Our server, Alexander, was amazing!! He made great recommendations, which I ended up choosing the spare ribs. They were very "fall off the bone" tender. The chocolate cake was delightful! The ice cream on the side had melted a little, so Alexander went above & beyond by offering an extra scoop. Thank you ‼ His service was impeccable, the establishment and ambiance are incredible and the food was delicious! Would definitely recommend and will certainly be back!

I was in Indy for work and the local team suggested Tony’s. The locals really played up the atmosphere, food, drinks, and the overall attention to detail. When we entered Tony’s, we could see right away they were correct. Our table was not ready, so the host showed us to the bar and we were introduced to the bartender. We ordered our drinks and sat in some comfy chairs and began to decompress. A short while later, our table was ready and we were taken to our table. Within seconds, were greeted, our water glasses filled, and advised that Alexander would be taking care of us this evening. Alexander arrived at our table and did his best to rally our group. He talked about the restaurant, the specials, appetizers and asked who was ready for another drink. We ordered more drinks and some appetizers for the table. We had crab cakes and shrimp. The shrimp were huge and everything tasted amazing. We ordered our meals and some slides for the table. Dealing with the nine of us was not easy, however, Alexander handled everyone very well. All of the food came out at the same time and everything was cooked PERFECTLY!! I had the strip steak and it was one of the best steaks I have ever eaten. The flavor and texture were amazing! The sides were wonderful. Overall, it was one of the best experiences I have ever had in a restaurant. It was so good, that we came back the next weekend. If you are in the Indy area and want a top-notch experience, visit Tony’s. Order a steak, appetizers, drinks, and a salad.

The food was delicious. We asked our waiter Isaiah for a wine suggestion with our rack of lamb and his choice turned out to be an impeccable pairing. The service was excellent. My partner and I really enjoyed our dining experience.

The dry aged New York strip bone in is to die for! Highly recommend! Chocolate martini is great as well. Very nice server.

Came here for my Birthday and everything was amazing. The service was awesome! My husband is very critic of places and he even said they definitely deserve a tip and then some. The crab cake was the absolute best I have had in Indy hands down! The ribs were falling apart and the pork chop was great! The sides were amazing as well and the bar had the drinks on point! I have no complaints at all. Will definitely be back again!

I had an absolutely exceptional experience at Tony's. The service was nothing short of impeccable. From the moment I walked in, I felt like a valued guest. The staff was attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. Every detail was meticulously attended to, making the evening truly unforgettable. I can't recommend Tony's enough for their outstanding service and warm hospitality. A five-star dining experience in every sense.

Great dinner and excellent service. Alexander was our server and he did a great job at making sure everything was up to a high standard and that we had everything we needed. He was very attentive too. Everything from the bread and salads to the steak and sides were cooked to PERFECTION. See you all again in a few weeks! :-)

Hands down the best steakhouse in Indy! Crab Cake is to die for. Steaks were cooked perfectly and absolutely delicious. The service was phenomenal as well. I highly recommend. If you’re looking for a high end steak house this is your place.

First time here. The food was excellent. In Indy the bar is set pretty high with St. Elmo when it comes to steak houses. The atmosphere is different, but not in a bad way. I wish the piano bar was open the night we were there. The menu variety is better than St Elmo's but unfortunately they had a problem with their stove that night so some items were not available. Our server did a decent job but he didn't seem to be able to project his voice in a fairly loud room so it was very difficult to hear him. I went with the short ribs and substituted the sweet potato side dish. Both were incredible! The other people in my party enjoyed their meals too.

It's elegant, the service is amazing, and the food is absolutely delicious. It's safe for people with food allergies because everything is made from scratch in the kitchen. Our meal was beautifully presented, and our server did an incredible job guiding us through the meal and the choices available. This is one of the few places in town and in the Midwest where you can get a legitimate crab cake. It was So Good! The Sea Bass was incredible and perfectly prepared. Every part of this meal was crafted with care. If you want to "Wow" someone with a dining experience, Tony's is a fantastic choice. These are not Texas Roadhouse prices, but they aren't any more expensive than Sullivan's or Ruth's Chris, and the food is phenomenal!! For your next big meal or celebration, give Tony's a try. You won't be sorry that you did!

Perfect dining experience! Can only afford to go for a very special occasion but it was wonderful!

