You'd never guess this place was so good. Nothing revolutionary, but really good salad and pizza. I had the spinach salad and House Special pizza. Both were great. And the ranch dressing was delicious. I also appreciated that drinks were self-serve though it is a sit-down-with-a-waiter restaurant.

Oh my God, the worst pizza I've ever had! This place deserves negative stars. Do not believe the reviews, this pizza is horrendous!! I wouldn't feed this to a dog!! Reply: I'm glad you said that. I didn't even mention that you tried to deny that you received my order, until I showed you the receipt. The pizza was so bad that the fact that you tried to deny you received the order was miniscule. So your response alone shows that the pizzas came from you. The pizzas weren't reheated. Would I reheat and burn both? C'mon! This is what you sold me, but I can completely understand why you would want to deny it, just look at it! I was passing through, had it not been for that, I would have brought this garbage back. However, I should have checked it before I left, so that was my mistake because I was in a rush. I just assumed the reviews were accurate, but never again! Nevertheless, It's so dishonest to try to deny that the pizzas came from you, but admittedly confirming you remember the order. Wow, this is not a bright moment for you! What you should have done was just admit the mistakes and apologize, which is what a reputable business would have done.

The best pizza in Natchitoches! They sell 8 inch personal pizzas also and they have a huge selection. The cheesy bread is delicious and they have a large selection of salads. Very friendly staff, you feel like you're at home.

Phenomenal does not even begin to describe this place! My family and I were in town for an event and wanted pizza. We prefer to eat at locally owned establishments and this place definitely did not disappoint. The staff was kind, accommodating, welcoming, and attended to us well. We ordered mozzarella sticks and a pizza. When the mozzarella sticks came out they were piping hot and oh so good! They melted in your mouth! The pizza came out bubbly and hot. It was cooked to utter perfection, loaded with toppings, and the flavor…. UNBELIEVABLE! I am a pizza lover and can say without a doubt that this was the BEST pizza that I have ever had the pleasure of eating! Peggy’s is definitely a hidden gem that will be worth your time to discover.

First time trying the establishment. It was absolutely amazing. The food was very fresh and delicious. The mozzarella and cheddar cheese bread was like no other. I had a New Orleans pizza to go with it and hands down there is nothing I've tried that even comes close. Will be back again next week!

It's just what it says on the sign, a homemade pizza. When I sat down I could see in the kitchen and they were making the dough from scratch and they didn't skimp on the cheese and toppings. Probably one of the better pizzas I've had in the south for a long time, especially for the price which is very reasonable for the high quality. Dining room is no frills, but it gets the job done. A lot of folks seem to be getting carry out and the ladies taking orders were giving estimated times to make their orders which was a nice touch.

Orderd 3 pizzas. Took 1 hr 55 min. Only 3 tables with customers out of 20. I understand when things go wrong but customer service needs to step up !!!! No apology, no compensation ,girl seemed as though she really hated her job. Won't be back ...if your hungry you better bring your own snack. Gonna be awhile

Great pizza. The cheese, sauce, and toppings couldnt have been better. I feel like maybe the crust could have been thinner or crispier on the underside, that's the closest I can get to a complaint about this place. Would go again.