Delicious! Walking distance from the softball fields (which is why we decided to try it). And I’m glad we did! It’s a low key building but the food was delicious. They were already out of ribs for the day which was a bummer but the pulled pork was good, Cajun coleslaw and Mac and cheese were also yummy! I’d def stop in again

Food is good but the wings aren’t nearly as good as it was before it changed owners. They definitely give you your money worth in serving size tho, and the racks of ribs are THE BOMB! 💣. The workers are really really sweet and work hard to keep things running! The decorations are too cute and the outdoor seating area is great if the weather is nice. Overall, I hope this place sticks around this small town!

I wasn't sure about this small little place. You just never know with a barbeque place if it's going to be good or not. Most are not. I was surprised, this one actually is very good. Good job. I had the pulled pork, tender, tastes great, no need for sauce, that's how you know it's good. The chicken was good, not amazing, tender in the middle but the edges were too dry. Chicken can be difficult. They were out of brisket or I would have tried it. The Mac and cheese was great, same with the beans and cornbread. Well deserved place. The drink machine was out of a bunch of things, but it's fine. I'd like to have seen some beer, but idk how they manage such a small little footprint. I hope they keep this place going, it must be working ok because it's been there for a bit from what I can tell.

It's a mix of good and not so good. The flavor of the pulled pork is really good, but it wasn't warmer than room temperature when served. The beef brisket was good, but the smoked chicken was dry and hard. The burgers had good flavor...after picking off the diced onions that weren't ordered (either of the 2 times she asked what toppings we wanted.) We would return for the pulled pork, mac and cheese, and green beans.

I had the pulled pork sandwich and it was good. They give first responders and military a 10% discount. My partner ordered a 2 meat sampler but for $14, I was expecting more meat. Overall, not a bad place to visit.

Our group came at 3:30 on a Monday, ordered Burnt Ends, Smoked Mac & Cheese, Cajun Coleslaw. ALL OF THAT, was amazing! You could taste the smoke in the Mac and cheese which was well seasoned and cheesy. The heavenly sauce on the burnt ends was a sweet and tangy delight. The woman at the front was very kind and hospitable. We will definitely stop again!

If you're ever passing through Edinburgh, IN, and you have a craving for some authentic and mouth-watering BBQ, Hickory Hillz BBQ is the place to stop. The minute you walk through the door, you'll be hit with the intoxicating aroma of smoked meats that promises a feast for your taste buds. Now, let's talk about what's really going to make you come back time and time again - the brisket, the burnt ends, and the one-of-a-kind mac stack sandwich. The brisket at Hickory Hillz is slow-cooked to perfection. It's tender, juicy, and carries that heavenly smoky flavor that only comes from hours upon hours in a perfectly controlled smoker. You can taste the love and craftsmanship that goes into every bite. But it doesn't stop there. The burnt ends are a flavorful treat that will satisfy even the most discerning BBQ aficionados. They're crisp on the outside, tender on the inside, and bursting with flavor. A perfect blend of sweet and savory, they are the ideal companion to any meal or a wonderful treat all on their own. And then there's the mac stack sandwich, an ingenious creation that is nothing short of a culinary masterpiece. Imagine 1/3 of a pound of meat of your choice, coupled with Hickory Hillz's unique smoked mac and cheese, all placed lovingly between two slices of bread. It's not just a sandwich; it's an experience. The creaminess of the mac and cheese complements the richness of the meat, creating a taste sensation that's both comforting and utterly exhilarating. I also have to mention the friendly staff and the laid-back atmosphere that make you feel right at home. Hickory Hillz isn't just about great food; it's about the joy of sharing those flavors with friends and family.

I like the way they rearranged the inside of the restaurant. The curly dog sandwich was a bit weird. Very hard to eat. I asked to have my tortilla chips in a separate container from all the goodies. Instead, all the goodies came in separate containers and the nachos were a huge cheesy mess. Ended up being fairly tasty though. The staff is very nice.