Not Coffaros anymore. Now J&J pizza. Not the same quality. Tastes like generic, machine made pizza. Like Chuck e Cheese. End of an era. Will miss Coffaros pizza.

The best restaurants are the small, out of the way, hole in the wall places that you find in any town in the world. This is one of those places. I have been eating here as far back as I have been eating solid food. I grew up in South River and this was the pizza of choice. Their pizza is fantastic. It has a sweeter sauce and a thinner crust that makes it unique. The absolute best pizza they make is the "ground sausage" pie. The sausage is ground up in the sauce under the cheese. The flavor is amazing. To my knowledge the restaurant has changed hands twice since the original owner, Mr. Coffaro, opened. The quality and taste has never changed with successive owners. I have always thought their delivery times were a bit long, usually a 45 to 60 minutes wait, so I have always picked up. Even as I moved out of South River, I still occasionally return because there is nothing like it.

Never will order from this place again. Called in for a pick up. Was supposed to be delivery but the guy kept saying pick up so we made it a pick up. Half hour later go there to get it and it wasn’t even made yet. The guy never put the order in to the cook. So he tell us 5 minutes. He was told the order by my husband multiple times and everything. Get home to have a plain pie when we ordered a large extra cheese and pepperoni pizza, fries and mozzarella sticks. Call them back and speak to two ppl and he tells us it’s an extra large pizza and cheese fries. Really?! AND the pizza was so under cooked! We couldn’t even eat it. That’s how bad it was! NEVER NEVER again will we get anything from this place again.

Pizza was like - there's nothing wrong with it, it's not bad, but it's certainly not good. We ordered garlic knots, and they just didn't make them.

Atrocious customer service. We've ordered the same order every Friday night for the last 6 months, our pizza light on the cheese and crispy. Pie was sent with a ton of cheese and floppy. When I called, the guy who answered said he wrote light on the cheese and crispy which is wrong because we have the ticket. He said that it's light on the cheese and the pictures below clearly show otherwise. While mistakes happen, he completely refused to acknowledge their mistake and was extremely rude on to me on the phone. When my mom called, he proceeded to cut her off and shouted at her saying it was made correctly, he wouldn't do anything about it, and to call tomorrow if we had a problem with it. Unfortunately he refused to tell us his name but whoever handles Friday night orders has lost a loyal customer and should learn how to deal with customers. Completely unacceptable and will never order from here again

The worst pizza shop in south river, the cashier very rude and the place old and dirty they don’t know how handle food for human consumption

If I could give this place a negative star I would. Ordered a cheese steak, chicken roll, and cheese garlic bread. the marina sauce that came on the side was ice cold. the chicken roll was ice cold and the dough was raw. The cheese on the garlic bread was ice cold and un melted. Cheesesteak wasnt even cut in half and did not have ketchup as requested .The food wasinedible. Never will order from them again. When i first called to order I was told they were out of chicken park heros, egg plant parm heros, and even GARLIC KNOTS! .called and asked to speak to manager/owner and was told there was no manager and the owner only comes in ever once in a while. will never eat here again.

2 times I ordered from this place and it has been nothing but an awful experience. The pizza was cold 2 times and we live down the street. They went to the wrong house BOTH times. We call back and they just said “sorry” and did nothing nor did they care.

The good reviews for this place are for the previous ownership and totally different pizza recipe. This place is now awful. Avoid.

Horrible, pizza looks and taste like something you get from a bowling alley/roller rink. Wings still had the fat on them, not crispy all around horrible.

We ordered a pizza with mushrooms and peppers which was a good value for the price and tasted really good....

Great services and the food was so good going back for more this week 😋

Don’t underestimate this low key pizzeria. They have by far the best pizza in town. Every bite taste just like a New York City slice. Love this place 🙌

One of the best pizzas around. The sauce is amazing, a bit sweet, which is what I like. The staff is very friendly. Family owned...which I think it is great to support small mom and pop shops and family owned places over big chains. Only downfall is the place could use updating or sprucing up. The appearance could probably bother some people, but I let the food do the talking and the food is great. Anyone who rated 2 stars or less I do not trust their judgment