Great place to take the friends and family. Super clean inside and the staff is really nice. Also the food is awesome! I love pizza Cottage and I will definitely go back. They also had karaoke going on outside on Friday night. You're looking for more information on that I would call first.

Always A Great Place To Eat! Servers Were Amazing

Excellent as always, pepperoni chips! Super Fresh side salad!, pizza is superb!

Great pizza, Great service, Great experience! We will be back!

Man I do love the pizza but the prices are such a joke anymore and more often my orders are horribly off. $3.69 for a “heaping” order of fries which I’d love to know how that is a heaping order. 9$ for About four and a half chicken tenders is also crazy. Also please fix your website for online ordering, it’s missing a ton of stuff that’s actually on your menu but not available when ordering online. Update 2/11/23: Ordered their pizza again because it had been awhile and thought we would give it another shot. Poor choice. The crust was different. It was paper thin! Why change it?? I noticed another person mentions this below too in another review. It was terrible. We won’t be wasting any money here anymore. There are tons of other solid pizza spots within 10-15 miles that we will support more often.

Love pizza places with arcades from my youth. This location in buckeye lake is far better than Circleville. White pizza was the favorite over Sicilian extra cheese pie. Red sauce is a little sweet for me. Good choice for buckeye lake.

Good place by the lake for good pizza. I had the BBQ chicken and definitely enjoyed it. The patio is small and the carpet needs replaced but this place has a real good home-town feel.

Placed a $30 order through door dash and didn’t receive our salad. I also ordered my pizza well done and I got it light baked. I called Pizza Cottage and asked if the salad was included in the order that was picked up. The person answering the phone cut me off and I heard him arguing with someone and then the manager got on the phone. She was rude from the get go and said because she didn’t have a salad in her cooler they must have sent it. Door Dash credited my account so this isn’t about the money. My daughter was missing half her dinner. I’ve been going to this Pizza Cottage since I was a kid. They have always had the most friendly and courteous employees. My sister worked there for almost twenty years. The previous owner was a family friend. I can honestly say this is the first time in forty years I’ve ever received such terrible customer service from the Buckeye Lake Pizza Cottage. Whoever the night manager is, change your attitude Lady.

First of all I'll start by saying I've always loved pizza cottage. I worked at one for many years. My experience this time at buckeye lake location was terrible. Subs came out right away pizzas came 45 min later and our server we only saw 3 times in the 2 hours of visiting. The pizza was cold once it came as well. I think winter fest was the same day so maybe by 5pm they were just eschatology but something needs to change. Get it together or business will dwindle.

No one even comes close especially BLT pizza 🍕. No one does top n bottom crust. I've been hooked since 1986 as a teenager. When I visit dad I must have it to take home 🏡

Celebrated my sons birthday today at the Buckeye Lake location, Theresa was our server, she was our server the last time we were there, also, she is the best!!! Always kept our drinks filled and asked if we needed anything, she is great!!! Always love the pizza!! Pizza Cottage is the best pizza anywhere, hands down!!! Love it!! Thanks!!!

Was staying in town on a deer hunt and decided to give it a try. So glad we did! The cheese stick appetizer was huge and the marinara was so good. We had a large pepperoni and sausage. The house crust was thin and crisp, just the way I like it. The toppings and sauce were really good. Each one of the staff were very nice. The young lady who waited on us did a good job. She kept our drinks full and apologized because the appetizer arrived one minute before the pizza came but that was ok because they both were great and we were hungry! One of the best pizzas I have ate. Me and my son couldn’t finish all the large. Highly recommend trying it.

This is the Buckeye Lake location. The overall experience was above average but not excellent. When you first walk in you notice a faint odor, almost musty smell. At first it seemed we were a distraction to the waitress, but she did eventually warm up. We ordered cheese breaksticks, which were slightly burned but just couldn't seem to stop eating them. The Italian sub was amazing. The cauliflower crust white pizza with onion had an amazing flavor, however the crust was slightly overcooked. I would recommend.

Our favorite pizza place with lots of other options, too. Marcus takes great care of his customers. Bbq chicken pizza is our go-to, but pepperoni is great too. Usually get some wings while we wait on pizza.

