I heard about this place from work and went with my Mom for lunch today. This was our first time here and definitely not the last! The atmosphere was welcoming, the service helpful and the food delicious! We got cappuccinos and they were delicious and had pretty art. I had a house salad and the personal size mushroom pizza, while my Mom had chicken noodle soup and the smash burger. The food was absolutely delicious! We also got some cookies and muffins to go. The Brookie is super good it's a brownie/cookie. If you're in East Aurora it's definitely woth a visit!

Snowing outside. Rain or in a very special day with open sun… anyway Elm Street Bakery is one of the best places to be in East Aurora Ny. U can see the “ pizzaiollo “ making a delicious pizza in a few minutes in front of you! Beautiful construction in wood and elegant decoration. Have a good time there

Steven is the Master of Coffee! The quality coffee, not to say the brewed batches aren't excellent in their own regard, is what takes the whole experience to the next level. Good baked items with a good cappuccino. I'll take two, please!

I’ve been coming to this place for a few years every time I’m in the area and the food is absolutely amazing. I can’t say enough about ANY dish or bakery item we tried. Everything tastes amazing! Prices are good and service very attentive and welcoming. The location is also very nicely decorated and cozy.

Amazing selection of baked goods including bread and many pastries. We had the shakshuka from the brunch menu (which features a variety of sandwiches options) and it was very tasty. Lively place on weekend mornings. What a great community destination!

What a cute little bakery this place is. We've passed by here before and they were closed so we made note to come back and I'm glad we did. We got a chocolate chip cookie with their apple bread which was very very good. And then we got a Caesar salad which was a bit pricey at $14. And we also got a personal Pizza cheese Which was delicious.

Elm street is always a must stop everytime I am in East Aurora. The place is always busy so you know the food is good. There are always something new to try on the menu. Bakery items I try to grab when I see them or else they could be gone after my meal. Great place for a quick snack, afternoon coffee and an elegant meal with everything in between. Give it a try. You won't be disappointed!

My husband and I love coming here for breakfast! I usually get black coffee but here I love the cappuccino. The barista makes the drinks look so inviting and pretty!

First time visiting today and can’t wait to go back! Everything was delicious!! It is very hard to find a nice place that checks off everything! Great coffee, amazing pastries with a delicious breakfast menu!! Have not been for lunch but cannot wait! For everyone that says it’s pricey I don’t think that is very fair to say. The quality of food you’re getting is the reason you are paying that price. Which in my opinion portions are perfect and fulfilling. I have paid more for mediocre coffee and pastries at other places. So excited I found this place and can’t wait to bring my friends for our coffee and lunch dates!!!

When you need a quick but good coffee, and some food to eat, Elm Street has you covered. I personally love going for breakfast since their bread is baked fresh in the mornings and it permeates the room nicely, and their coffees are excellent to go or to park it in house. I was recently in to grab baguette for thanksgiving plans, and I am always so pleased with their bread options (even at 10am the day before thanksgiving!).

This place is so cool. The old building, the food, the service, and everything else make for a great breakfast/coffee spot. I'm sure they're lunch is good too, but I only had some samplings of the baked goods and coffee.

Really cool spot to eat and hangout with friends. The salami sandwich was just okay, kinda disappointed. But steak sandwich and the potato bacon soup were great!

Came in with a group of friends for lunch on a busy Saturday. The staff helped us all find a spot to sit together and accommodated a few other needs. Everything we had was delicious!

Really cute spot for food and drinks right off Main Street. We came on a busy Saturday and had to wait in a bit of a line to order and then again to get food but overall was very fast considering. There is plenty of seating and the staff is very friendly. Food was phenomenal, especially obviously the bread in the sandwiches and the other baked goods. The bread had a great crust and just the right amount of firmness to support the contents of the sandwich. Both the Cuban and the Philly were very flavorful and well balanced. It is a bit pricey but worth it for the experience and quality of food. Would highly recommend if you find yourself in East Aurora. 4.8/5 -BJ

Was taken on a surprise breakfast date and this place was super cute! We went on a weekend and it was very busy with people and families constantly coming in and out. Ordered a couple breakfast sandwiches, pastries, and a latte. Wish the sandwiches were warmed up (maybe we just had to ask?), but overall everything tasted really good. Would definitely stop in again to get more pastries and another coffee!

The atmosphere was fantastic. You could sit outside or sit inside, and the staff were very friendly and helpful. I ordered a hot item and it was good, and when my companions ordered some breakfast sandwiches, they did not realize that they were pre-prepared, and not made on the spot. That was a little bit disappointing for them, but the food was still good. Maybe it mentioned that on the menu, but we did not see it. We will definitely go back.

I loved this place!! Everything from food and drinks to service are top notch. There's a speak easy that is open Thursday through Saturday from 5pm-10pm so we definitely have to come back for that. We were there at breakfast time. The lattes are amazing and cute too (the cups and the swirl on top)! The Market is also so cool and the sweet treats are so yummy!! Highly recommend!!

This gem in East Aurora is a must visit not just for the delicious baked goods but also the well crafted drinks and flavor packed dishes on the menu. On our visit we tried the oysters, octopus, pizza and sandwiches. All of which were superb. I was more than impressed with the octopus which was cooked to perfection and paired perfectly with the sauce and potatoes it came with. And the plating and service did not go unrecognized. Looking forward to trying more of what they offer on my next visit.

Who doesn't want a rustic chic bakery with fresh breads, pastries, non run of the mill food and amazing coffee... Wait did I mention the coffee. That man that makes that coffee, he has magic, coffee shouldn't taste that good and he is pleasant and the conversation while you wait for your coffee is superb. Ladies at the counter are always helpful and always nice. Great for a coffee with Friends or grab a bite to eat. Outdoor seating with fire cooked pizzas...also a must after a stroll from surrounding shops.

All I had was the blackberry white chocolate tart, but it was really good. Will definitely go back and try some other things. * The dent in the tart was from me, not the bakery.

Elm St is a hub of community in EA- the barista, Steve, pulls the best cappuccinos and lattes, and honestly puts love and care into every cup. The sourdough is off the hook- they turn it into everything from baguette to English muffins, rye with caraway, and gorgeous, crusty farmers loaves. They make lots of pastries, croissants, cakes, rolls, and cookies- all home made and good quality. The wood fired pizza is thin and tasty, but barring the cup and char pepperoni this pizza is definitely not akin to "Buffalo" style, leaning more towards Farm to Table, with more sophisticated toppings (and a price to match.) They have local brews on tap, nice wine, and a cute evolving food case with gorgeous cakes and local eggs, cheese, and a few of their salads and dressings to go. This place is always busy- but not open Sunday and Monday, so they're missing out on what would probably be a lit Sunday brunch scene. Get there earlier if you want local faves (and mine) like their Jambon beurre sandwich or foccaccias. Expect the basic EA bougie crowd, with a parking lot full of Teslas and Subarus.