Gotta give them 5 stars for sure! This joint has a gangsteresc feeling. Decked out in all the most famous mobsters America has ever seen. The food was delicious! Ordered 2 personal pizzas and 2 appetizers and both were fantastic, full of flavor! The mushrooms are wild hand picked and battered fresh for the serving! They were hand down the BEST! mushrooms I have ever had! Keep the great food coming guys, good work!

I wanted to try something new, but also close to home. It was only about a 13-minute drive. There was parking when I arrived but it was a slower night. I ordered so many things because I couldn't decide. I absolutely loved the building and how it was designed. Then, the menu also matches the vibe and aesthetic of the restaurant! Had a great time there and will definitely be going back soon. Also, everyone, please try the Italian wedding soup!!! It was awesome!

I ordered the Jalapeño popper cheesy bread, Al Capone sandwich and coconut cake “to go” and let me tell you, my taste buds are going wild. The sandwich is juicy, crispy and flavor packed, the popper bread is cheesy and creamy with a kick and the pie is light and airy (ask for some caramel drizzle and chocolate drizzle like on the brownies and you have a Samoa cookie tasting cake”. The wait times were great considering they are very new and was told understaffed; You never would’ve guessed. Can’t thank the kitchen staff and servers enough for doing what they do to make such a diamond in the rough run smoothly. Can’t wait to go back ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

If you’re looking for an alternative to bar food you must try Mugshots! Only 15 min drive from Buckeye Lake. I had no expectations bc it hasn’t been opened long, but I was very pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere was cool, the staff friendly & attentive but it’s the food that’s going to bring me back! Everything is made from scratch, even the sauces & dressings & you can taste the difference! We started with meatballs - moist, amazing sauce & garlic bread. I didn’t try the bread bc I had the jalapeño poppers cheese bread - spicy & flavorful! The fried pickles with homemade ranch were crunchy & tangy. Our entire group raved about their entrées: cheese burger; chicken Diablo & meatloaf. I can only speak to the Frankie’s spaghetti which I enjoyed very much! Portions are huge so we didn’t have room for dessert but I’m definitely going to try the dessert flight next time!

Went to opening night at Mugshots! Food did not disappoint and service staff was very friendly. Atmosphere was great. Definitely a gem for the small town of Pleasantville, OH.

First time dining in a new restaurant.. so far, so good, we didn't like the old one.. but this time it's all good.. our food was great, the atmosphere is amazing.. menus are wonderful.. we devoured the fried mushroom.. spicy diablo pasta is not spicy at all for me.. but I like the overall taste.. the meatloaf was fantastic too.. our waitress was amazing! (Forget her name, but she said it was her first night working) It's all good. We'll definitely recommend it.

Really good food and the service is excellent. I think we have been 3 x, and it's been good every time.

DO NOT be on a diet when you come here to eat!! LOL. I always enjoy eating at unique places. The atmosphere is very relaxing and the food is very delicious!! The staff and patrons are really friendly. With the exception of their tater tots and ketchup, EVERYTHING is made from scratch. Their pizza is cooked in a stone oven, with a pizza crust not too thick and not too thin. I ordered the mobster meatloaf and all I have to say is yuuuummy!! It is worth the drive!! What made it more personable is one of the owners stopping to talk!!