We were on the way home to Cincinnati from Pittsburgh. We stopped here because we wanted to eat at a place we've never heard of before. The food was really good. I got a salad and spicy garlic chicken wings. The chicken wings were outstanding for sure. My daughter got a small pepperoni pizza and some breadsticks with marinara. She loved it. The place looked really nice. It was nice and clean. The service was really good. I would recommend this place for sure. And the prices were decent as well.

Great pizza!! Some wait staff were in training and the newbies were left standing around. There are times when they run without a hostess, which puts strain on the wait staff to stay on top of things. Maybe the managers are new? Went here twice this week and it was a bit unorganized.

The pizza was really good. The server was very nice and helpful. She was also the manager. They have a sign posted that they need help. That's the reason I went in to eat. However, you apply online. When I did, it only allowed you to put in 2 jobs. The 3rd job I would have added was the one that would have probably landed me the job since I used to cook for Tommy's Pizza. I would order their pizza again. Up there with the best pizza I've ever had.

Went there on a whim after passing it, being in town for the first time. It was an absolute delight! Pizza was fantastic, one of the best I have had. Dianne (I believe) and Tabbi, were both amazing servers. Friendly, gave recommendations and gave us sauces to try, since we were new. Most definitely will be back.

Tonight was not good. Long time patron. Tonight, we ordered online, and we're told it would be 35 minutes for pickup. When my wife arrived to pick up dinner, the drive-thru employee indicated she had no idea where our food was or how long it would take to be complete. We finally got our pizza an hour after the order was placed and it was cold upon pickup. I also understand the manager was yelling at the employee(s) at the time. Not a great way to run a business.

The pizza crust was over done around the edges and hard as a rock. It left cuts in my mouth. It was super salty. I won't buy P C again. Cristy's has way better tasting pizza with excellent crust.

The pizza is my favorite but don't try to call on a weekend night because they won't answer the phone. So if you don't dine in they want online orders, which I think are bad because the food is always made ahead of time, and it's never as fresh touch management is changed over the years so now it's not nearly run as nice as it was in the 70's through the early 2000's. The pizza's still the same recipe. It's awesome but dine in it's worth the wait.

Service and pizza was great! We heard good things about the BLT pizza and it did not disappoint. Santa Clause unexpectedly dropped in too and our toddler lost her mind!! It was wonderful!!!!

We got 3 pizzas yesterday and I picked them up in the drive thru. The lady was so nice! The pizzas were delicious. Especially the Spicy Thai Chicken! Highly recommend.♡

Great ladies working here, super sweet! Food was excellent and beer was cold!

After a day out on buckeye lake, pizza really is the best thing ever. We rolled in a bit late on a Sunday evening, the place was super clean, and staff was really friendly. Pizza was delicious, and came pretty quickly. Overall really great experience and would absolutely go there again.

Took awhile for someone to come to our table, no one even acknowledged us. Once our server did come by, our service was great. She was very attentive and would check back. Food was hot and delicious.

Tried this place for the first time over whe weekend and they have some of the best wings I have ever ate in my life. Waitress was very polite and kept our drinks full the whole night. We even ate supper there 2 nights in a row.

It wasn't crowed we just went in and found a seat. The order takers were right there "fast" my italian sub was super. Had a side of fries crisp and hot. Wife got a 7in pizza. It was good too. No complaints here. It a super place to eat

Excellent pizza and great service dine in or carry out this place has been consistently good for years

5 minutes right now in wait for food, understandable. Straws can be quite “. Expensive “ maybe. But mine broke with barely and rotation of it. I’ll update you later. Has a nice outside area as in the photo. A salad didn’t take long, of course. Let’s see what is next. Also, Wait for your food please, no need for 1 star review. Now let’s see how long my other foods take. Took at most 9 minutes.

Haven't gone to pizza cottage for awhile. ...ordered a Italian sub 4 dinner today needles to say I'll NEVER GO THERE AGAIN!!!!!! Spent 10$ for 2peices of bread a pinch lettuce 3 tomatoes the size of a nickel 3 hot peppers and I don't think there was slim to no cheese needless to say where's the meat other than that tasted good but if that's standard ur subs r sinking ......