First time stopping by after passing this place many times, I was super pleased with my order. Toasted Asiago bagel with scallion cream cheese was delicious, definitely will be getting it again but darker toasted it was just missing a little crunch. Ham Egg and cheese on Everything was perfect, fluffy eggs, just right thickness of ham slightly crisped around the edges, melty cheese. The bagel had a great crunchy exterior and soft interior. I really appreciated the density of the toppings on the bagel and the ratio of them.

Clean place, clean bathroom, great customer service, fresh food, and great price. My new bagel to go shop.

The bagel and egg sandwich was good but the staff behind the counter taking orders, lacks basic customer service skills.

This is the place where I showed my children their first Egg bagel. Their bagles are freshly made and just delicious! Their Wednesday Bagel special is a family hit in my house! Their home made cream cheese is something I will always buy. They sell Boars Head Cold Cuts, so all their sandwiches are premium flavor and tasty. I only get my pork roll egg and cheese from here!

I went to pick up the bagels today early morning and the new manager started fighting with me when I asked why don’t you make more Jalapeño bagels as most of the times they runout of the bagels by afternoon, then he came out the aisle and charged at me, to which I walked away but it was clear he wanted to pick up a fight and abused me and called me a fool! 😱 I didn’t want to get into a altercation so I just walked away! Not sure why the owner hired such bad attitude people!

First time customer here and I must say my egg sandwich was excellent!! Bacon egg and cheese on a everything salt and Peppa bagel was super soft and fresh and the guy behind the counter is friendly... Hats off to u sir thank you.

Excellent food and bagels. Bobby does a great job. Nice atmosphere eat in or take out. Bagels n sandwiches are very good.

Very bright and clean inside. I went in for a half dozen bagels and lox-cream cheese.The cream cheese was not good and the bagels were really terrible. Sort of just rolls in the shape of a bagel. I wont be going back. sorry.

I love this place it's my go-to when I need to buy bagels for the school or for the family. Always fresh and service with a smile!

First of all, this place is 100% not an actual basket of bagels. Don’t come here if you think you’re going to be walking into an actual basket made of bagels. *oops*. Now, if you want breakfast and good bagels…. Oh, definitely come here. Big bagels. And you know what they say about “big bagels”…. More cream cheese

Kitchen was closed half an hour prior to the closing time. Owner said the shop fully closed at 2:30pm. Shop door and online hours say they close at 3:00pm. They only had two varieties of bagels. We got really flat bagels with barely any cream cheese on them. Fairly expensive too for what we got.

I used to enjoy eating at the Bagel Basket but, as of today, I will not patronize the business anymore for the following reason. Today, I noticed in addition to the order and taxes, there was a 3.2% service fee added to the order. That, to me, is a prime example of "GREED!" Why should I pay a service fee when I'm patronizing the business? Are you charging customers for the "new digitized register?" However, I visited the Bagel Market, located on Route 27, for the first time today, and a service fee was NOT added to the order. So, Bagel Basket, "Good Riddance," you've lost a loyal customer, because of your GREED.

Soo good omg, second time im coming, first time I ordered more, should’ve taken a photo then oof, affordable too, the coffee is good too, wish it was a bit stronger

Absolutely the best Breakfast sandwich in the area!!! Thick warm chewy eggs and cheese and crisp bacon on a fresh made roll- I been missing this since I left old bridge Speaking from personal experience I was eating at Bagel Mart for years but take an extra 2 minutes to get a proper sandwich and you won’t go back to Bagel mart

Great Bagel shop! Fresh bagels really good fillings and great customer service! This is not my closest bagel shop, at least 3 closer, but it is the one I use the most! Definitely worth the extra distance to get a quality product from a team that cares about what they send out, ensuring customer satisfaction seems to be the order if the day here!!

Great service, everyone is super nice. Small shop but has a great breakfast and lunch selection, and everything is delicious.

Awesome bagel place. Make sure you go early because the place gets busy fast. Great selection of bagels as well as choices for breakfast and lunch. They also have specials daily. You can use doorsdash etc as well.

Here’s the order, can I get an everything bagel scooped , double toasted and go lighter with the cream cheese. Sure !!! Here you go sir a bagel that’s not scooped , barely toasted and no cream cheese. Not to mention they messed up most of the order. Jesus not that hard !