This is such an amazing pizzeria, the wuality, quantity, ambience, and staff all are amazing. The Pizza was made to perfection, it was served (heated) within no time, the staff was very helpful to all the customers. The seating space is not much but they have a couple of tables outside the store as well. Visited this place as recommended to be top rated and it definitely was top class. The gelato looked amazing, although didn't try it.

Wow! I don’t even know what to say for this pizza place! It is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever eaten! And it’s also not that pricy compared to the other restaurants in downtown Key West! I definitely recommend you try it out! You will not regret it!

BEST PIZZA PLACE!!! My family and I had the capriacola and cheese pizzas. They were so very generous of the cheese and it was heaven. And oh my goodness please don’t get me started on the crust. It’s so soft and crunchy. It tastes like homemade pizza! Very authentic! Recommend to everyone in key west

Spectacular pizza. We were on a boat all day and wanted pizza. Walked over and ordered a pie. Took about 15 minutes. It was great. Homemade crust. Watched the guy hand toss it and load on all the toppings. It tasted as good as it looked. They did offer slices to go. Had drinks and Gelato. Not a lot of places to sit. The staff was very friendly and gave us Plates and silverware. They had freshly created Parmagan. Overall a great place for pizza.

We had some coconut Gelato, it was very good. The service was nice. They let us try some of their other flavors.

Somethings changed in the 4 years since I've had pizza here, and unfortunately it's for the worse. The pizza tasted over-cheesed and it was just ok. I would explore other pizza options before returning here.

I was recommended to this pizza place and the facility is clean the staff is helpful and greets you with a smile. I was in the mood for some great pizza and this place was an incredible delicious spot. The pizza was warm and the topping on the pizza were fresh tasty and delicious. I will recommended this pizza place to all my friends when they visit Key West,FL.

I live near Chicago and when I visit FL I am used to not having good pizza. This place is amazing! I ordered it through door dash (because we were pool side) and I am super happy with the pizza. Highly recommend this pie if you are looking for a quality pizza at a fair price.

Fantastic Pizza for a reasonable price! Please dont go go pizza hut or papa johns. Instead choose one of the greatest pizzas in the States I had so far. Very nice!

We were hungry after a boat trip and looking for a quick snack, and wow, this was a good decision. Great handmade pizza for a fair price, way better than average. It even seems to be one of the best places to eat pizza in America (based on a Tripadvisor ranking). That's impressive, so go for it!

I came in here a couple of years ago for a couple of slices with my girlfriend and they were mediocre. Probably because they had an idiot making them that day. Jump to last night and was watching the game next door and was hungry. I ordered a pepperoni at halftime to have at the bar and it was excellent. We could tell the dough was fresh with a great tasting sauce and just the right amount of cheese. Pizza preferences can be quite personal but we think this is a great version of NY style pizza.

As a pizza lover this place is TOP KNOTCH!! 🍕the crust is perfectly toasted and delicious. Service was phenomenal, Gracias! We loved all three different slices. Can’t recommend enough!!!

Great pizza by the slice. We tried pepperoni, grandma, and the meat pizza. All them were great, but the Grandma pizza was our favorite. Their gelato was also great.

Amazing pizza!!!! So good, must try in Key West!!

Looks like a small hole in the wall pizza place and that is a good thing! The pepperoni pizza was more on the thin crust style but was very flavorful. Those ezzo pepperonis make it stand out; the cheese was heavy enough that the slices do not fall apart like some cheap pizzas. Not as much sauce but really it had just enough. Quick and solid service made this a happy choice we want to come back to!

Michael took GREAT care of us. LA Suprema overbaked at my request. perfect. Gelato was the real deal.

Amazing Pizza place in Key West. Must visit this place. They do have vegetarian options. They have fresh and homemade pizza. Also we had fresh gelato ice cream as well. It was really delicious.

Their Gelato is amazing, but a bit pricey compared to the other places I have tried. It tastes amazing, though. Their pizza is great in taste, perfect thickness with amazing flavor and crunchiness to it. Highly recommend.

We’re new in town and craving for pizza. luckily we found this pizzeria. They have variety of pizza. We ordered lasagna and Hawaiian. This was the first time I tried lasagna pizza. Their pizza really good. I highly recommend if your are a pizza lover.

Ate here twice in two days. It's not NY style pizza, but it is done of the best pizza I've had in the state of FL! They have the small/ crispy pepperoni, which sealed the deal for me. Gelato was also good. No fountain drinks and bottle selection was limited. Inside seating area was small, and a table or two outside. Definetly good for a quick stop, or great for grabbing a slice on the go. Great location, close to Duval.

Key West food at it's finest. Great place for a quick bite at a decent price. I had the Caprese, fresh mozzarella and tomato slice along with fresh basil, just enough crisp on the crust to make the perfect slice. Others in the group had pepperoni, perfect ratio of pepperoni to cheese cooked to perfection. The crust was incredible from the first to last bite, nothing wasted. Staff were very friendly, down to the "Hello Kitty" tee-shirt. Took a few extra slices to go, intended to eat for dinner, only made it about 20 minutes once we got home to finished the extra slices, may need to return for dinner. Keep making pizza like this and they will come!

Wow, what a great lunch stop after a leisurely bike ride and some key lime pie from Key Lime Bike Tours, just a couple of blocks away. The pizza and garlic knots were delicious and prepared quickly. I thought the prices were very reasonable. When we stopped, there were three meat free pizza options to choose from in addition to several other pizza options. My white slice was amazing. There is some seating available, but the place isn't huge. I didn't have room to try the gelato today but it looked yummy..

Being from the New York area which has the best pizza in the country I was very skeptical getting pizza in Key West, never planned on it actually! I walked past and they have a banner that says they won Top 10 pizza in America in 2018 from Trip Advisor so I said why not, let's give it a try! It was VERY good! Top 10? Probably not but if you are craving good pizza in Key West, don't go anywhere else! They also have great gelato.

Best pizza I've ever had! We ordered the stuffed meatlovers pizza, fresh ingredients and clean place. Will definitely come back!

Staff was friendly and the pizza was great. Solid bang for your buck. Gelato is really good here as well. I recommend the pistachio and espresso flavors.

This pizza is the BEST! Wish I could give it 6 stars. Delicious, reasonably priced, and quick delivery, fresh and hot. Here on vacay ... wished they were in Stark County, Ohio!!

Lunch special wax fantastic! Pizza slices are large and really excellent. I could definitely see why this place is rated SO highly. Pizza was definitely fresh and handmade. Downtown location was so convenient, staff was extremely friendly, and it was a great experience

If you want to have Pizza and Gelato, this is the place in Key West to visit. The spicy pepperoni pizza is mind blowing!

truly is the best pizza in the area but tonight well i guess we all have off nights - every bite tastes burnt. unless i guess i remove the pepperoni i paid extra for . . . maybe should have remade this one.

Just an incredible place. Pizza by far the best Ive had. Not one topping/ingredient overwhelms the other. Baked to perfection. and What made it a 5 star was the customer service. Everyone here was friendly and welcoming.