We went for our anniversary. It had been a place we wanted to visit and we were not disappointed. We had the generous size crab cake that was moist full of flavor and lump meat. Our steak was delicious the seasoning as a 5/5. Out of all the steakhouses that I have been to in Indianapolis this will be my go to for a great steak. The sides were shared as we had mashed potatoes creamed spinach. I suggested that they sell the seasoning and the manager let us know it’s the technique not just the seasonings. Our Waiter Garret provided great service and a complementary dessert for our anniversary. We will dine again.

Our party of 6 celebrated 2 birthdays. I messed up on Open Table and made our reservation at the wrong location. They were quick to find us a place in the bar to accommodate. Lucky we were dining early that night. Service was impeccable as expected and the entrees were delightful. The sides were fine. The desserts were average. Hubby had the bone in ribeye, which I normally won’t even try but I had a bite and it was beautifully seasoned and melted in my mouth! I ordered the Chilean sea bass and it was perfectly cooked and seasoned. It came on a bed of oats, which I did at all. Not sure who inspired that but next time, I’ll be asking for a sub on that. Friends ordered the Pappardelle fra diavolo and split it and still took home leftovers. They said it was spicy but so good and would highly recommend it. Another ordered the shrimp and grits, which came with a coffee based sauce so what your normally see as a light colored dish was brown. He loves coffee and enjoyed the dish but said he would not recommend it. Said the coffee overpowered the dish. The last order was the pistachio pesto orecchiette, which was also a giant order. We all felt like it was a little dry and could use a tad more sauce but it was delicious. Our family sized sides included Mac & cheese, blah, nothing special, Bourbo whipped sweet potatoes, yum!, and creamed spinach, bland. I forgot we did order a jumbo lump crab cake, which perfectly describes its perfection. Would highly recommend it. For dessert, our birthday guy and gal were each brought a confection that were shared by everyone and neither was completely consumed. I ordered the crème brûlée and felt like was having a pudding. Bring your appetite and your piggy bank but so worth it!

Tony's is our special occasion "go-to." It has never disappointed. I ordered the fulet and my husband had the New York strip. We always share sides and take some home. Side portions are enormous! I always enjoy the crab cake appetizer.

WOULD TOTALLY RECOMMEND. My waiter Alexander was pretty cool. It was my girlfriend‘s birthday and I wanted to surprise her. She love steaks and trying new ones from different restaurants. The food was great. The atmosphere was great.. it was a little louder than what I would like, but I can honestly say I enjoyed my experience.

The staff at Tony's is a testament to the restaurant's commitment to exceptional service. From the friendly and knowledgeable servers to the attentive sommeliers, every aspect of your dining experience is meticulously attended to. They are well-versed in the menu offerings and are more than happy to provide recommendations or guide you through the extensive wine selection.

The best experience! Our server Jay was awesome, along with all the other staff we encountered. They were all very friendly and polite. The food was AMAZING!! Not one bad thing to say…other than I can’t wait to come back! We were celebrating our ten year anniversary and they brought us a cheesecake, which was also amazing!

One of the best experiences I have ever had. Thanks Tony's for the excellent service and delicious food. Also, thank you for showing so much concern for our friend with a nut allergy and making a special dressing for her salad. Will absolutely come back and tell friends

Loved everything about this place! It was mine and my boyfriend's first time eating at Tony's and it was an overall exceptional experience. My boyfriend made a reservation for my birthday and I have to say 10/10 from the service, to the food, to the ambiance. We had Alyssa as our server and she was such a sweetheart. She went above and beyond to make sure we were enjoying our meal and had everything we needed. The food was cooked to perfection! Our steaks were so tender, juicy, and flavorful. We are already planning another visit soon! Also Trey was kind enough to pack us fresh bread when we wanted to take home what was leftover. Thank you Tony's for making my birthday a memorable one!

This place is hands down the best place I have ever been.! I can't describe it in words. You just need to get up and go. The food was impeccable!! Nothing short of perfect!! I would work an extra shift to buy dinner here. I have never said that before. Way better than any steak house in Indy. Just go, you won't be disappointed!!

An absolute DIVINE experience. The crab cake was awesome and the steak was so flavorful. Although the crab cake is listed as an appetizer, I had it come with my meal. All in all I would give it a 9.7/10. The cocktails are strong so you’ve been warned.