-Had to edit the review since last pickup tonight. Guy overcharged me. $23 for a regular pie pickup. Even Grubhub charges $17 for a regular pie. Guy even used my picture for regular pie which I have since removed since being overcharged, it’s my home table. If you’re going to order, do it through grub. They don’t honor the online menu prices

My husband tried this place a few months ago to switch things up as we didn’t love the local spots we had been going to and now my kids won’t eat pizza from anywhere else!!! Every time we go there we are greeted by the friendliest staff that go above and beyond to show you the meaning of great service. I mean he even gave my kids free ice cream after their pizza, what a guy! Place is always kept extremely clean and they offer a nice selection. We won’t be getting pizza from anywhere else again! #loyalcustomers

Sal's and Anthony's pizza is the best pizza I have tried on the island the best customer service I ever experienced I highly recommend this place. They will treat you like family visiting their location. Once again I highly recommend go check them out you'll thank me later.. tell them Ace highly recommend you......

I swear by this place. They literally have the best pizza I've ever had and I always point people in this direction. I hate picking up food but, it's so good here I don't mind making the trip. On top of the phenomenal food, the owner is a extremely courteous, hard working and I a overall stand up guy so you really can't ask for a better pizza place

Stopped in for a slice with my wife and son. Ordered reg slices, chicken & tomato slice along with dozen knots. The reg slice was very good with the crust being light along with the sauce having tons of flavor. The chicken and tomato slice was just as good. Can't forget about the knots. For the longest time everywhere just makes rolls and puts on garlic and butter. Not here, they were actual knots. Think I found our new pizza place. And to think we have passed this place for years.

I recently moved to this area and the first time I tried this place was in the summertime for my daughter‘s birthday. They were very professional and polite and everyone enjoyed the pizza. Now I go there pretty frequently and I get the garlic broccoli and chicken pizza which is my absolute favorite!!! They are always very kind, funny, and warm when I walk through the door thank you so much!

Went for a few slices for lunch. Had a regular, Buffalo chicken and Penne slice, all amazing. The regular was thin, crispy and you can taste the quality of the ingredients. Reminiscent of Brooklyn pizza. Owner was very kind and treated me well. Definitely will go back soon.

I'm impressed, the food , the place , the service everything is beyong amazing . I'm glad we bout food from there. I'd give it 10 stars if I could . Awesome place , the shrimp parm heros are amazing 🤍.

My boyfriend and I just discovered this place not too long ago. My family has been in the pizza business for a long time, if you want amazing food and great service with genuinely nice workers then come here!!! absolutely love this place!!

Wanted to give a hugh Thank you to Anthony and his staff... They did a phenomenal job with our catering this past Saturday 8/12/23. From delivering on time with friendly service, to amazing presentation and Absolutely mind blowing flavorful dishes. Garlic knots were so tasty, and best of all the garlic was robust but not overpowering. The fresh dinner rolls- were so soft, just yeasty goodness. Sausage and peppers were my husband's favorite. The eggplant rollatini was a crowd-pleaser along with the chicken cutlet Parmigiana. That marinara sauce was perfect packed with flavor (as if my nonna made it). I must say you don't disappoint whether we are dining in doing take out or now our first catering event - just amazing every time. Thank you from Danny & Nina Marie.