My family have always enjoyed their 5-Star pizza and food. Last night my son asked me if we could go there and get some pizza. So, I looked up their hours of operation on Google maps and it said they were open until 9pm. So, we drove there and arrived at 8:40pm. All the chairs were already stacked on the tables, so no seating was available. I asked if we could place a to-go order we could eat in the car. I was told, "No, our kitchen closes at 8:30!" I recommended and requested that they please update their open hours online since they are not open until 9pm. They are closed to dine-in and take-out orders at 8:30. We will return in the future for their 5-Star pizza and food, but last night that didn't happen. I contacted Google maps and requested the proper hours be listed. UPDATE (1-Month Later): Their hours of operation still show they are open until 9PM. But if you want to get carry-out or dine-in food, be sure to arrive before 8:30 or you will be turned away.

We live in Evergreen. Guido's is worth the travel for great new York style pizza! Friendly staff, they got it all here. We pick up since we are so far away but no more domino's!!!!

Very quiet vibe of a pizza place that we've been to. Nonetheless, the inside was clean, not super busy and the staff was friendly. Delicious pizza, the crust had a nice chew and flavor. Cannot go wrong with fresh ingredients and it being homemade 10/10 even the basil tasted garden fresh. Would return again next time we are in town visiting.

DO NOT get their “cheese bread”!!! This was the MOST BLAND “cheesy bread” anyone could ever possibly make!!! Watered down tasteless pesto carelessly splattered on bland bread, extremely bland chewy tough cheese!? Which I don’t know how you can mess up cheese. And my god, the worst watered down tasteless “marinara dipping sauce” I have ever tasted! I was so hungry and was on a quick lunch break from work. I scarfed a few pieces down super quick and instantly regretted it. From the moment it hit my stomach I had the sensation of NEEDING to puke and get it out of my stomach! I threw the rest away , and the remainder of the day I continued with that feeling of needing to puke that stuff up. Super disappointing as I use to go here growing up. I can not speak for the pizza but I REPEAT! DO NOT GET THEIR “CHEESE BREAD”

This place is always a go to for a small celebration or just a good pizza. The staff are amazing and helpful when you need something. Definitely the best pizza I have ever had.

Jersey native here. Stopped here to get gas and didn't expect much but the pizza ended up being some of the best NY style I've had in Colorado. Great price, large cheese pizza only 13.65$.

Delicious pizza, fresh and light , not greasy. Service was great too.

Family friendly. Great authentic pies, that are reasonably priced. I recommend you take the family there. Staff was slammed on a Sunday, and made it happen. Kudos!

Stopped on the way back to Denver after a hike in the mountains. Quick and friendly service in a welcoming atmosphere. We got The Boss pizza NY style and it was perfect. My husband is super picky about pizza and he loved it. Also, save room for the specialty ice cream, so rich and creamy!

A really great local pizza spot. The owners put their heart into the restaurant and it shows in the quality of the food and the service. The menu includes very good salads and gyros as well. Our family favorites are the Boss and Florence pizzas. Great combos made with super fresh ingredients.

Best pizza and service. Such a great hidden place! A must stop if you are driving through there.

Caught sight of this place after getting a tow off of I-70. Absolutely delicious NY style pizza. Superb crust with toasted & crunchy edges. Flavorful sauce and toppings cooked to perfection. I'll make the drive back again soon just for this 'Za.

Best authentic New York style pizza in Colorado. We are two east coasters who have lived in Genesee for years. Believe us when we say this pizza is THE best! The owners are the absolute greatest and we love how it’s a family affair.

This pizza shop was amazing! We came with a party of 9 and the service was quick and efficient, the staff is very friendly as well! The soda was crisp, the pizza was hot and fresh, and the rest of the food was amazing! Highly highly recommend eating here!

Wow. The pizza was okay but NOT what we ordered. We ordered a 16" New York Style pizza with 4 toppings, one of which was sun-dried tomatoes. What we got was a Sicilian style pizza (which was $6 more than the NY style pizza!) with regular tomatoes (NOT sun-dried). The other toppings were correct but still.... to mess up 2 out of the 5 items that were specified is not impressive.

First time there and got take out. Ordered the Philly cheese steak. 11.00 for this thing. It has to be the saddest cheese steak I have ever had. It's almost like Wendy's "Where's the beef??!?". And there is no cheese on it. The sandwich is also extremely small for the price. Look at the photos and see for yourself. Bread 1.00 at most. Onion and pepper maybe 50 cents. And if there is a bucks worth of steakum on this thing I would be surprised. That's one heck of a profit at over a 400 percent markup. ***UPDATE*** Went there last night. I ordered a Calzone. Great size for the price and it was good too. Wife got a BLT and that sandwich was large in comparison to the Philly cheese steak.... Maybe someone was having an off day. I do wish I could find a place that makes a steak and cheese grinder.

Best pizza in Colorado, maybe in the world ! 🌎 The dough is freshly made every day, they use quality ingredients and perfectly cook the pizza everytime! The service is friendly and professional, the atmosphere and decoration is great 🌄

Really good service despite there only being one waitress! And the pizza exceeded my expectations, super good. The salads are also good, and there is a decent beer/wine selection.

Great place to get a couple huge slices for a great price. If you leave here hungry it's your own fault. Staff is always courteous and I love to sit outside on the back porch when it's nice out.

Gluten-free pizza was lovely with a super thin crust. Unfortunately no coffee and no lemon for the iced tea. Very clean. Grey decor.

The garlic bread was not appetizing… pizza tasted pretty good!

We've now ordered from here twice. We ordered a calzone and salad, and the second time, their pizza. All in all, pretty great food. It's a bit of a drive for us so we won't be frequenting Guido's, but one of the best pizzas I've had. Wish they had a closer location.

We tried out Guido's for the first time today ... outstanding!! That is about the BEST pizza ever! The owners and staff are very friendly, they had lots of business happening including some obvious repeat customers based on their interaction ... which translates to me that this is all the locals' favorite place. Now it is ours as well!

Grew up on NY-style pizza. Love love love the light crunchiness of the crust and the family is always so nice and welcoming. We drove an hour out of our way back from a camping trip just to get this perfect pizza fix.