This is what took me there Brendon Leslie review. The plants are a nice touch out side until you walk in the place. The young at the register was a grump but, I even asked him did he like his job mumbled said yes. He took my order 2 pizzas one cheese , one Hawaiian. Let’s just say they need help with the Hawaiian. Nothing special about this pizza at all!!!!! Or even the place.

If I could rate this place 0 stars, I absolutely would. I have never written a bad review, ever. We have ordered from here 3 times. Oct 16, Nov 25 and tonight Dec 31.. on Nov 25 our food showed up not only very late, but super cold and we were missing parts of our order that we PAID for. My husband called and told them and they said “next time we will just give you extra”....... in which we were not ok with, we paid for food we did not receive. We decided to give them another try tonight, around 8-8:30pm we placed and order with them we let them know about our previous experience and that we were told to ask for “extra” of an item we never received previously....so we did. Therefore Our dinner order was placed and delivery time was set to 9:50pm...well... .it’s now 10:30pm we still have not received our food or a phone call that they are running behind and Bella Mia is closed and of course no one is answering.. a $35 meal, vanished. As a precious business owner I am embarrassed for this place on how poorly their service is, and lack of urgency. I am now left to figure out dinner at 10:30-11 pm at night for my family on New Year’s Eve. This is absolutely ridiculous!!! We will never be ordering and wasting our money here again.

Excellent food and Service! Can't say enough about the food quality and staff. This pizza is the best! The White pizza is mozzerella, ricotta, tomatoes, and spinach. It is unbelievable. They also have excellent homemade pasta dishes. If you have not tried Bella's, you're missing out. Thank you Bella's for consistent and great food.

Love this place! The whole pies are awesome! My favorite is the Quattro Formaggio (but i always add ricotta) and I love the selections of pizza-by-the-slice. It's all good, but my number one favorite is the white pizza with ricotta, spinach and mushrooms!

Ordered off of Ubereats on Fathers Day, an almost 80$ order. Our garlic knots were burnt, salad was brown and had a burnt cooked onion in it, one of the pastas was 23$ and it was the smallest item we recieved. And when I attempted to contact the store no one answered. Probably because it was 15 minutes to close and they were ignoring the phones. I will never order from this establishment again and I urge you to choose Olive Garden over this place.

Chicken Francese portion was very small for it being over $20. Also, Linguine was undercooked. We also got a chicken Parm sub and there was more sauce and cheese than actual chicken, and also just wasn't good. Don't know if this is related, but my wife (who had the Francese) got incredibly nauseous about 15 min after eating it, and my stomach has been in knots from about 2 hours after eating the Parm sub until now (the next morning). Again, could be a coincidence (I don't want to claim that we got some sort of food poisoning since there's no proof whatsoever) but either way, won't order from there again based off the price and low quality of food.

I ordered a pepperoni Stromboli and the bruschetta and the Stromboli has about 2 pieces of pepperoni in it total. The bruschetta is the furthest thing from bruschetta I have ever seen in my life. It is 99% onions and 1% herbs and HUGE chunks of tomatoes. There is no oil/sauce like traditional bruschetta has and the tomato’s are grainy and do not taste fresh, the onions are overpowering the entire thing and it is just gross. I am not one to leave bad reviews especially for smaller restaurants but I’m just not satisfied with my food at all and hate that I wasted money.

Just ordered take out pizza and knots for the first time. The pics on Google make the pizza look soft and fluffy (my preference) but it's definitely thin NY style. Also saw a baby roach (not palmetto bug) run across the counter. Will update my review after I try the food. After food review: Pizza was crunchy (not my style), sauce was the best part, garlic knots were tasty but 2 were pretty burnt. This place has potential but there's other pizza places I'd order at over this one.

Absolutely terrible. Pizza completely soaked with grease and dough not cooked. Boli was burnt on top and not cooked on bottom. This used to be place but last few months just garbage coming out. Time to find another pizza place that cares. $50 down the drain.

