I was happy to see the sign vegan pizza when I was looking for something quick to bite. The vegan pizza was made to order. They have really good vegan pizza. I ordered personal size pizza which I was expecting to be small size. The personal size is huge. I could only eat half a pie. I also had the Caesar salad which is huge too. It was really good Caesar salad too.

Stopped in to Michelino's for lunch today... and what a great decision it was! I tried the Ziti with meatballs and garlic bread! Seriously ... it knocked my scarpadella's off! The customer service was amazing and John the owner personally made sure everything was on point. I highly recommend Michelino's In Rahway!

I started coming to Rahway frequently a few months ago. I found Michelino's by chance after coming off the train, and as soon as I went inside, it was an awesome atmosphere. The restaurant was clean and the food was nicely displayed, and everyone working there wore masks. The person that served me is named Lenny. He is lovely! He helped me right away, and brought my food over to the table with a smile on his face, to boot! Everyone there is really nice. The girls that worked there were all awesome, as well. I met the owner, John Michelino, for the first time tonight. What a great guy! Salt of the earth. The prices there are good, and more importantly, the pizza is AMAZING! I go to TONS of pizza places while traveling... and this place, honestly, is one of my top 3 favorites. Would highly recommend it! Another thing I love is that they are involved in the "Rahway Taste Passport" initiative in town. Definitely worth a quick look at rahwayishappening.com and vote for them! I like to promote local business, and loved this idea. Thanks guys! - Avery

I used to live in the Bronx and recently moved to Rahway. I love the place but hated that I couldn’t find any good pizza. After living in NY it’s hard to find pizza like what I had there. I drove my husband nuts going to different pizza spots only to be disappointed over and over again. Then a coworker told me about Michelino’s and my life in Rahway will never be the same. When I called for delivery John was so pleasant and extremely helpful. It was like calling a family member. The pizza was fresh, had the perfect amount of cheese and the crust was thick and soft. I am extremely satisfied and have found my go to pizza spot.—- DEE

NOW THIS IS REAL VEGAN PIZZA!!! 🍕 Guys, I have found the New Jersey holy grails of pizza! I am super excited to have stumbled across this pizza spot in Rahway. The service was immaculate & the vegan options were amazing! The fact that the pepperoni vegan pizza & garlic knots tasted like they were made with love & specifically just for me is mind boggling. 😩😋 The vegan cheese was perfectly melted & the personal size / crust were so tasty. The garlic knots were warmed to perfection & served with a yummy marinara that was finger licking good!! I had the pleasure to meet the owner which was the sweetest & very informative when it came to the food options. The scenery was the cutest. A mixture of greenery & old school comfy seating with wall art frames that were perfect for the eatery ambience. The restroom literally had a homey feel & was super clean along with the rest of the establishment. Do yourself, your kids, your family & friends the favor of stopping by here. You won’t regret it! I will definitely be returning. Thank you so much guys!!

Michelino's has always and will always be a staple of the rahway community. The pizza is to die for and there extensive menu is perfect. Thank you for all that you guys do for our community and the school district.

The food is delicious and the prices are very reasonable. My family loves their garlic knots and their pizza never dissapoints. The Buffalo chicken slice is always my go-to. The location is conveniently located, service is fast and friendly.

I love this place. Came here with my family and everybody were so nice and it felt like home. The manager and counter girl were amazing. I didn’t take pictures of the food because we were starving but trust me when I say there was no food left over. It was delicious!!! Definitely coming back again!! Also is this a byob? It would be great if it was

I Love Michelinos! From pizza to pasta Delishh and the Staff make you feel very welcome. Amazing Service

It was a pleasure speaking with you John about my concerns. I hope the issues you’re having with the employees get resolved to bring more customers coming to your business. The different type of garlic knots are definitely something worth having to be made to order! I look forward to meeting you soon! Update: After meeting John, I must say what a well rounded man and family. He cares about his business and wants to do right by his customers. I will definitely be visiting more often because of this. Thanks John for treating me and my son like family! Looking forward to seeing you in the future! Current update 12NOV2022 : Wow John out did himself again the food was so good my son ate a slice before I could take the picture! Thank you John for once again treating us like family! Hope to see you in the future with your buddy schedule!

Staying at the nearby hotel for work this was an excellent option for dinner after a long day travelling. Ordered take out and thoroughly enjoyed my food while watching football. Staff were very friendly, highly recommend.

Met the owner John who is such a nice guy. Pizza is delicious and the customer service is on point. It’s the second time I called for a pizza, and they already knew my name and had all of my information in the system before I said anything. Definitely a nice touch.This is my go to place for pizza hands-down.

Uh Oh It's Magic. After a busy morning of rescuing jalousie window panes, I worked up quite an appetite. I could smell the pizza being made & it was delightful. I ordered my meal but was quickly invited to dine in. John, the owner, was amazing. He seems to be a genuinely nice guy. He makes you feel welcomed. I ordered 3 slices of the white cheese pie. There are fresh seasonings to add to your food (parmesan, red pepper flakes, italian seasonings and a host of others). They were loose and free flowing in their containers. My meal came quickly and hot. I sat and watched the Lionel Richie concert while eating my delicious meal. My pizza was flavorful and fresh. I enjoyed a cranberry grape drink to wash down my meal. I was offered a box to take my leftovers. The conversation with John and his team was comfortable and free flowing. I truly felt refreshed as I left. Oh I can't forget the bathroom. It was CLEAN and beautifully decorated. It's probably is the best bathroom in the city🙏🏽. This is a huge plus. Please Michelino's of Rahway, keep doing what you are doing. You are a favorite in my book.

