Small neighborhood gem. Friendly service, very good food, reasonable prices. Only critique would be the chicken marsala needed a bit more salt but still very good.

I was at the hospital nearby because of my sons birth and I asked the nurses where they typically order Italian from and they said this place primarily and one other place. Well there seemed to be good reviews so we went with Antonino’s. They were nice on the phone, the delivery guy was nice and there were no mistakes with the order. They provided plates and utensils like we asked too. We ordered a tray of the rigatoni Al a Vodka, Calamari, and the rice ball supreme. My wife said that she enjoyed the rice ball (I didn’t try it). The calamari unfortunately was very over cooked, and when they prepped the squid they never removed the pen (spine, plastic like material) and it was throughout the majority of the pieces except for the tentacles. The other thing I found was something green melted on a piece of calamari, and when I looked in the container, there was something white and plastic with green writing that had the word “product” on it that was melted in the fryer with my food. The calamari was very well seasoned but it only needs to be cooked for 1-3min depending on the temp so that it’s tender but it was like chewing on rubber. The pasta was a bit over cooked too so it had no bite to it and the sauce did not taste like a vodka sauce, but more like a sherry cream sauce. The flavor wasn’t bad, but not what my kids expected from a vodka sauce. Unfortunately there were many small mistakes that makes me feel the kitchen staff do not put much care or concern into the product they are serving so I can’t see myself ordering here again.

Use to order from Antonio all the time, but recently they’re being real cheap making the crust so thin with less cheese, so the crust was burned. I also had Alfredo pasta and the sauce tastes like it came from a can sauce. I will never order from this place again.

Service was excellent. Food was very tasty. Went there randomly to try out italian foods, and found it to be a good place with good service and foods!

This is a very tasty establishment. All the food is incredible and I like that the pizza is made very thin but with a lot of cheese so I don’t gain extra calories!

A classical authentic Italian restaurant. The food is delicious. The service is friendly and the price is reasonable. Next time I should try their yummy pizza.

Don't think I've ever ordered something bad off the menu. From appetizers to desserts the food is some of the best I've had on Long Island. Great food, friendly staff, clean silverware and facilities. Parking lot a bit of a hassle to get into and out of but worth it. Highly highly recommend.

I don't want to give this gem of a place a recommendation because then i will never get a table. Yes I am selfish. Sorry.

Utterly disgusting. Don't waste a single penny here. Ordered a pie of barbecue chicken with onions only to receive a disturbing Mashup of uncooked onions with a hot pink ketchup like sauce on the bread. I have never seen anything like it. Everyone I order form here the chicken is dry and everything is under seasoned. It's like their scared to touch spices. I'm warning allyuh to not bother with this place.

Great lunch entree. Meatball Parm,Caesar salad and a little dessert. Good meatballs,side Caesar salad. Tight parking alongside restaurant but prompt service and decent prices. Overall good experience. Will return when back in the area.

The staff is so kind and courteous. They are respectful and patient whenever I call for phone orders. The food is delicious and they give ALOT! Big portions and high quality Italian food. Top notch. Great price. Warm hospitality. This is an amazing spot for Italian food! I always order from here and have never been disappointed. Great customer service as well.

Delcious, we started off with the fried calamari appetizer. I had the Eggplant Rotini, Maria had the chicken marsol. Two more in our party enjoyed their meals selected from the 3 Course Menu. We finished off dinner with the Canoli. Fresh crisp shells and excellent filling. Our meal in total averaged out to 50$ a person.

This restaurant is the one I always prefer. I go to many restaurants but to this one I constantly return again and again. The team is very chummy and the food they offer is so delicious. I never decline to have a good dinner in this restaurant. I highly recommend this place.

Extensive menu. Tasty food. Friendly service.

Delicious food and some great prices, and friendly service

By far one of the best Italian joints in Nassau County. Their tortellini alfredo and chicken marsala were simply perfect and the sauces were well made and not overpowering—something all too common nowadays.

