Good ambience but food was average. Only thing good was the lobster. The mushroom appetizer could be better..real tiny and 5 pieces for $16 is a rip off. The clam chowder soup was watery too. Overall it was a disappointment.

Had an amazing time here. Customer service was great. Everything I tried on the menu was seasoned well. The bread was soft and warm. The stuffed mushrooms were tasty. The shrimp cocktail were cooked perfectly. The filet mignon was delicious. The yellow tail snapper was fantastic. The yellow rice was seasoned nicely. The baked potato was small to say the least but it was okay. The New England Clam chowder was perfect, fresh clams and seasoned very well. AND THEN THERE WAS THE CHEESECAKE! OMG! Show stopper! Case closed. The end!

We came here for dinner one night and everything we ordered was very delicious! Our server was very sweet and friendly too! I also have tried a lot of Key Lime Pie in my life and I have to say that this one was so yummy!!! We will definitely be back as they had a really good selection on their menu and they also had a lot of specials the night we went.

Everything was decent, nothing too extravagant. My partner stated that his meal was okay. While my shrimp scampi dish was the same. It didn’t feel like the pasta had any sauce or flavor but I loved how the shrimp where jumbo. The only plus, to our visit to Duffys was the bread and butter. With the bread nice and warm and the butter was cold. All in all if your options are limited then I guess it would be okay to give Duffy’s a try but I wouldn’t recommend. It was a slow Friday night when we visited so I’m not sure why everything was subpar. Also our waiter was okay, she didn’t seem too engaged with us at all.

Of our four days in Key West, this was our last, and best, of the evening meals. Buffalo wings as an appetizer. For our main: Great lobster tail, prime ribs and jumbo shrimp scampi and steak meals between the three of us. Portions were generous. Shared Key lime pie to finish it off hit the spot. All were super good. The service was cordial. The restaurant has a nice warm feel to it. Would go here again.

Meal and service couldn't have been any better. Price was reasonable for seafood meals. The food was very good!!!!

Not bad service, but ask questions! So the service person if you ask, the right questions can answer everything, but it doesn’t come voluntary. Like … “let me tell you what the special are or you try…. It’s my fav. Pretty cut and dry. The place is super clean over all.

Great place! The conch fritters are LEGIT. Prime rib was amazing. Filet was great. Lobster was perfect. The bernaise sauce here is off the charts. A must have dinner when im in Key west. Thank you duffy's!

We came here because it was right down the street from us. We had the crab cakes as an appetizer, there where 3 very small cakes and could have been fried on the side also because it tasted under cooked with just the top and bottom fried. I had the lobster and steak tips for dinner. The steak was good but my lobster was dry and tough. The rice was the best part of my meal. Not impressed.

Ate here twice on my last visit to Key West. Best seafood and mouth watering steak. If you are looking for good seafood congratulations your journey is over. Ask for Donna. Service is impeccable.

We really enjoyed the food. The lobster tail was the best part, I probably would only get that if I were to go again. The reason for 4 stars is because they have a young hostess who is learning (which is ok, there is nothing wrong with that) the first night we tried to go there we called and asked if we needed a reservation. She said no. We came and she asked if we could wait 10 minutes. We waited outside for over 40 minutes and she kept letting other people in front of us. Eventually we left and came back the next night. She should have a list or something.

Great local place. Server was friendly. Salad was very fresh and the house dressing was very good. The hollandaise sauce on the stuffed shrimp was delicious. Definitely recommend

Pleasant waitress, relaxed environment. I had the local fish 'maison' (house) and it came with a very good baguette and salad. Generous portion and was very good.

Great steak and fish restaurant with pleasant vibes and attentive staff. Ordered mixed fish platter and beef tenderloin. Meal sizes were right, not too much. So there is space left for their delicious key lime pie too :)

Little hidden Gem, small inside i was a little worried when we sat and the table was sticky and the place was mostly empty. It did not disappoint though! My wife had the Chicken Milanese, I had the prime rib and lobster. There prime rib was awesome! The horseradish cream sauce was delicious. The Broccoli was a bit undercooked but the prime rib and lobster was so good I did not care. Their key like Pie is TART. Which is how i love it. Very good! Service was strong but they were so that was easy. Atmosphere wise it is BLAH, not beach themed, it does not have any TV’s. Even at the bar. It is a nice little gem and the food is great but it fails on the theme and atmosphere.

We really enjoyed the chicken and crab cakes. Salads were prepared nicely with more than just lettuce and a cucumber like most places. Nice warm loaf of bread was served with the meal as well.

The filet is amazing - I felt it was better than the high end steak places like Ruth’s Chris and Flemings. Lobster tail was amazing. Price of the food is half of the high end places as well. Atmosphere is very relaxed.

The customer service was amazing! Our server, Kenni, was very kind and knowledgeable about food choices as well as fun things to do around Key West. The food was excellent and her recommendation on trying the the cheesecake was perfect. The ambiance of the place is very cute. I love their little lamps inside. I would recommend eating here when you visit Key West and ask for Kenni.

Food tasted great and the portions were a good size.The service was great. We only had 3 of the 6 in our party and they sat us right away and were patient with us while we waited for the rest of our group. Definitely will go back.

Nice family owned restaurant with authentic and good food. We had the alligator tail as a starter, which wasn't that great. It was deep fried meat, so you couldn't really tell anymore what kind of meat it really was. The main course (local catch fresh fillet) was absolutely delicious and perfectly cooked. It came with a lobster soup and rice, so the price of 32.99$ was also very reasonable. Service was also good and the location is also very nice. I would come here again 🙂

They have the Best Prime Rib! We go to Key West every 4 months or so and get it every time. We have to do takeout because they’re not pet friendly but that’s OK It’s well worth it!

Really good prime rib and Florida lobster tail. I always look forward to getting some Florida lobster when I come on down to the keys. They didn't disappoint plus the restaurants More laid back than your typical key West destination you can actually hear yourself think.

Fantastic steak and lobster. The staff is so welcoming! We had house-made frozen cocktails prepared from scratch. Perhaps the best meal we had on the island.

The chicken Caesar salad was tasty enough, steak was just ok and the key lime pie was the third we have tried in the keys and would give it third place. Nothing wrong with the place but wouldn’t go rushing back.