Hidden gems: Jewelers in Indianapolis

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Indianapolis. This list contains 15 places from Jeweler category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories



Master Jewelers image
1
Master Jewelers
Jeweler
Straightforward showroom selling traditional & custom jewelry, including engagement & wedding rings.
5.00 (136 reviews)
RINGMAKER, LLC - By Appointment image
2
RINGMAKER, LLC - By Appointment
Jewelry designer
👍👍 Every single moment of this process was lovely. It was totally apparent how much care went into ensuring my fiancés vision and I was done to perfection. I’m so grateful we went to them to recreate the rings from Howls Moving Castle for me and my husband to-be to wear forever :^).
5.00 (43 reviews)
Goldman Jewelry image
3
Goldman Jewelry
Jewelry store
👍👍 I've been coming to Goldmans for 12 years now and the service and craftsmanship has always been top notch. Dennis is very humble but I will say his skills are impeccable. Stop looking, this is the place to go.
5.00 (15 reviews)
JEWELRY JUDGE OF INDIANAPOLIS LLC image
4
JEWELRY JUDGE OF INDIANAPOLIS LLC
Jeweler
👍👍 Catherine is extremely knowledgable and has done multiple appraisals for me over the years. Her work is quite detailed and I always feel confident that her accuracy, information and expertise are first class. I'll be seeing her again soon.
5.00 (5 reviews)
Orofino Jewelers image
5
Orofino Jewelers
Jeweler
👍👍 Took my ring to get sized and also have the diamond reset. The work done on my ring is just beyond reproach. Work is done right in store which is really important to me. I will definitely return to Orofino for all of my jewelry needs. My ring looks absolutely beautiful, thank you so much!
4.90 (44 reviews)
Jewelry Lady image
6
Jewelry Lady
Jeweler
Store offering diamond engagement rings, wedding bands, custom pieces & pre-owned luxury watches.
4.80 (59 reviews)
KAY Jewelers image
7
KAY Jewelers
Jewelry store
Retail jewelry chain featuring engagement rings, timepieces & designer collections.
$$$ $
4.70 (57 reviews)
The Gold Cobbler image
8
The Gold Cobbler
Jeweler
Jewelry & watch repair shop offering services such as resizing, restoration & cleaning.
4.70 (45 reviews)
Kirles Jewelers image
9
Kirles Jewelers
Jewelry store
👍👍 Owner is a long-time Friend. I am in Indy from FL, stopped in to see him. He was not present, but the Staff, not knowing who I was, received my visit as extremely cordial and accommodating as they have treated all persons I know for over 5 decades. You CAN 'go home again'!
4.70 (31 reviews)
Gold N' Gems image
10
Gold N' Gems
Jeweler
😠 I went to this shop this weekend to sell my wedding band. It was an 18k gold and when I got there, he didn’t bother to check the authenticity of my ring, just said it’s too light that we have to sell it as a scrap. I told him this is 18k that it has more valuable than what he is selling. He responde...
4.70 (15 reviews)
VanderZon Jewelers image
11
VanderZon Jewelers
Jewelry store
👍👍 Wonderfully helpful staff, beautiful jewelry, and a range of prices for every occasion. Thank you!
4.70 (7 reviews)
D & L Jewelry & Repair image
12
D & L Jewelry & Repair
Jeweler
😠 This is NOT a good place to take your expensive wrist watch to for repair! I regretted taking my watch here. First, my watch spent over a week at their store and when they finally have it ready, they have messed up the watch while trying to open the back just to replace the battery! There are all ki...
4.60 (32 reviews)
Patora Fine Jewelers image
13
Patora Fine Jewelers
Jewelry store
Established, locally owned retailer providing fine jewelry, loose diamonds & custom pieces.
4.60 (30 reviews)
KAY Jewelers image
14
KAY Jewelers
Jewelry store
Retail jewelry chain featuring engagement rings, timepieces & designer collections.
$$$ $
4.50 (99 reviews)
Irvington Jewelers image
15
Irvington Jewelers
Jeweler
👍👍 I have a question. I use to go to a shop eather at your store or on the west side of your store. This was back in 1978 or 79. Are you that same store with a different name? I recall an older gentleman really sweet and loved to talk and knew his stuff. He helped me more then he knew. So are you that...
4.50 (56 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories


Last updated:
( )