Just got chicken fingers from this place and they were absolutely disgusting! They were so over cooked and burnt, when I cut them open they had no meat inside because they were so dried up and burnt. I don't know , maybe it's me but usually chicken fingers are long pieces of breast meat, well these were cut up pieces of some part of the chicken, they were no way all white meat breast pieces. When I called to complain they told me that is always how they cook them all the time, and told me that if I had a problem to take it up with Uber Eats. I will NEVER order from this horrible place ever again. I tried to feed it to my dog before I threw it away and she even turned her nose up at it, so what does that tell you? Move on if you are looking for a new place to try because this one will surely disappoint.

The pizza was good, but staff never asked or came to our table to see if everything was good. Also, we had to ask for our check, now; we were the only customers! Also, be aware of the billing, as my sister and I had the personal pizza with 1 extra topping, and my meal was more.

Some of the best pizza I have ever had. The owners are very nice. This is the true definition of a hole-in-the-wall pizza joint. Try the white pizza. You will be amazed! The crust is delicious. I would call it thin crust. The crust is what puts the pizza of over the top. Don't pass this place up!

Tried them out bc my wife and I never had them before. We got a supreme pizza and a meat calzone. The calzone had barely any thing on it and not much cheese at all. The pizza was not good at all. Shows pictures of alot of toppings and it seemed like the main toppings were cheese and spinach. I really wish they would of said spinach was on it bc I would never have gotten it. I literally hate spinach. My wife loves spinach and still hated this pizza. The toppings were just not good. And just like the calzone there wasn't anything on the pizza. Extremely disappointed. Would've been better spending $40 somewhere else. Anywhere else.

This is literally the best Italian food I've had in a long time. I was thinking about getting Olive Garden tonight, but I decided to get Bella Mia and I made an excellent choice. This tastes like real Italian food, nothing to be compared to any chain restaraunt. I've been coming to this place for years for their garlic knots and pizza, but this is the first time I tried the pasta and I am seriously impressed. The arrival time for my food to be delivered was 6:40 and they got here exactly at 6:40. Amazing service. Thank you.

Nice place

Better than Olive Gardens

Super bad experience, bad service, bad food A live cockroach in cheese This is the worst place ever a live roach inside the cheese plus a real bad service, And no face mask or gloves for virus pretty nasty and smelly place So sorry I don't like to do this but people needs to know about this place

stopped in for bowl of spaghetti. place is small and we happened to arrive after high school got out, but the food was great. Garlic rolls made from their pizza dough were superb.Thanks for a really good meal.

Love their quick and tasty pizza

Our family enjoyed the Veggie Pizza and would recommend this place for a great product.

First time ordering. LOVED IT! Haven't had a NY style in a long while. Definitely going back for more soon. Service was excellent too 👍

Good pizza . pretty face and good service

A fav spot for Pizza. The staff was very helpful and welcoming. Prices were average for the menu.

Excellent! Pie was fantastic as well as the tiramisu. Our new favorite!

Delicious food and fast service

After living in Florida, coming from the tri state area, 21 yrs ago, hands down, best pizza in Lee County, not even close.

Food was cold when received called and talked to the manager himself and was accused of lying that I’ve complained multiple times when I’ve ordered from their maybe 3 times never complained until now. He was very disrespectful and rude so is the staff HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE. If I could give 0 stars I would

Love their sauce Really great pizza

A delicious hole in the wall pizza joint very similar to NYC pizza for sure! Fast and inexpensive, everyone is super nice too! Thank you Bella Mia Pizza! Happy New Year 😁

Best calzones, pizza, and Greek salads. Great cheese, sauce, and dough.

Awesome food

Great pizza

Amazing food !!!!

This is hands down the best pizza I have had in a long time. The man at the counter was friendly and you could tell they were busy. While there I had to add an extra pizza because more company came to my home and he did that no problem! I will keep ordering! Thanks for brining me back to NY! Yummy! oh and no one ever has a white veggie pizza like this!

Best pizza since NY! Small eatery but packed w taste! If you are an Italian food connoisseur and not close, it’s worth the drive! May be your new fav place! Bella Mia pasta, YUM! aka vodka pasta, YUM! Meatballs, extra Yum! Subs... delicious (meatball, chick parm, steak & Italian have not disappointed) Even his spaghetti is done correctly. (Noodles made to order not sitting in a pot going over what a noodle should be or taste like) His sauce is for sure the Star 🌟 His desserts are very good and home made. I do and I have recommended this Italian mom n pop spot to anyone. We eat there twice a week sometimes as it is that good! There is a small seating arrangement or order out n pick up or have delivered... Enjoy!

