So happy to see Jimmy's reopened after the fire. Jimmy's has now become a restaurant with a bar instead of a bar that serves food. They have done an excellent job redoing the building they are now in. The service was excellent, as our waitress checked on us frequently but not as to be pesky. We came for Jimmy's pizza and it was delicious. With the expanded menu- we'll be back for more. We did try the Portabella mushroom sticks and they were very good. The only downside has to be the parking as it's very limited.

We go to Jimmy's usually twice a week and love it! Jimmy, Deb, & Katie are the best and we love to drink and dine at the bar with Stephanie! Great service, atmosphere, food, and prices. When around Galesburg I encourage you to try it out!

Always delicious food! The Betty White on Texas toast is amazing! Best pizza in town! We love the owners and staff, they treat everyone so well. You don't leave hungry either! Fantastic variety at the bar, too.

Great menu selection and a friendly service. We had food delivered to Reserve Artisan Ales. The John Wayne and Al Capone burgers are really good, but everything on the menu sounded delicious. They do offer a kid’s menu. The macaroni bites appetizer is a great addition to a meal.

Tried their pizza for the first time - not too shabby! Love the inside, beer could have been colder, but other than that I’d recommend trying it out!

Pretty good pizza. My only issue was the green pepper and onion seemed to be rather large pieces. I would have preferred if they were dices up finer. It did take awhile to get my pizza. I would certainly go back. Friendly staff and great atmosphere. Parking is not the best.

Great pizza. Great atmosphere. Great service. Pizza came out quick loaded with toppings and our drinks were always filled. Can't wait to come back!

Ordered pizza for delivery and it arrived hot and appealing. Loved the ample cheese and toppings . However when you start into it, the sauce tasted like someone dumped the sugar bowl in it . The sauce was sweet enough to cancel out any tomato flavor. On a side note ,the crust could have baked a little longer as it was doughy. Had the sauce not been so sweet, the pizza would have been great ! Happy Joe's and Pizza Hut should put toppings on like this !

Title: Quick and Tasty Bite Near Amtrak Station! Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) I recently stopped by Jimmy's Pizza while waiting at the Amtrak station across the street, and it was a delightful surprise! Firstly, I have to mention our server, A.M.B. She was incredibly friendly and attentive throughout our meal, making the experience all the more enjoyable. I decided to try something different and went for their burger and fries, and let me tell you, it was worth every penny of the $11.32. The burger was juicy and flavorful, and the fries were perfectly crispy. A great choice for a quick and satisfying meal. If you're ever in the area and need a good place to grab a bite, Jimmy's Pizza, with its convenient location across from the Amtrak station, is definitely worth a visit. Fast, friendly service and delicious food – what more could you ask for?

Neat atmosphere. Great service and great food. Lots of sandwiches and pizza to choose.

We were inquiring about certain things on the taco, one person in the party we had is vegan and wanted something special taco no meat/ and clearly our waitress didn't get it, it wsn't really busy and so we ordered 2 large p izzas we eneded up with 1 large pizza and an order of onion rings. This was not at all a good experience and we will not return.

First time at Jimmy's Pizza. My family and I were impressed with the decor and atmosphere there. Our waitress was attentive and accommodating, the pizza and haystack onion rings was amazing. Great vibes & staff in the vibrant atmosphere at Jimmy's Pizza. We will be back for sure!

It has been a long, too long since I had ate at Jimmy's. Back in the W days. Still is the Best pizza and I've been around the world. Ate some good slices. Great service also See ya's soon

Have been here a handful of time for lunch, and everytime the pizza was delicious! I have also been here for dinner a time or two with my wife where we tried the pulled pork nachos and the pretzels. Overall, everytime I have been here, I have left satisfied. I just wish the pizza crust was a bit crisper.

My first time at Jimmy’s and I had heard the pizza was good. I had high expectations. The place was nice, service was great and staff very friendly. The pizza itself was less than desirable. The sauce tasted like some sort of a barbecue sauce and a very bad one at that. So sad….. really hated to say this.

We ordered wings, tenderloin, and burger. Everything was fine. It wasn’t the “best” place I’ve been, but there was absolutely no issues. It was what you would expect from a small town pizza joint. Next time we may need to try the pizza since that’ is what it’s known for

We’ve loved Jimmy’s for years. I decided it was time to put my love in writing. This local business has great food - let’s get that out of the way. We’ve never had a bad meal there and particularly their pizza is always a home run. Our last visit we had this basket of spicy onion rings with jalapeños. Delish! One of the great things about Jimmy’s is that just so cool inside. The decor is retro and funky and interesting and fun. I think that’s why we just love it there! You won’t be disappointed if you go to Jimmy’s!

Great tenderloin! The wait staff was friendly and attentive. We didn't have to wait or even ask for refills, they would show up even before the last few sips. Definitely would go back!