Had roast beef of the day on a Saturday night in a kids meal meat was so tough you couldn't cut it vegetables were hard.waitress asked how it was we said it's terrible.she said sorry new chef and hasn't done this before!took the plate away didn't even offer another meal or a refund.my poor elderly mum ate nothing on it! Sorry a no go for me

Sadly the atmosphere that used to draw me into The Tavern has gone. It was always such a lovely cold weather eatery sitting by the fire with a bowl of soup but this is now gone. I hope once you guys get the staff back that this feature comes back. Food was a little on the pricey side for what was on the plate but was nicely cooked and fresh ingredients. Well try again in 6-12 months to see if things change.

Had lunch today with a few friends and it was awesome. The meal, service were fantastic. Cold beers and great food along with fantastic staff made it a great day.

A jewel of a place. Excellent, fast bistro service, best value steaks on the Peninsula, quiet. Try to get a table near one of the 4 fireplaces, okay? A recommendation is the garlic bread, the porterhouse, the chicken burger, the Parma. Budget on $50 for 3 courses, or two and a drink. Support your local taverns, folks, and this one's a better. We'll be back.

Food was excellent and plentiful. Lots of older people meet there so sound was good. Peaceful and non fused eatery

The Baxter Tavern is one of those downright “feel-good” pubs. Smiling, friendly, helpful staff. Delicious food, served promptly & hot. I had the koftas & they were amazingly delicious. My husband had the seafood risotto & he too enjoyed his meal. Highly recommended.

First time there, it was a bit disappointing. Had a chicken parma with chips , didn't come with salad, No salad $28 The sauce they used tasted like chutney and was very over powering. Food out of 10, I give them a 4. Maybe good for a drink and some pokies.

Very tasty and generous meals, good variety on the menu, good prices, generous seniors discount, staff very friendly and smiling 🙂, nice atmosphere and pleasant setting. Definitely recommended.

Very disappointing meal last night. The limited menu is very restrictive. The website should display the limited menu rather than the full menu. I understand and appreciate the difficulties of the short staff issue but all other venues I have visited in recent times manage to offer their full menu. Please change your website so that all diners are aware before they visit.

400g porterhouse steak with peppercorn sauce with vegetables & salad bar. Complimentary warm bread rolls. The meal was delicious! 😋 20% off price for seniors. Great staff & 3 open fireplaces made for a cosy lunch which was of enormous proportions. Take the doggy bag 😄 Excellent venue ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

large cosy bistro with fire places. Hearty senior meals, very tasty. We even got a free bread roll which is becoming unusual .

This is a great venue for Xmas lunch. The staff are welcoming and attentive to your needs. The all you can eat lunch has fresh seafood, cold meats roasted ated meat and veg, other veg dishes and salads and kid favourites. Add to this the mini Xmas puddings and a selection of deserts, including an ice cream bar. Coffee is included in the price. The venue is comfortable and not noisy, considering the number of patrons. We thoroughly enjoy Xmas Lunch here.

Had not been to Baxter Tavern for a very long time. The decor is still the same and a bit dated but add to the homely atmosphere. The food was amazing, a wide range to choose from, quite a few Vegetarian options too. Free salad and fruit salad with a main dish and yummy free bread rolls. They had a musician playing and he was really good and not to loud and overpowering easy listening music. Will definitely be back soon.

Delicious menu and friendly service. Everyone enjoyed their meals, even the professional chef within our group!

I don't know how they get their batter on the fish so crispy and airy. But it is sensational. Had an African curry there a few weeks back as well. Both meals were great. We think it is a hidden gem

Went for lunch, the meals were great. The soup was delicious, You had roast pork. Lamb is so cheap at the moment it would be great if pubs Had Lamb or Chicken for a roast dinner.

My wife and I made a point of having lunch at the Baxter Tavern today after shopping in Carrum Downs knowing how good it is after being there before.My wife had the chicken scallopini which she said was the best she had ever had my roast pork was delicious.The drinks are very reasonably priced not like Sorrento and Portsea where they are so expensive.Sunday lunch you can listen to some very talented musicians.The best Pub on the Mornington Peninsula by far.Thankyou so much.

