This was great for what it is. The gyros were seared well and moist. The saganaki was done perfectly with a good lemon and salty flavor.

I’m new to the Indy area and have been looking for a great place to grab some Greek food and I’ve found it! Greek Islands is fantastic and you get quite a lot of food for your money. I tried the traditional γύρος (gyro) my fiancé tried the σπαγγέτι (spaghetti) and we both were super impressed. If you happen to be familiar with Tarpon Springs Florida’s Greek community - this restaurant has very similar food. Love this place and will definitely be back soon! #SupportLocal

Me and my wife had planned on eating at the Italian restaurant but didn't realize we needed reservations. So we walked down to Greek islands and it was a great stroke of luck. Greek island has fresh delicious and authentic Greek food my daughter is usually a light eater but she cleaned her plate. The pastitsio was delicious!

Came here for an early dinner after strolling around a museum for a few hours. If you like Greek food, you won't be disappointed. Started with the saganaki, which is always a visual treat when ignited. Who doesn't like fried cheese? The pastitsio was great! Basically a Greek version of lasagne. The gyros weren't pretty decent, too. Just don't expect the taco-style sandwich. This one comes with a mountain of meat and a pita cut into quarters with the tzatziki on the side, making assembly a bit of a challenge, if not slightly messy. Still tastes great, though, and there's definitely more than enough food to fill you up and leave you something for lunch the next day! The service was quick, attentive, and almost embarrasingly polite. They want your business, and it shows.

This is my go to place for tilapia grilled and seasoned perfectly! Lunch was delicious as always!

They were the nicest people. Great service and great food. This was just a happy place to go.

I got the meat pie. It was amazing! It's got this really crispy pastry crust and the sides were great too!

The food was amazing and authentic! The waiter spoke Greek as well and the food was prepared promptly but not pre-made. The hummus is to die for and the Moussaka is incredible. There's more to Greek food than just gyros! Definitely great place to bring a date either casual or inexpensive high class.

For lunch I tried out the Gyro . What is so cool is the soup! I am from Northwest Indiana, and this soup is very known up there. Like a delicacy. It is known as lemon rice lol. Us region rats love it. Anyways, the gyro and the soup were fantastic. So glad I tried this place, and I know where it is at now. It hit the spot! Will be back, next time I want to sit down inside or out on the patio in front. I mean, I was thinking about this Gyro 10 hours after I ate it , then I came here and decided to write this review. Worth noting, my two coworkers loved the chicken gyros they ordered, I just like them original . The cucumber sauce that I can’t spell for the life of me was fantastic with the handful of diced onions and tomatoes. The potato was almost magical. Not even going to elaborate on that, you just need to see what I’m talking about. My lunch slapped today.

I haven't had the pleasure of dining here in many years but I was so happy to see that the food was just as good as it was the last time. I had the moussaka, my mom had the gyro platter and my brother had the spanakopita. Everyone's meals were perfect, 3 different palates pleased, and the service was friendly and great as usual. Neither my mom or brother had eaten here before but both agreed the food was great and my mom declared this was the best Greek restaurant I had brought her to in Indianapolis.

First time at a Greek restaurant and I had my reservations as first but boy did they take care of us. We explained to them that this was a first time and they took the time to explain the food and gave us great options. We were thoroughly pleased with the food and even got free dessert on the house. They have turned us on to Greek food. Thank you for taking the time to explain everything and being so amazing.

It was my first visit there and I enjoyed it. I had been intrigued by the idea of making Moussaka but wanted to try it first. They were kind enough to serve it to me at lunch even though it was not on the lunch menu. Thank you very much! It was good and the serving was big enough for me to make two meals. Glad I tried it! I learned that I don't want a 13x9 pan of it which is what the recipes I've found online make. Service was slow but the place was packed with only two servers so I understand and didn't care because I literally had all day! I'll go back and want to try some other items that will suit my taste more closely.

Great locally owned place! Great food!

The food was authentic and absolutely delicious!! We loved it all

This restaurant was phenomenal. The food was so fresh and delicious. The service was great. Staff is super friendly and made it a better experience even being busy. Highly recommended.

My first time here and eating at a Greek restaurant. The food was amazing, delicious and piping hot. The service was fantastic and I would highly recommend you to go and try their food and hospitality. I had ordered tilapia with just the potatoes because I am a very picky eater but my sister ordered us some type of cheese that was flaming and it was delicious and I have never had it before. Sorry, I can't remember the name of the flaming cheese. Lol it is a must go and try for yourself place because of the atmosphere alone and the food.

Food was very good but the air conditioning was not working and it was uncomfortably hot. Still food was very good.

First time eating here and we were impressed ! It was really good food :) had a great time

I called the day before to see if they would be able to accommodate my large group of 25 and they said yes. They very graciously accommodated us at 4 tables, but the restaurant is cozy so we were still all able to talk to each other. The food was excellent and the bread, appetizers, and salad were a great way to start our way. They got our food out fast considering the size of our group and the fact that the rest of the restaurant was full. I was particularly grateful for how kind and patient they were with the kids in our group, and I had a lovely conversation with the staff afterwards. The prices were very reasonable for the amount and quality of food. I would absolutely recommend this restaurant and look forward to coming back when I visit Indy again!

Very authentic cuisine. Super tasty and plenty of food. Got to talk to the management and very sympathetic to their supply chain issues. The lady sincerely sounded upset that she couldn't provide the full menu or Greek beer. Great place and great people. Hopefully the country will pull out of this recession and save mom & pop businesses like this one.

The food was so good and our whole table was so cared for. So glad we chose this location Everything was lovely!!! Will return!

I was traveling through Indy for work and asked a friend where to he. He recommended this place. So I decided to stop and eat lunch there. I tried the saganaki for appetizer and it was amazing! The. I got a chicken gyro with feta. It was very good also. I definitely recommend this place.