I just moved into the area. This pizza is top notch! The workers are ALWAYS in there getting after it! Customer service is great. This place is a gem as it sits on the border of houses and businesses; it’s the perfect location. Oh yeah I forgot to say the pizza is amazing!!!!!!! I typically don’t order or like “non standard” pizzas like the photo I shared of the chicken bacon ranch pizza; but I hate to admit this pizza was soooo good! A must try if you’re a traditional pep and cheese guy like me. One last thing: protip! Buckeye Barn pizza reheats in the air fryer perfectly!! Try it!

A nice little place, delicious pizza, clean, comfortable. All the lights were off on a Saturday which was weird but we still dyed in.

Solid pizza. Been here one time while fishing at Forrest Lake and we got the Hawaiian. Was not disappointed. Can’t wait to try the fried chicken next time.

We went for dinner tonight for the first time. We got 2 small pizzas and some chicken strips to try later. First of all, the service was top-notch. Tina, our server, was friendly and exceptionally attentive. Gage, the new owner, stopped by our table to check on us as well. He had us so impressed that we took home a fresh strawberry pie and whipped cream! We will absolutely be back often!

Used to have the best pizza around for miles under new management if your a person of color probably would go here my friend was with me and they literally lied to us saying they didn't have pie but there were pie signs everywhere I walked in and talked to another employee after getting pissed and pie magically turned up! If you want that old barn pizza or family atmosphere it used to have it's not there anymore used to go there for a very long time as a child more than disappointed with this one.

We stopped here for lunch on our way home from Pennsylvania back to Illinois. It was a short drive from the interstate, and it was well worth the stop. We had a group of 14 people. The food was great and the staff was awesome! I would be there all the time if we had this place back home.

Absolutely fantastic! Very pleasant and inviting atmosphere and people. The Buckeye Barn has completely blown my mind with their food and hospitality

I really wanted to love this pizza. The dough was gooey, and it upset my entire family's stomach. I thought the taste was okay however my husband and kids didn't like it at all. We threw away 1.5 pizzas. Staff was very friendly on the phone ordering and at pickup.