Don't judge this book by its cover. The best fried buffalo wings I've ever had! Inside you'll find a menu with everything from WestMex, Cubano, Grilled Cheese and everything fried chicken. The fries with Cajun seasoning were also excellent. Cool Colorado vibe, family friendly, delicious food, outside seating, and friendly staff. It was the perfect place to grab a quick but A+ dinner on our way through.

Otto’s in Fairplay has the same fire 🔥 food as the food truck in Alma. I love the chicken sandwich the best but have tried absolutely everything here. The owner sources food locally as much as possible. There is a large parking lot here so wheelchair access is easy. Plenty of room for a large family and is a wheelchair accessible facility. They have local artwork for sale on the walls inside. I have never waited more than 15min for an order here no matter how busy it is. The customer service here is also top notch and “Colorado friendly!” Thanks for all the delicious food, I will be a customer for life.

Music is a little loud. Steak and egg burrito was delicious! Steak had no fat and seasoned well. Fries were homemade and delicious. Pulled pork was a little spicy, no fat, very meaty.

An awesome find! Lots of fun food and gluten free options too! We had the colossal chicken and the classic chicken sandwich with a side of fries which were done to perfection- all of it!

We’ve been blazing through Fairplay repeatedly over the last couple months going to Denver for training from the Western Slope, about a six hour run. This was the 1st time we pulled in and into Otto’s Fairplay it was. I’ve eaten Philly Cheesesteaks in south Philly hundreds of times years ago and these were about as close to Philly as I’ve had since. Hands down THE BEST in Colorado. My wife had the Special Chicken Sandwich and it was a thick ol slab of moist and fresh crispy chicken. They’re using fresh and great tasting buns and rolls. The french fry basket was piled high with big ol Sticks of spuds. We waddled out there full and eager to return. So, if your on CO-285 and blazing towards Fairplay, slow down and pull into Otto’s Fairplay and grab a tasty bite!

Very small = very delicious! Great menu! It is in a VERY busy area in Fairplay - but definitely worth the stop.

Great little place in Fairplay. We had breakfast sandwiches, the Mountain Cristo and the Kritzy. Both were amazing with the Cristo offering Sriracha syrup ( yes, it's sweet) and blue berries on a fried egg and sausage. It is a great blend of sweet and savory. This place is small but has good seating outside to enjoy a sunny Colorado day and a number of tables inside if the weather is marginal. The inside decore featured art that could buy. If you're in the area and hungry, be sure to check them out.

Excellent stop on the way to/from Denver. The Cuban and the breakfast burrito were both delicious. Expect it to take slightly longer than typical fast food. It costs more than fast food, too, at $15 for a sandwich with no drink or side. But it's well worth the wait and the cost