I’m from STL and now live in the east coast. The average google rating of this place had me thinking I was going to get some great pizza but it’s completely average. Definitely wouldn’t be a hit on the actual boardwalk in Jersey. I’m not saying you shouldn’t try it but if you are like me and curious about the pizza as being “great” based on the high reviews, I can tell you it’s soulless, bland pizza. It wasn’t greasy in fairness so it has that going for it. I won’t be coming back personally. Last point - and this isn’t a huge deal- but I ordered an 18 inch and it measured 17. Best pizza in STL is La Pizza on Delmar or Blackthorne Pub (long wait times). Funny thing is, another pizza place in Ellisville, I think it’s called Pizzarelli, they have what I consider boardwalk style pizza, despite advertising themselves as New York Style.

So good, incredible staff, amazing service and great value prices. I am so happy we stumbled in here and have continued to come back. My wife always craves the wings, my kids love the pizza, and I haven't found anywhere with a better run place especially in recent years of everything being short handed , the crew here is great.

It is a tiny restaurant that serves very mediocre pizza. Nothing seems to be made from scratch. Save yourself the trip and just grab a nice frozen pizza a frozen toasted ravioli. It’s the same thing.

This place is usually really great but the past two times I've ordered delivery the toppings have been wrong on the pizzas. Tonight's Maui Chicken pizza has no chicken.

Delicious pizza! I ordered their boardwalk pizza in 18” for delivery. Pizza arrived in a timely manner, was warm, and had generous amount of toppings on it. No shortcomings whatsoever. Happy customer here. Highly recommended. I’ll return!

Always like to try out different pizza joints. Picked up an 18inch cheese and garlic bread. Both overdone and dry. Bland crust and a generic tasting pizza sauce. It's not NY style at all. Closer in flavor to Marco's pizza chain. Better pizza at Pizzarelli or Chiro's for the area. Still haven't found a real NY slice outside La Pizza in U-City. My hunt in West County continues.

Pizza was great all around. My wife had a gluten free and I had the 12 inch shark attack. Loaded with meat basically. Really enjoyed the Midnight Dreary beer from the adjoining brewery. Certainly would go back. Just a little pricey.

The pizza and wings here are staple, and the new microbrewery addition raise the bar again. I stopped in to pick up my usual order, and stuck around to try a new beer off the tap. Sly behind the counter was great, I highly recommend stopping in.