he also noticed the sentimental value that some coins had on me and refused to Buy them for that reason. Please bring your business here. Well worth the time. Thank you Steve!

Stopped in at Buckeye Gold in Dublin the other day and met with Dominic. He helped me pick out the perfect coin for a birthday present, which was great as I do not know much about rare coins. Very personable and knowledgable!

My sister and I had a great visit. James was very patient, explained how he valued our pieces and made everything understandable. Excellent customer experience. We’ll go back when we’re ready to sell.

Fantastic

I came into Buckeye Gold in Dublin today as I am preparing to move. I was amazed at how much money some of the stuff I had was worth. Dominic did a great job helping me and explaining each step of the process. I without a doubt will recommend Buckeye Gold to any of my friends looking to sell and coins or jewelry!

I went to several jewelers in town to sell some gold. I did not know those other jewelers were taking advantage of me until I went to Buckeye Jewelers! Dominic offered me top, fair market valve for my gold. The others quoted me hundreds of dollars less!! Dominic said they should have all offered me the same price as him because that’s the current market valve for the weight. Thanks again to Buckeye Gold and Dominic for running their business with integrity and professionalism. Those qualities will keep me coming back!! 👍

Dominic was extremely helpful and gave wonderful customer service! Helped me out a lot and gave me much better prices than any pawn shop I’ve ever been to!

The young man who waited on me was courteous and patient. Not a whole lot of negotiations on price and not a lot of high end coins outside of gold, but a nice well kept store with good inventory. I will go back if I am ever in the Columbus area again.

We went in with a variety of coins and silver pieces we had collected through the years. The folks at Buckeye Gold we very pleasant and professional The process of selling our pieces was very simple and fast Would recommend

Dom is extremely knowledgeable and helpful. Always friendly and can find what I'm looking for. He sees me coming and he'll bring out selections of coins he knows Ill want before I ask. Always a fair price and I always walk away happy and with a new bit of numismatic trivia facts that's hard to find elsewhere.

Dominic was extremely helpful 🤗 He was able to assist me with questions I had on a couple of coins. Very well mannered and knowledgeable...highly recommend seeing him!!

Awesome place! Dominic is incredibly informative, fair, and friendly and the only one I'll ever bring my stuff to. Highly recommend both Dominic and Buckeye Gold!!!

Great service, fair price, no games or anything like that. Very knowledgeable, great place overall

This place is awesome for purchasing precious metals. Dominic and Mike have been a pleasure to work with, and I will definitely return in the future to do more business with them. I highly recommend this location if you’re looking to strengthen your position in hard assets, or if you just enjoy collecting gold and silver.

We had a great experience with Dominic today. He help use with all of our needs. I would recommend any to go there that is selling gold or silver or in need of a nice piece of jewelry. Dominic Michael and Steve will take great care of you.

Great service; the guy took a lot of time introducing and explaining our interested kids to appropriate coins, and he was very honest and genuine.

I went to Buckeye Gold Coin to see if they were able to examine a pendant to confirm the karats it was advertised as. Steve was extremely helpful and quickly was able to determine the karats of the piece and weight for me. Having been so helpful and thorough in explaining everything despite me not making a purchase, I tried to give him some money but he refused to accept it. I'm super appreciative of Steve's knowledge and willingness to help and I would without a doubt recommend his store to anyone.

Awesome experience !! Super to work with, very informative and friendly ! I will be going back for sure ! Thanks for a great experience ! Highly recommend

I had a great experience with buckeye, Dominic was informative, friendly, and gave me a great price.

We have recently been to both the Hilliard and Dublin locations and received excellent service both visits. Knowledgeable, friendly and encouraging to our young coin collector. Already looking forward to our next visit.

John King did a fabulous job at the Gahanna location!

Mike has always been great to deal with! Bought my husband his anniversary gift here the last two years and they have a great selection of coins.

A great place to buy nice collector coins. Dominic keeps an eye out for items that per our discussions would interest me and be great additions to my collection. I highly recommend stopping in if you are a coin collector of any age.

Best gold shop in town! Always pay top dollar and have a some great people working for them. Recently Mike helped me with some items and I will gladly be back!

I had a great experience selling a gold Krugerrand with Dominic. The process was quick and his price was extremely fair! I will be back if I need to sell anything else.

Dominic did a wonderful job helping me sell some of my high karat jewelry. I would highly recommend Buckeye Gold for all your selling needs!

I have been to Buckeye Gold a couple of times, and have been extremely pleased every time. Dominic gave me great prices for my Pandora Charms & Bracelets and I would recommend seeing him and any of the great people who work at Buckeye Gold.

They don't give u enough money

Very pleased with my experience at the Graceland location, highly recommend! Educated professionals.

The young man that helped me was not nice or fair. He threw a few items back across the counter at me in a very disrespectful manner that were family heirlooms. Please don’t use this company or location.

great deals.

Steve helped me make a lifelong dream come true. He's a scholar and a gentleman. This business has my absolute endorsement.

Dominic is always willing to help and very personable

Nov 2021. We went to Buckeye Gold on Sawmill to sell a silver coffee set and some other items. Dominic and Mike were very easy to talk to and told us their process to buy gold and silver. Very informative. We were given a very good offer, in our opinion, and walked out with some extra cash. You will not fell pressured to sell. Highly recommended.

Anthony was so helpful and patient throughout the whole process! Highly recommend working with him!

Anthony DiMuzio was really helpful and extremely professional! I will definitely be back to see him!