Visitor Reviews

Top-rated.online cuts through the clutter, highlighting only the reviews that are most helpful, earn the most likes, or come from the most active contributors.

5/5
Claybrone W.
6 months ago on Google • 3 reviews

They are my favorite pizza place in town. The crust and breadsticks are great and they don't short you on toppings.

5/5
Becky H.
4 months ago on Google • 4 reviews

Omg I just had the most delicious burger from these guys. My work is doing a “burger week” and these guys were on the roster. Was a septic for a burger from a pizza place but this was outstanding! Will definitely be back and check out the rest of the menu. Well done guys!!

5/5
Cody T.
3 months ago on Google • 4 reviews
New

Have had Pizza By The Guy before burger week with a great experience each time. They are knit into the community and care about their customers. Their burger special from Burger Week was an awesome pizza-infusion!

5/5
Paul J.
2 years ago on Google • 4 reviews

We are long time customers of Pizza by the Guy, and are never disappointed with the pizza! These dirty sticks are some of the best bread sticks we've ever had, we had to take a picture

4/5
Chris C.
2 years ago on Google • 58 reviews

First time eating here and we were pleased. We had cheese sticks and chicken parmesan pizza. Very good crust on both and sauce had great flavor on chicken parmesan. Fast service. Would eat here again

5/5
Caleb B.
2 years ago on Google • 78 reviews

My absolute favorite pizza joint in the area and has been since I was a kid. They have alot of cool different kinds of pizza combinations. The classics are also done perfect. Love the Stromboli and hand tossed pies. The crust really is delicious and the toppings are of the same caliber.

5/5
Jason J.
7 months ago on Google • 269 reviews

This place is a hidden gem that I wish we had checked out sooner. We dined in on a Wednesday afternoon with kids and everything was great. We all got personal sized pizzas and an order of cheese sticks for the table. I loved my pesto based pie with chicken and roasted garlic. The owner was great as we were leaving. We'll definitely be coming back.

4/5
The Traveling M.
11 months ago on Google • 988 reviews

My first time here. I was passing through town and decided to try it. I ordered the Calzone and Breadsticks. I got so much food it was crazy, lol. The Calzone was so good definitely in my Top 5 since trying it. There were 8 Breadsticks in an order and they were huge and good, couldn't eat them all. My only complaint would be the small dining area only 4 tables, kinda cramped otherwise I recommend this place especially if you love Calzones.

Trends

See how the number of reviews and average review scores have changed over time.

Similar Restaurants nearby

Moonlite Bar-b-q Inn image
#1

Moonlite Bar-b-q Inn

Barbecue restaurant

Revered BBQ mainstay known for its smoked meats (including mutton), plus lunch & dinner buffets.

4.50 (3.8K reviews)
Texas Roadhouse image
#2

Texas Roadhouse

Steak house

Lively chain steakhouse serving American fare with a Southwestern spin amid Texas-themed decor.

4.40 (3.2K reviews)
McDonald's image
#3

McDonald's

Fast food restaurant

Classic, long-running fast-food chain known for its burgers & fries.

3.30 (1.8K reviews)
Ole South Barbeque image
#4

Ole South Barbeque

Barbecue restaurant

Laid-back locale offering simple Southern barbecue eats such as pulled pork & ribs, plus breakfast.

4.50 (1.5K reviews)
Last updated:
()