Great food, wonderful attentive staff. There pasta sauces are delicious and their pizza is possibly the best in the area. The also indoor seating that is separated with vinyl sheeting separation tables. Truly a wonderful place. I highly recommend Antoninos to anyone looking for a romantic dinner or just a quick bite.

Great hole in the wall restaurant! The grilled calamari and chicken marsala are delicious. Highly recommended!

Came here starving. Parked in the lot. “Sit wherever you want.” Prixe-fix lunch, $22. Plenty of delicious food, lots of choices. Perfect service. What more can you ask?

I celebrated my nomination this evening in this excellent restaurant. Well we enjoyed a enjoyable evening and the restaurant was evidently one of the reasons for the happy evening. The crew helped in a splendid manner, the meals were very good and my buddies were very delighted. We shall surely come back again for more celebrations. thanks very much.

Simple , cozy, and just get right down to the business of authentic Italian food. The restaurant was packed on a Tuesday evening, yet we were accommodated with seating. Get the rice balls for an appetizer.

Delicious standard Italian cuisine. They have a great prix fixed and family style portions if you come in a group. I loved the bread pin wheel in the bread basket.

Grabbed a grandma pie to go recently, strange pie, I think sliced cheese rather than shredded but the worst part is it was ice cold, basically congealed

Picked up a regular slice and a Caesar salad. The regular slice was solid. The grilled chicken caesar salad was not good. The grilled chicken was overcooked and not seasoned, no salt or pepper on it.

One of the tastiest pizzas I’ve had so far. Grilled calamari were fresh and also off the charts. Give them a try you won’t regret it.

Quaint little place, I think it's a great delivery place more than a dine-in in my opinion.

Amazing Risotto

Good pizza

Amazing

My family has been coming here for 20 years, it’s delicious, good prices, good service. We love Antonino’s!

Family and I had eaten here for the first time and believe me it won’t be the last. Each entires were well prepared and had authentic taste. Very friendly service. I have recommended Antonino’s to many friends and families. Go out and eat at the Antonino’s, you will enjoy every bite.

Cozy place, nice service, tasty food. My family and I had a lovely Saturday lunch.

It's a nice neighborhood haunt with large portions very low seasoning. But it was not my cup of tea.

Linguini with clam sauce, penne alla vodka, chicken bruschetta are delicious.

Cozy location. Staffs were friendly and the lunch portions are good enough portion. Really liked it very much overall.

The sauce here is fantastic. Lunch special was wonderful with a very fair price. Terrific service. Very cozy place. One of our new favorites

We don't get a chance to visit often enough, but so far inconsistent quality , differs each time. Never bad, just not as..previous visit

Always great , Best Broccoli Rabe anywhere, Very friendly staff from the cooks to our amazing waiter , been a customer since they opened in 1997 and will continue…..🏆

Always great food. Had take out last night. DELICIOUS

I ordered pasta the other day and they were super delicious . The delivery guy was so friendly and kind, i think his name was Izo. Gave him a big tip by the way. Cudos to this amazing restaurant !!!!

One of the BEST places in the town .Thank you for delicious food and THANK YOU for Managers and all team .You guys really hard workers. I would suggest every one to try this real tasty piece of Italy in New York.

Been here at least a few dozen times over the years. Always friendly service, and food is great. Pasta is always cooked perfectly, aldente, and generous with the sauce! The calamari is fried crispy and not greasy. My comparison is always chicken Parm, and they do a wonderful job with it. Chicken is moist and tender, with melted cheese on top, smothered with just the right amount of sauce... Enough that you want to take the bread they give you and save some to clean the plate. I'm not really a salad person, but they make some really good salads, and their pizza is probably in the top 5 in a 10 mile radius. They also do the right amount of toppings; covered, but not so covered you can't lift the pizza. Tortufo is my favorite dessert. It is vanilla ice cream, with toasted almonds and s cherry, all covered with a chocolate exterior shell. They cut it open for you so that it's easier to eat (or shared)! My experience has been cheaper to call and order, over Uber eats. (Faster too!) They are very close to Northwell healh.