They have dropped the ball. It used to be good now it is not. I will never ever go there again. Astonishing That they are still in business. The dish of fettuccine carbonà was fit for a dog, discusting.

Had a lovely meal there tonight but more importantly had amazing service. Michelle was patient and helpful when I was asking multiple questions about menu choices and her recommendations were spot on. Got to say her friendliness and sense of humour made our night.

Beautiful food. Great drink selection. It's in Baxter. It's tavern like. Good ol, Baxter Tavern! (have you been listed as historic yet?)

Fantastic pub style environment. Great tasting menu with wonderful accommodating friendly staff. Always a favourite 😊

Good afternoon I have been having lunch and dinner at the Baxter for many years I am very upset that you go to the bar and use a debit card $1.00 surcharge You go to order at the bistro Using debit card 70c surcharge That’s $1.70 before we even sit down This is totally unacceptable Regards Colin Forgot to end on a high The lunch was awesome fantastic meatballs and spaghetti and the wife had an amazing pasta dish The food is always great just don’t like the surcharge Regards Colin

Great place to meet, food is served hot. We wanted to order the seafood platter but you have to ring the day before, we were told so it was fresh , disappointing as all s3afood should be on hand fresh ?

Love the food , very delicious definitely would come again … however I ordered the porterhouse steak mediam- rare, I received a medium well steak… normally it takes me about 10 chews per bite however it took me a solid 38.5 chews.. as I was chewing viciously on the porterhouse I started to stress out and thought I was going to choke and collapse because I was overthinking it too much …Now we can’t have can we? Although love the place! Keep up the great work :) Ps the carbonara geocci was mint!

People were nice, food was average Bread rolls were great. I chose the Ravioli and pumpkin. The sauce was like the contents of pumpkin soup. It was a bit heavy for the dish.

I had a meal with my children and their families at the Bistro. I had Nasi Goreng it was very tasty with the Asian taste twist. It was the Seniors serve it was quite a large meal. The dish featured chicken & prawns with the rice as well as vegetables and of course the Fried Egg 🍳 on top. I enjoyed the meal and a gin and tonic topped off a great evening with my family. Staff were very nice and cleaned the table of the plates and glasses 🥂 as we finished the meal.

Considering how busy it was, the food came with quick (considering we were a table of 20 and the whole place was packed) The dishes were amazing!

Always a lovely meal. Wedges with cheese and bacon fantastic. Fruit salad was disappointing, looked like it was days old every person on our table couldn't eat it. Watermelon even tasted and looked old. Not fresh at all.

I recently had the opportunity to visit Baxter Tavern, and overall, it was a pleasant experience. From the moment I entered the establishment, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The interior had a cozy and rustic charm, which added to the overall ambiance. The service at Baxter Tavern was attentive and friendly. The staff members were knowledgeable about the menu and provided helpful recommendations. They were quick to address any inquiries or requests, ensuring that my dining experience was comfortable and enjoyable. The menu at Baxter Tavern offered a good variety of options, catering to different tastes and dietary preferences. I particularly appreciated the focus on locally sourced ingredients, which added a fresh and flavorful touch to the dishes. The food was well-prepared, with generous portion sizes, and the presentation was visually appealing. One standout aspect of my visit was the selection of beverages. Baxter Tavern boasts an impressive assortment of craft beers and a well-curated wine list. The staff was knowledgeable in suggesting pairings and guiding me through the options available. In summary, Baxter Tavern is a delightful establishment that offers a cozy atmosphere, friendly service, and a well-executed menu. It is an ideal spot for casual gatherings or a relaxing meal. I would highly recommend Baxter Tavern to anyone looking for a quality dining experience in a welcoming setting.

Went to the Tavern for the first time today for lunch and was pleasantly surprised.The welcome, the friendly staff, the atmosphere and the selection of food was excellent. Food came out on time and the dishes were fresh and tasty. Great place to meet up with friends. Will be back.

