Simply the best. I do all of my parties here and I would never go anywhere else to celebrate events in my family. My daughter even had her wedding reception in the private room in 2020. Everything from food to service to atmosphere is incredible. The staff is very accommodating and works with you to achieve what you want. Besides the parties, they are a great place to go for dinner on a Friday or Saturday night with friends or even just to grab a slice if that's what you're in the mood for. To me, you can't beat this place - BEST FOOD and so much more. What else could you ask for?!

Awesome pizza! Definitely worthy it!

Really fabulous Italian restaurant! It feels like a neighborhood restaurant, but tastes like a special night out!

My wife and I just had our daughter's graduation party in private room at Cafe Amici's and it was awesome! Mike and his team did a great job with everything, the food is really good and delicious, along with the sandwiches. All of our guests were raving about how tasty and yummy everything was. The room is nice and big and very clean, the air conditioning is really nice and cool on a very hot day outside. Mike's staff working the party where wonderful, a man and lady, sorry don't know their names, so helpful and nice. Thanks Cafe Amici's for making it a truly wonderful day for my girl's!

This pizza palor has an great grandma pie. This cafe is an excellent value and underrated.

Food is delicious with generous portions. Good atmosphere with choices of different types of seating.

This place is just absolutely excellent!!! They have a ton of selections for slices, cooked to perfection! Everyone in the place is super friendly every time. Definitely worth jumping off the New Jersey Turnpike for this pie!! Alfredo, Buffalo, Margherita, take your pick the pizza is phenomenal

Excellent italian food..very good..well worth a stop to eat..and friday,saturday night dinner..or any day or night..they also cater..I recomend all their dishes..this place is gonna be 1 of my favorites..I will be eating here more often

We really like their pizza and other Italian specialties. Their sauce is particularly delicious

A nice "local" restaurant most frequently used for take-out or lunchtime orders. Evening dining attracts fewer people but the food is generally well prepared with attentive servers. It's BYOB helping to lower the cost of a pleasant and satisfying dining experience.

Pizza is not supposed to be able to do this. It was not really edible. But the cheese steaks here ok tho, and decently priced. Just be aware the garlic bacon cheese steak uses bacon bits that are sweet with that artificial maple flavor.

Staff is completely rude, sauce is watered down, think the owner should get a better attitude and stop cutting corners. Places like this cut corners when they struggling financially. At this point dominos taste better.

Great to go dinner for my family!!! Delicious, hot and well packaged. Highly recommend!!

We had my son's college graduation party in the back room. The room was set up perfectly for 65 with plenty of room to stand and chat. The service was top notch and the food was muy delicioso. So many attendees raved about it. The food was also reasonably priced. I was extremely pleased, since this was the first time having a party there. I would say the only negative is that the walls could be repainted. Aside from that, I would undoubtedly have another party there again. Thank you!!!!!

I am definitely not from the area but did have the opportunity for a quick visit. Had a 3 slice order and the staff was very friendly and welcoming. Pizza was on par with the neighborhood slices in Brooklyn NY although a bit smaller. I will revisit if back in South Brunswick in the future.

What an amazing place wonderful customer service. We had our company Christmas party at Amici they went out there way for us covered every little detail it was overall amazing. All our staff had such great things to say about the waiters the food the atmosphere just a wonderful place to host a party or just grab a bite to eat.

After moving to East Brunswick from about 25 minutes away and leaving behind our favorite pizza place, we began ordering from all the greater-EB area places. Cafe Amici was hands down the best. Their pizza is wonderful, with high quality cheese and delicious sauce, and it's extremely consistent. We also enjoy their subs. Their staff is also very kind and friendly.

Had a graduation party there for our 2 daughters great food and nice private room. Would highly recommend

Wow after hearing how Cafe Amici donated meals to health care works We ordered dinner for the first time. Not only was my food GREAT but the gave us a bunch of free items with a hand written note saying stay safe.

We ordered a grandmas, margarita, Cesar salad w chicken and chicken tenders. Everything came out good, no complaints. The outside looks a little run down, but the food is good. Only suggestion is the grandmas is a little to thick for our liking, but I would go back to this place again.