Excellent real Italian food....And the man that owns it cooks everything Himself.People from all over that appreciates real Italian food should come here and try it.. Excellent prices also

The Best pizza I have had In the North Fort Myers North Cape Coral area. Pizza is 5 Stars They seem to be a little confused at the register not knowing who's Pizza belong to who. I also read in newspress they have been given numerous warnings and citations from the health before being shut down for a couple days to clean rodent droppings and other sanitary issues. I guess it's a good thing the pizza is cooked at a super high temperature LOL but I'm very hesitant to order from their because of their long list of violations that keep happening.

Great Lasagna

One of the best tasting pizzas in the area! Loved it!

I moved here in January 2022 and think I've tried all the local family owned pizza places now. I'm very picky when it comes to pizza and think this is the best in North Fort Myers/Cape Coral area! I picked up two 18" pizzas yesterday and was very, very pleased. The standard crust is about perfect, thick enough so it's not floppy but plenty thin enough to fold it proper for New York style. The flavor of the crust is excellent as are all the ingredients. A very generous portion of cheese and well balanced with the sauce. Now that I finally found this place I highly recommend Bella Mia's and will return again and again and again! :)

Excellent Brooklyn style pizza & amazing crust! Can't wait to try their main dishes next!

Im from out of town was looking for a good pizza spot and came across this place. The guy over counter not too friendly tried to make conversation looked like he wasn't interested got a slice asked him if he can put it back in oven so it can be more well done and he put it back for couple seconds didn't notice a difference. I said to myself hope pizza is better than his personality and it was just okay I'll keep looking for a good pizza spot

This is by far the best East Coast pizza in the area. It reminds me of pizza from Westport, CT. 4 stars for the ambience. Waitstaff and owners nice folks. Bought a bottle of wine there that was corked. 😝 But I alway go back for pizza and garlic knots are the bomb! 😋😋

Ordered carry out but they have a couple tables for eat in. Ordered the chicken parm and it was fabulous. Garlic knots...a hit. Give it a try. Pizza slices ready to go for a quick meal or order ahead for what you want.

You'll love this pizza. The chicken alfredo is fantastic. The owner has put his heart and soul into this place for over 12 years. I can honestly say I cannot think of a time when he has not been in his store. Is always clean and the sauce is incredible. The pizza dough has great texture and flavor. He uses great toppings, strombolis are out of this world

Visited this little place by my son’s school. Their Bruschetta appetizer is great. The Alfredo sauce is also really good and I am not usually a big fan of Alfredo.

We ordered food for pickup. The food and service were great. Just wished they had delivery.

We decided to eat in. This was our first time here. The individual who took our order didn’t ask us what we wanted to drink and spent zero time to make sure that we had all that we needed. Maybe we just didn’t know how his business operates? The lasagna came in an aluminum foil dish that was sat on a plate. I was given a frozen heat and serve meal for a fancy restaurant price. The food was similar to what I would make at home nothing fancy but not bad at all. The shrimp scampi that my husband ordered he described the same way, nothing fancy. I am interested in trying the pizza on a carry out basis. Update since trying the pizza by the slice: we enjoyed the non traditional pizza for the homemade taste and for the convenience. We chose to stop here for the pizza twice so far. It is on the healthier side of the pizza spectrum.

We don’t eat at Bella Mia, we pick up our pizza and eat at home. The pizza is excellent, we get a thin crust and the pizza is well done. The cheese is great, the red sauce is very good and sometimes we get 1/2 with sausage and mushrooms. I highly recommend Bella Mia!!

Ordered a cheesesteak and half mushroom half pepperoni pizza with some garlic knots and a canoli. The sauce and cheese were nearly flavorless, crust seemed stale, and toppings were just sparsely thrown on in chunks. I might as well have gotten 2 cheese pizzas and called it a day. The garlic knots were dry and hardly had any garlic and the canoli was borderline inedible. Only decent thing I can say is the food came quickly. Much better options around.

Had terrible service here, which was a shame, it use to be our go place for Italian. Placed our order, when my husband came home it was all wrong, he tried to call to see what happened and they hung up on him twice.

