We tried this restaurant based on getting a coupon for 4 sandwiches and a large Greek salad for $42. Not a bad deal. But you get what you pay for. I love falafel which is ground chick peas that are fried. One of the sandwiches ordered was falafel (at least I think it was falafel) and it looked and tasted like nothing I’ve ever seen before. We also ordered souvlaki sandwiches which were decent but small. Now I know why the total was $42. We tried it. Would we ever go back? I don’t think so.

I had a hankering for a good Spanikopita last night. I've had the gyros from here before and they were good (though to be candid a gyro is a gyro to me; kinda hard to mess that up). I placed my order for pick up and grabbed my spinach pie - cost me nearly $9. Completely reasonable for an appetizer except you don't get a pie (I've gotten this same appetizer from other Greek Places and you get a massive circular tin or something similar). Here, you get a very small slice of a pie wrapped in paper and to make matters worse, it wasnt even good. It was drier than it was moist as it should be and I could barely find any feta cheese in it. A disappointment to say the least. I'll stick with Aegean Grill going forward.

been going there 20 plus yrs. No one compares. My family loves gyro night!! Thanks Athens Could use a new card reader machine! But still worth the wait

Hidden Greek Gem. Gyros the way I remember them from Astoria. The Gyros are the bomb, best I've ever had since the 1980s and their Yogurt sauce is not overwhelming and just perfect! I promise you will not be disappointed!

Food is always good. We always take out. They never botch the order or forget something and the staff is always really friendly and appreciative. Definitely a business worth supporting.

This restaurant is absolutely AMAZING!!! Our server John was so professional, great manners, and so down-to-earth. The prices are great and the quality of the food is truly off the hook! Please come visit my buddy John, (server)! Awesome job Athens Square Cafe!

Always happy with the quality and freshness of their food. When ordering on line the food is always ready. Staff is very friendly

Great food. Love the greek salad with the chicken

I moved to Rocky Point almost three years ago and have not found a Greek place that compares to Athens Square! So tonight’s meal was amazing!! I wish there were duplicates of this tasty deliciousness out east!!

No pictures , I apologized but we were in the area & decided to try this place for lunch today. We’ve been to many Greek eateries in Suffolk (mostly central Suffolk in case this makes a difference) & we’ve never been served such a tiny gyro. We’ve also never been given a gyro that didn’t have at least lettuce & tomato on it. We got the combo gyro with side salad. The gyro was minimal. We also ordered the lunch small salad with shrimp for $14.50. It was an extreme disappointment. Shrimp was low quality , rubbery (I’m sure frozen & possibly freezer burned) and tasteless. Way too many onions in the salad & couldn’t remove them because they were chopped. Meal (Just gyro) was questioned & to the owners credit , he was not rude at all just simply explained that that’s how they do it. Anyway, always stinks to have a disappointing meal. We’re in the area for doc appts occasionally but won’t be back unfortunately.

Horrible customer services. I have never been spoken to so rudely. I will not be returning.

Had a lovely dinner with a friend here. Salad with grilled chicken. It was very good and very reasonable

This is probably the best place to get Greek food in East Northport. But, I used to live in South Nassau, near the Queens border, and the Greek food in that area is much better. Their lamb gyro is good. Their salads are also good. Tzatziki sauce is too heavy on the dill. They don’t offer shaved meat.

This is the best place in northport-east northport to get greek salad. The chicken was so tender not tuff or like bubble gum the salad was excellent even the tomatoes. We just happened to try it after a long time. So glad we did. This will be our new place for the best Greek food.

BEST falafel and Greek salads on the Island, hands down!!!!! Good, quality FRESH food prepared quickly. Bonus since it's literally across the street from my job.

I had takeout from there the other night and I enjoyed it. Fresh ingredients and friendly service. Price is average.

Beautiful presentation, great food as always. We had a small Greek salad with chicken gyro meat on top.