The fried calamari was enough to feed 3 and it was well made. Since it is Tuesday seafood night I ordered clam and mussels with a light red sauce, Ceasars salad and rainbow cheese cake. My hubby ordered fradiavolo, house salad and Italian cheese cake. For me the sauce on my dish was salty so really did not enjoy my dish. My husband's dish was really good. The fried calamari delicious with the fresh made sauce. The rainbow cheese cake was to die for it was rich and it tasted like a rainbow cookie. The Italian cheese cake was good had a slight lemon flavor. The server was very attentive to our needs. At one point the restaurant got hot and some people were shifting to the pizza area. But all in all a great calm place to sit and enjoy a meal.

Rolled in from out of town, AMAZING service and pizza on Long Island. HAVE to get Rosemarie’s grandma slice, the the garlicky sauce + fresh mozzarella is unbeatable with the thicker crust. Sean was a delight and made sure we had a delicious and great experience. Even threw in extra snacks on the house, best pizza place in Farmingdale!

Good experience, nice general pizzeria / Italian restaurant. Nice to have wine options. Food's pretty decent. The staff are very quick and courteous and ready to help. Worth a stop if you want some good food.

Vodka pizza is always my favorite so I ordered their vodka flatbread which was great and the portion, price, and quality were on point! Also, I was coming from out of town after a long 6 hour drive, was super tired and got there close to their closing time. I’m not sure the name of the waitress - wish I remembered to give her credit, but she was super sweet and let me still dine in without making me feel rushed!

The specials are awesome! We have been ordering take out from them for years. The other night we decided to eat in. They have really good specials. We went on Thursday and ut was Chicken night. Very big selection with dessert included. Cant wait to try Tuesday's seafood special.

Not the best service. Nobody brought us silver ware. None of the tables were being cleaned after people left. Took a long time for our orders to be taken and we had to ask for menus. Wont be coming back especially that there is a pizzeria across the road too.

We had a nice pasta meal at Rosemarie's to celebrate a family event. Good food and excellent service. Try the weekday specialty nights...they seem like a great deal!

Good customer service, but $27 for burnt pizza is no Bueno.