Small, no frills trattoria. They’ve been here for years providing the best pizza in North Fort Myers. Authentic Italian dishes, Calzones, Stromboli’s, etc... once you’ve tried it you won’t be going anywhere else. Reasonable prices and fast service. If you’re going there for lunch just make it there early for the selection of slices.

I stopped in to try the pizza. Not a very friendly place, the workers seemed very unmotivated. The pizza was ok, a little bland and oily. The drink refrigerator was dirty with greasy finger prints all over it. The restaurant as a whole was dirty, the mirrors, counter etc. Even the credit card reader was dirty! It could be a nice place, but needs a good cleaning!The slices were smaller than other places...fair enough price though. I wasn’t impressed with anything there. Just being honest.

First time ordering from here, never again. Ordered the Sicilian pizza, it was not cooked properly most of the dough in crust was way under cooked almost raw. They also forgot to add the toppings requested we received nothing but greasy cheese which would slide off the pizza. Worse pizza ever.

We had a variety of food from appetizers to entrees for three people everything was outstanding. Definitely will go back.

Good food, friendly service!

decided to give this place a try since it was late, this place is a joke i wouldn't even recommend this place to my enemy , i would leave a o for the stars if i could, had my food delivered late and cold, salad was not even made to the description, 1 pizza was cooked fine and the other pizza was burnt, garlic knots over cooked, so i decided to take a drive over there to see what was going on, after getting there and talking to the owner i realized why the food was the way it was, he was very rude and refused to give me my money back, and to make it worse they do not follow cdc guidelines, not 1 employee was wearing a mask while spit was coming out of the owners mouth as he is telling me to leave his place and refusing to refund me, i left the food and walked out, please do your self a favor and go else where, there is plenty of better places around

Nice portions

Pretty good food but the noodles in my chicken Alfredo were half cooked but besides that very pretty good food.

Great food

Dinning room really needs some work but the food is excellent.

Good pizza and garlic knots

The BEST Tasting and Largest calzones. We had eaten here 5 years ago and loved it. Moved across the bridge over to Lehigh but found ourselves on this side of town and we're so fortunate to find Bella Mia open and thriving. Garlic knots better then before and the Meat lover Calzone too big for us to devour in one sitting. Just wonderful. Well worth the money. Great food, price and even free movie. Will be back. ☺️

If you want GREAT PIZZA AT THE COST OF EXCELLENT SERVICE I RECOMMEND AL-CAPONES ....UGGGGHHHH SOOO YUMMY...THIS PLACE IS NO WHERE CLOSE..NICE TRY THOUGH🥰

Feel it is a bit overpriced but maybe it was my orders these couple times. Our pizza always seems to be undercooked in the middle and hard on the edges. :/ ingredients are good and everything else is fine.

Well, hopefully the owner doesn’t lash out at me. We got the ‘Boli’ and mozzarella sticks. The sticks were very salty and dried out. Our biggest issue was the Boli. It went in the trash. It was wet and raw inside. The sauce was the worst we ever had, seriously. Our experience was a 1 Star but I don’t want to hurt the overall ratings that much. Could have just been a bad day.

Best pizza in north fort Myers, small dining area. Very affordable prices

Good was very tasty...

Great friendly customer service. Food was excellent and reasonably priced

Pizza was flavorful and really delicious! Garlic knots were crunchy, buttery, and the marinara sauce was the perfect compliment to them. My chicken Caesar salad was good, with fresh parmigiana and a good sized portion of chicken breast. We will definitely be back!

The pizza taste great and we enjoyed the pasta dishes too. Glad we found you guys, great family owned restaurant.

I've been to quite a few pizza joints here in Cape Coral and Fort Myers. This one is hands down my favorite! When I try new pizza, I ask myself if it's better than Bella Mia's and it never is! My mom was from New York and she told me it is most like what she remembered having in New York, this was her favorite as well. I love it because it's not too saucy or too cheesy or doughy it is all the perfect ratio and flavors you can't get anywhere else! Plain ol cheese pizza is what I get & it's perfect every time!

Are at Bella Mia today .. lasagna we good , my veal Marcella was good .. great service Not crowded , yes I will go back

Great food with amazing service. Very cozy and clean.