We came for an anniversary and was not disappointed! The ribs were AMAZING! My husband had the fish tacos and was so impressed with them. The banana breeze frozen adult drink is to die for. Prices are good for the quality you receive

Well I can’t remember all the names of the foods precisely we got but Fogarty’s is easily the best place we have ate at in Key West so far and a few of the drinks we had were just as good, the dirty monkey and the grape ape. The service was great and our blonde waitress was awesome, sorry, forgot your name. We got a fish sandwich, some kind of pecan fish, 3 cheese pasta and blackened fish tacos. I substituted fries for my rice n beans, I’m just not a rice and bean guy. I sampled all 4 dishes and they were all Amazing. My vegetables with my dish were also cooked to perfection. This is definitely a must stop while you’re in Key West. I’m pretty hard to please because I’ve eat country cooking and Cajun food(thanks to my bayou work buddies) all of my life and it’s some of the best food in the world but Fogarty’s definitely met my high expectations.

My mom and I had the fish tacos and margaritas. The fish tacos were perfectly cooked and the sauce had a great kick to it. They were not cheap on the liquor for drinks. Would definitely recommend.

Tim our waiter was great, we received fast service, friendly and great attitude. Food was really good, couldn't have asked for anything better. Great experience.

Fogarty’s is an absolute must in KW. The atmosphere of the restaurant is so fun and enjoyable. The menu is not overly complicated like a lot of places are nowadays, the food is fresh and delicious, the drinks are so refreshing (and fun!), the music choices are great, and ALL of the staff is attentive and friendly. As a manager in the Food and Beverage industry, this place hits all my marks. I visit at least twice every trip, and will continue to do so every time I’m in town! I would even dare to say it is my favorite in Key West!

We were visiting key west and we went here twice in a row. Fish was very fresh and everything tasted yummy. Service was good, people are nice. I got the tacos, and the blacked shrimp wrap - both delicious. Especially the wrap. My parents got the fried fish sandwich and it was delicious. The second time they got the dolphin sandwich and the shrimp/bacon sandwich. They were happy with those as well. Food comes out very fast! They have the fans going so it can get cold but, we asked the manager to turn the one off near us and he was nice about it! Overall great experience. Would go back again!

While on vacation in Key West, we ate at Fogarty’s twice. That’s how much we loved the food and service. I ordered a dish that blow my mind. Totally, was expecting something on the tiny side. It was an unexpected delight that the quality of food was more than I could have imagined. I love outdoor eateries and it was spacious to accommodate large groups. My husband ordered the same dish two days in a row. Hands down the best restaurant in Key West.

Classic American style restaurant with seating areas and high stool tables. Very friendly and knowledgeable staff. Luke helped us with the menu and suggested the perfect amount of food we needed. We came in right when the storm came and we found a table for four quite easily. The burger, ribs, and tacos were huge and delicious. One of the best restaurants in the area.

I'm giving this 5 stars because my meal was delicious and flavorful, however I must add that the other three people in my group did not feel their dishes were all that flavorful. I wasn't all that hungry and chose from the appetizers as my dish. The bruschetta was fresh and full of flavor and exactly what I was looking for. We all enjoyed the the local live music and patio eating environment.

The food was amazing, I had a shrimp po-boy with tons of shrimp, the bun could barely contain the shrimp 😁. The fries were well seasoned and delicious and my drink the Ruby Roo from the Flying Monkeys Saloon was terrific. Definite must stop, and dont be alarmed by the roosters walking around, they add to the atmosphere!

I've had many meals here. Our sever Natalie was perfect. Mahi tacos, shrimp po boy, and conch fritters. Everything perfect.

My conch fritter appetizer was amazing! Best on the island, and the remoulade sauce A+ I don't remember our servers name, a redheaded guy. He was 💯 did a great job! Good people are hard to find.

I’d say the food was just ok for what it cost. We stopped in for lunch. Atmosphere is excellent, but again your in Kew West can’t go wrong anywhere for the atmosphere here. Roosters running around makes it much more entertaining. Service was great and quick. We had a late lunch which put us there around 2:30 and we were seated right away. We’d probably try somewhere else next time in the area.

Generous delicious portions of food and tasty pina coladas. My only dislike was they use high fructose corn syrup ketchup. I meant to order bacon on my burger but forgot so it eould be good if the wait staff were to ask if I wanted bacon like they did the day before when we ate here. Otherwise lovely and highly recommend!

Somehow I kept making it back to his place, great food great music great bartenders. They're shrimp po-boy was surreally awesome. Don't miss this place.

Fogarty's is pretty good and has a great location right on Duval street. The food was great but the drinks were not. The service was slow and almost inattentive. When we asked our server a few details about the food before we placed our order, she said she honestly had no idea. I do admire the honesty, and in the end, the food was great. I ordered the key lime shrimp and my wife ordered the three cheese pasta. Both meals were delicious and visually appealing. For the drinks, my wife order the Pina colada and I the Rum Runner. The rum runner was far too frozen and kept plugging up the straw. I ended up removing the cover and drinking from the top but it tasted like a little kids freeze pop. Way too much sugar and I could not taste any rum. I would still recommend this place as a good place to grab lunch while walking along Duval street.

You can people watch here. The food you find here is the staple menu for the majority of the Resurants on duval. We wanted more earthy seafood. Not fried shrimp or conch or tacos. It’s the common theme everywhere when you ask them “what do you recommend”. The place served its lunch purpose and we decide to just do fine dinning moving forward as it seems you get less of the fried options. My mahi mahi tacos were ok. The rice and beans no flavor. The chicken fingers ok.

In the heart of Duval Street. I try to eat here every time I’m in KW. Love the atmosphere and their menu. Fast and fresh food. We have a Fish Sandwich (a whole fish technically) 😊 The pork bowl and a Fogarty’s Burger!! Will visit again next trip!!!

The Seared Tuna was awesome but everything else we ordered wasn't very good. Half of it didn't get eaten. Kids burger was really raw inside also. Service was wonderful though. Someone came out to make sure we knew my child with the peanut allergy would be safe to eat there which was very nice.

I got the Fogarty's Burger, the best one in town as they say, so my expectations were high! Its sure was good but I wouldn't say best one in town because a few things were missing: no special sauce, they just give you generic ketchup, mayonnaise and mustard. No special ingredient, what about a slice of smokey key lime? Frozen drinks are pretty good though and kids get a little present to entertain them. So in the end an overall pretty good location to go to 👍

First time to Key West found this place had a AWESOME experience! We had a real cheeseburger in paradise great food conch fritters, southwestern chicken egg rolls,great frozen mixed drinks & cold beer service was top notch cant wait to get back !

Fogarty's was one of the best places we ate at in Key West. We were so surprised! The Mahi Mahi Bites are incredible! The best seafood we had. The Bruschetta was also excellent. My husband couldn't stop eating it. Also the Rack of Ribs platter was just delicious. Meaty tender ribs. We loved it. And the service was excellent. Great value as well. Thank you for doing everything right! This will be our go to place.

Seated immediately on a Saturday night during Spring Break on the great outdoor patio. Service was good and food portions were huge and delicious. They are known for their frozen drinks and the variety is huge. Great place to people watch also.

I’m pleased of the experience in this location. Personal was friendly and acknowledging. Waiter Tim very hospitable and did a great job. Food great and drinks well prepared. We had the “Pain in the ass” drinks. The fish and Broccolini delicious. We recommend and we’ll be back when in the Keys

Food was good, atmosphere was good as well. The fish sandwich was one of the best I have had. Best part is that the kids meals were only $4.95. you may get some chicken visitors while you eat.