I have been coming here as a regular with my family for many years now - it's my childhood pub. So, I have been getting the steak and chips every time and it has always been good, but never quite fantastic. However, I hadn't been for some time until recently and may I just say, well done. The chairs got an upgrade, the plates are very aesthetically pleasing and the food has improved greatly! I had a rib-eye steak that was perfectly cooked, the chips have always been great and my steak stayed hot on the heated plate. I'd only fault it for being under-seasoned, and the garlic flavour in the garlic butter was really mild. Apart from that, fantastic! Maybe get rid of the painting of the naked woman on the wall though. This is a great place for families and I was a little disturbed to see it while I was trying to eat. I shall be returning soon. - L

Wonderful four of us had lunch every body was extremely happy. Fair prices. Everybody gave it five stars, 300g Peterhouse medium rare cooked spot on. calamari amazing. Nicest chips I've had in a long time

Nice pub. Have been going there for years. Good food and good service.

Food is fantastic... so good the lounge gets extremely crowded and very noisy...being why we choose to eat in the public bar. Same great food, but at public bar prices. The race callers on the screens are still quieter than the crowd in the next room.

The restrictions meant less people but the staff were pleasant and the food was typical pub grub

Excellent pub with a great selection on the menu. Large size meals and friendly staff. I definitely will be going back again.

My family are I went for a meal last night and was fantastic, the food was great and friendly staff and also a great atmosphere.

Had a great time family get together for a birthday. Food was delicious nice and fresh and we'll cooked. They obviously care about the quality and taste of all their food. Everyone enjoyed their meals. Even all the kids loved it and ate it all, difficult task sometimes 😂. Recommend Baxter tavern great for families friends and couples.

Great atmosphere and a lovely fireplaces in winter. Food quality has fallen slightly. Lower quality seafood seems to be used now. Steaks still good though.

Went for dinner tonight and was looking forward to fish chips and salad but was very disappointed when I got my meal fish and chips and only rocket no tomatoes onion or dressing. That was not a salad especially when you look at the photos of your meals your salads are proper salads. Very disappointed

We celebrated my partners 60th Birthday there today. The food, service and staff were fantastic. Thank you very much to everyone who worked our tables today 😊

Very disappointed as I ordered the salmon and it was over cooked and hard not cooked well. The calamari was frozen in the middle I thought everything was fresh and good but serving food frozen is not on. I would like you to keep everything fresh from now!

Their choice for Vegans and Vegetarions is virtually non-existant. What they offered was blan and unattractive. They are leaving money on the table as I will not be back (and attending with a group of 30 + that go there once a month) till I hear they have raised their game. It is not hard to prepare a few simple mains and desserts that are Vegan friendly... All it takes is some imagination and some pride in your work. They need to look around at what is happening in the mainstream and realise it's 2022. not the 1960s any more. You offer a few choices of mains and desserts that are vegan friendly and anyone can enjoy them. I and many others cannot give you our money if there is simply nothing worth ordering.

Good meals. Homestyle favourites. They do weekly specials and have a salad bar in the bistro which is complimentary with all mains purchased. Quick service. I do recommend booking ahead. The do not supply take away containers. Keep that in mind if you aren't partial to a big meal.

Had a lovely lunch with a sister branch of cwa today. My pizza was fresh flavoured and well cooked. Yummy. Coffee is excellent. The other meals looked great and quite generous. Fire was on and place was cosy.

Stopped in for a bistro lunch with the husband at a whim. Staff are very friendly & informative & the venue has a pleasant ambience. The food is exceptional, from the entree to the salad bar. The only downfall I can pick is there is no kid area, though the majority of lunch patrons were elderly. If I could give them 4.5 stars I would.

Came to the bistro today for lunch with a friend. I had the chef’s special which was a chicken parmigiana with Napoli sauce, spinach, mushrooms and melted cheese on top accompanied with chips and fresh salad of my choice. It was absolutely delicious and plentiful. The staff were lovely and only to happy to be attentive. We will definitely be back soon. Thank you for such a pleasant time.

The staff here are so friendly and accommodating we really enjoy our lunches and when we return are always greeted with a smile. The meals are very generous and tasty with a great variety on offer.

Unfortunately lost stars from me as there was glass in my food ! Management quickly took away the last of the salad they had and informed me they binned it from other customers. However no compensation or apology was given. The space itself is lovely and has many amazing items on view. The open fire places made for a very warm space.

Wonderful venue and meals were beautiful. Our Christmas break up of 13 really enjoyed the lunch, including our wheelchair member. Keep up the good work and see you next time.