This place was well worth our trip outside of Green Bay! The pesto fries are excellent and the pizza was the best we've had in the area with delicious tomato sauce and hand made crust. The dining area inside the old church was small but inviting. We sat outside, where a huge tree provides plenty of shade. There service was great, although expect it to be a little slower than a chain restaurant. It's one of those places where they give you time to enjoy your drinks, then your appetizer, and then your meal. We loved it and we'll be back!

The pizza is pretty good, but they've added a bar now, and the whole place is filled with people from Suamico which really ruins the atmosphere. At first I wasn't sure I actually wanted to go, based on the presence just hanging out on the front porch, then once again I was apprehensive in the bar area. The dining room was quieter, but doesn't look it gets much attention in the way of maintenance. It looks like there are things that haven't been touched since it was Pie from the Sky. If you want the pizza, I would just get it to go, it's pretty good.

Love this place!! They have a great deck for outside seating. Servers were bringing out So many dishes to everyone and they all looked wonderful! If i am in the location again I will be going there again yummy

Fish fry was a big disappointment. The website said our fish fry would include fish, French fries, rye bread, onion and tarter sauce. We ordered the fish on a Friday night. The fish was dry and thin - not good. Our plate did not have the bread and onion. The service was very good and fast. The French fries were very good. I think we will come back and try the pizza as they were serving A LOT of pizza.

Absolutely amazing pizza. Perfect crust. The pesto fries are outstanding. The drinks are very tasty as well. I highly recommend!

Great Caesar salads, pesto fries and pizzas. We had a family gathering of 16 people yesterday afternoon. Ingrid our server single handedly managed our entire group and she did it with a smile. The food was excellent. You can really taste quality ingredients. Never disappointed with their dishes. The bar staff that served us our first drinks did a great job.

Good atmosphere, great staff, amazing food. We ordered 9 full size pizzas, all came out at the same time, all hot, all delicious. Staff was friendly and attentive. We will be back.

First time there and will be back. Sooo good. It's the kind of pizza that reminds me of my childhood. Thin crispy hand tossed wood fired pizza! Thank you Rustique for taking me back to those years and reminding me that good pizza is still out there. We had Pesto Fries, CBGB and the Gaucho! All fantastic. We devoured the pesto fries in a matter of minutes!! Highly recommend this place.