I just moved to the area and I've been here a few times. Prices are very good and my kids love the pizza. They have a good number of vegan options as well, which I liked a lot. The staff is always pleasant and helpful. I plan to continue coming here.

As a native New Yorker, Michelino’s in Rahway compares to the best pizzerias in NYC. The food always comes out hot and fresh and the staff always delivers efficiently with a smile. You can tell the owner takes a lot of care in matching the staff to his own core values. The environment is comfortable, almost like going into his home. Lots of plants, bench seating, a nice TV with music videos, cartoons, and trivia, as well as one of the cleanest ‘fun to read’ bathrooms. If you’re planning to visit, order ahead and take a seat for a while. Michelino’s loves to host and offer a meal only they can make.

Where do I start? Fantastic customer service and food, was treated well by all employees and had the most unique slice I’ve ever seen. The general Tsos slice is definitely a hit, kudos to Agustin the chef. I stepped in as I know Michelinos from Elizabeth and this shattered all my expectations. John the owner greeted me and held conversation with me throughout, Dana was very polite as well offering great service. What started as a quick bite while waiting for return train ended up with not just the slice, but a half pie of slices on the house and a chance to charge my near dead phone for a bit before leaving. Completely changed my night, good people exist in this world and tonight definitely reminded me that! Showered in kindness with nothing expected in return couldn’t recommend more!!!

First time here... Visiting from NC Staff very friendly. Had 7 different slices and garlic knots... Everything was great . No complaints..I will definitely be back The Owner John was awesome he came to our table and talked to us for a bit and have my kids Cookies...

Stopped in for lunch while in the area for work with a small group of coworkers. There were plenty of options for slices, and among us we pretty much tried all of them - ranging from veggie to buffalo chicken wing. The pizza was great, and the staff was incredibly friendly and attentive. The owner was highly engaged and brought us a round of Italian pastries for dessert - they were delicious. We definitely enjoyed our visit, and would recommend to anyone in the area. Great food, and great people.

The pizza is AWESOME and so is the customer service! Very easy to get to and park if you need to pick up (parking lot on the side). Interesting options, especially for anyone who wants to try something plant based or vegan. We got a pizza with broccoli rabe, non-dairy cheese and plant-based sausage and it was amazing!!

Located steps from the local train station . We walked in the door and felt like family. We were greeted by Jeanna and John . The shrimp parmigiana , fried zucchini and fried calamari were superb . Authentic Italian dishes & sides were prepared fresh and served hot . And what treat to have the Oreo zeppolis we found that they had three other flavors , Nutella , plain and , cream. If you are planning a fun day trip like me . Make sure you add a meal at Michelino’s

Great small pizza place. The pizzas are delicious. I have not had their dinner plates or sandwiches in many years so i can not give my opinion on those. Prices are higher then most pizza shops in Rahway. But i would recommend the pizza, the place has some parking and is a clean and safe pizza shop.

Perfect food with perfect quality and perfect service! I have been eating Michelino’s for years and the Rahway location is the best there is. John and his staff have wonderful personalities that always make you want to come back for a pleasant experience! I highly recommend this pizzeria, you won’t regret it.

Let me tell you. I have been in the military for a Decade. I have been to many different geographic locations, with many different pizzerias. Growing up in Rahway I knew that the Buffalo Chicken Pizza here hit different. I have traveled across many nations on a journey to find a slice that even competes…….. NOTHING ! I couldn’t not be any more serious when I say……Michelinos in Rahway has THE BEST Buffalo Chicken pizza on the Earth bro!

I ordered 2 large pie for Mother's Day, the pie we're so delicious. I remember Michelino's yesterday. It was so hot to cook I decided to ordered eggplant parmesan w/spaghetti so good and with garlic bread included. The lady behind the counter was very nice. I would highly recommend Michelino's to all.

We bought takeout pizza and a Caesar salad with chicken. To our surprise we started eating the salad and the lettuce was brown, we couldn't even eat it had to pluck out the chicken so at least that didn't go to waste. Did they not see the old brown lettuce? It's a simple process, the only reason we gave it 3 stars was because the chicken and pizza was good, otherwise they would have gotten 5 stars. Be careful when you order a salad that they don't put the wasted old lettuce.

Michelino's food is beyond awesome in addition to their exceptional hospitality. There are many eatery's in Rahway but I love their food the most. I've lived in Rahway for six years and Michelino's was my first stop. Pictured below is the Buffalo chicken wrapped in bread & baked Ziti w/meatballs. Very tasty. I highly recommend this establishment. You won't be disappointed at all. Beautiful & friendly environment. John, the owner, is very kind as with the rest of the staff. 5+ stars. Wanda J