Pasta cold. Meatballs not made of real meat (bland/tasteless too). Tomato sauce also tastes bad. Garlic bread stale. Don’t recommend. They also packed the food incorrectly.

I come to this unique place once a month because I enjoy the ambiance that is outline this restaurant. The personel is very friendly and experienced. The service is exceptionally efficient. Needless to say, the food they cook is magnificent. I frequent many times and I was always joyful. The price is reasobable. I highly suggest this place to my friends and family.

Always wanted to try this place ever since moving around here. They always have people dining in. Food was good but the pizza is way better! I would definitely try the restaurant again.

I ordered chicken parm dinner and sausage and pepper dinner. Both with salad, pasta and seltzer. They did not deliver the salad the sauce was bland the side pasta was bland, the best part of the dinner was the seltzer.

I certainly liked their dishes and service, awesome location very close to my house. The staff members are always super friendly. Will come visit again.

So disgusting. Everything we got was inedible. Used to be our favorite Italian restaurant.

The customer service is consistently quick, fantastic mood, welcoming employees. Will return here again when I get nearby.

We love to go out. Last night we visited this delicious place which we didn’t know before. We spent a delightful evening there with excellent dishes and a nice crew and a professional cuisine. We put this venue in our phone list and we shall surely come back very soon. We highly recommend.

Very good Italian restaurant, moderately priced and the food is freshly made.

Great pizza, the walnut salad with avocado was awesome! Raspberry dressing delish! Great wait staff. The bread was dry and hard, serve it with some olive oil instead of butter.

Friendly staff!! Great food. Had it delivered with no problems!

Great pizzia

Omg!!! Their lasagna is phenomenal first time eating here and it wont be the last

I loved , delicious food, good service, we will back.

Always delicious. You can buy their salad dressing. Sometimes the service is slow.

Best Italian food in LI .Delicious meals ,pizza is amazing also very friendly staff. I highly recommend the place.

As always it was delicious

Great food and beverages. Service impeccable! Our second visit, will definitely be back!

Good food. I Love the pizza.

Wonderful and warm place

Parking can be a challenge...

the pizza was ok the delivery driver was rude about not getting a tip and it brings back bad memories of a weird kid ripping the chesse off the pizza

First time going snd it was good

Awesome spot to eat food when in a hurry. Their service is quick, rates are affordable, awesome vibes. Will come back again

We came Sunday afternoon and had the special app/ pasta or soup and choice of main entree but o somehow expected a more flavorful from this place but very ordinary and typical pizzaria just ok

The place serves big portions and for reasonable rates. super friendly owner. Highly recommended.

I've had food (mostly takeout) over the years from here when I visit the area. Nice food, reasonably priced. The Alla Vodka is great. And they have gluten free pasta, which is good.

Great food, great people

The service is outstanding. The food is delicious and includes an amazing tasting menu with flavorful greens and tender proteins.

Good food but very plain

Great small Italian restaurant. Great prices and decent portions. Attentive staff

Great service great food

Good food. It's a small restaurant with small seating. Parking is a bit of a pain. I'd definitely take food out but, probably not eat there again.

Consistently good food and services

My favorite place to enjoy a slice, toasted almond, or really anything here is just amazing. Unfortunately, I'm no longer in LI and I haven't been there since COVID but I can guarantee and I don't do many guarantees, its6wirth the trip.

I would never order from this place again I ordered.. a chicken parm hero the bread taste old and wasn’t toasted at all Mozzarella sticks they were not cooked & discolored not even hot The baked clams were not hot The baked raviolis were all over the place The two cokes were even warm You guys are literally .7 miles from the hospital how is everything cold except the cokes ? smh 60 dollars what a waste of money yes the delivery was quick but I’d rather you take the time to make the food the right way then rush it out to me and have it like this horrible at this point I’m thinking I should have just stuck to the hospital food. I wouldn’t even give one star but I have no choice. Smh