Pizza was awesome, as usual, but the service wasn't all it could be. Maybe it was because She was at the end of Her shift? I'm only speculating. I also didn't like that the dining room is way to open. Almost like You are on display. Haha! Sometimes You don't want to hear what the People are talking about 3 tables over. I thought the pie was exceptional though and I would actually go back for another try:)

Absolutely delicious. Ordered a family antipasto and a large stuffed with sausage, garlic and tomato. This was the best pizza crust I've ever tasted. Great flavor with everything we ordered.

These folks did a wonderful job with our large party crowd. The various kinds of pizza, drinks on demand, and cheerful service made the special night all the better. Kudos to you all!

I went here for a birthday/graduation party. Lovely little spot. The food was delicious. The creamy garlic dressing is not too thick and covers a salad nicely. The sausage and peppers are the superstar for me. Never had them taste this great anywhere else. Baked mostoccoli was rich and gave a very home cooked feeling. Chicken was not dry. So this was a plus for me. There were multiple pizzas, but I ate too much of everything else before I got to them. So I can't provide an assessment of the pizza, except that they smelled great.

Meatball sub? A picture is worth a thousand words. Not even edible. Seriously disappointed in an establishment I go to often. This legit looks like a horse took a dump to make this. Tipped $5 on takeout, drive 15 minutes home to see this.

We had the $14.95 buffet. Great salad bar: fresh salad and add ons. Wonderful soup but they ran out so only had 1 small bowl. Hot bar had 4 types of pizza, chicken, Italian sausage, tomato bread, spaghetti (no sauce???). Server came only once after bringing drinks. Next time we will get there more than an hour before closing.

This is my first visit there and I never knew that Aurelio’s Pizza in Crete IL had a Buffet. I did enjoy the video! Price was very affordable and employees are happy!

Their stuffed pizza was fantastic. We are always happy with the quality of the food. If it weren't so expensive we would definitely come more often- but it's worth it every now and then.

I’m not a fan of Aurelio’s pizza at all…never have been. HOWEVER, I went here because my husband is a huge fan. Everyone was so kind and thoughtful as we dined with our toddler.

I go here at least twice a week for lunch with my girlfriend. We get almost the same thing each time. Amazing atmosphere, amazing staff, amazing food. We both absolutely love our waitress Cindy.

Took my daughters here one evening. We had Cindy as our waiter. Clearly she was flustered, don't work well under pressure and is forgetful. We were sitting near a large party who was apparently too loud for Cindy. She came to our table, attempted to take our order but because she couldn't hear (her exact words) because of the loud party near our table, she left and didn't come back until that party was gone. Issue #2, I had to get up twice to find her because it was taking to long for her to bring items I requested. She admitted both times that she forget (she apologized). Final issue, I ordered the birthday girl the kid's meal, pepperoni pizza. When Cindy brought the food, it was all cheese (no pepperoni). I pointed out to her that the pizza was incorrect and was missing the pepperoni. Cindy leaves to go to the kitchen. Instead of bringing the correct order, she brought a bowl of cold pepperoni. WTH?!?! That was the final straw for me!!! I felt insulted with that gesture. This location will never get my business again.

What a great lunch buffet! I hadn't been in years and had forgotten about it. Came in today with my spouse and really enjoyed it. The food was great, service was really very very good (especially for a buffet), and the price was super reasonable. We'll be back for sure!

I had dinner with the Lions. The meal and service was great. I especially loved the hot cherry pie. Mmmmmm

Went there for the lunch buffet and it was great. Pizza, fried chicken, meatballs, pasta and salad. Great atmosphere

Went for the Friday lunch buffet, pizza was very taste, chicken was really good too. It was a great lunch outing.

Loved this placed but lately they can’t even cut a pizza evenly or completely through the crust. Also can no longer use my rewards points for delivery since Aurelio’s now has and online order app you need to use, and Crete doesn’t want to use it. So different pizza places now get my business for delivery.

I have been a good costumer. Go there 3 to 5 times a week. But asked that they change up the buffet a little bit. Instead of plan sausage how about adding some mushrooms told me no that’s the way it is. So Monday and Wednesday buffet same pizza no variety so now maybe I’ll go 3 to five times a month or year. Guess they don’t want my money. Shame is I really liked going there. Well best wishes to all of you’s, take care.