This is exactly what Key West locals need. An amazing traditional Irish pub in Key West. It is now opened today March 28th as Sally O Brien's and is absolutely fantastic. The owner Scotty is a cool dude. The food was amazing and couldn't be happier. My wife had the fish sandwich and my son and I had the Shepard pie. So good. This will be one of our local hangouts for sure.

Amazing small town restaurant with one of a kind food and amazingly friendly staff! I ordered the chicken curry pot pie, and it was fantastic! Highly highly recommend! Athena was our server and she did an excellent job. Everyone was throughly happy with their food. We are here for 5 days and definitely coming back for more!

The new owner Scottie has done a fabulous job renovating the old Shanna Key and reopening as Sally O’Briens. I’ve eaten there several times and the food is all fabulous and healthy portions. The bar fills up up quickly so you need to come early if you want a good spot.

So clean nice and newly renovated. No smokey smells anymore. There is a new owner in town and he is awesome. Super awesome staff, very nice and attentive.

Fantastic place to get off the beaten path and have a great food and drinks. The new owners are very nice polite in the staff couldn’t be any better the food came out quick hot it was delicious. If you’re in Key West And need a good old Irish pub spot you gotta come here. Sally O’Briens. This is one of my favorite spots to visit.

First time visitors. Had the specials- pulled pork sandwich and open faced prime rib sandwich with mash potatoes. Also tried the Buffalo chicken dip and the wings. Super friendly staff and dogs are welcome. Would definitely recommend.

Unique little Irish joint, what you would expect out of a pub. Great environment for watching sports and hanging with buddies. Food was as authentic as you can get for island Irish food. Bartender was friendly, gave great insight on what to do and see on the island. Great spot to start your trip!

My family really loved this place. It was definitely a highlight in a sea of mediocrity that we found in Key West dining. We ate dinner here twice during our vacation. Our server (I think her name is Molly, curly red hair) was super welcoming and accommodating, friendly and had great menu suggestions. The food was really fantastic. The pizza was honestly some of the best we've had in quite a while, it was excellent!! Definitely more of a locals place, doesn't feel touristy. Also LOVE the 80's music!!

Great sports bar with european soccer event, smal but very good menu card, very tastefull nachos dish. For soccer fans a absolute must!

Oh my. This was NOT a good tasty experience. This meal was absolutely awful! The waitress was incredibly kind-but i couldn’t stomach the meat at all. It tasted unlike anything I’ve ever experienced??? I love a good special but this is a hard pass from me. The potatoes were good for a couple of bites, but then they just went wrong. I’m not sure what was wrong here. But the taste was off

Came here for Trivia night (Thursdays). Arrived during happy hour and the staff was wonderful. We placed our orders (dollar happy hour wings were freaking delicious!) and the food was great. The prices are typical for the area and cheaper than some of the fast food joints in town. They're still fixing up the place so it was a little rough in areas, but nothing bad. The acoustics in the back room were crazy loud since the carpet was removed, but that's to be expected with a crowd. 7/10, will return for those chili-lime wings! Also, it's a bar/restaurant, if you want fine dining and white tablecloths, go somewhere else and pay through the nose. Come here for good grub and good company!

Many favorites are still on the menu. I especially like the shepherd's pie. My wife really likes the pizza. Nice selection of draft beer on tap. The reuben sandwich has gone a little down hill, but is still good (but not great as before). We see a lot of new staff, and the service is great.

While staying in Key West, my Son & I walked over to Sally O'Brien's Irish Pub. They were completely sold out of Corned Beef, so no Reubens! We dined on an amazing Arugula Salad & a bowl of Potato Leek Soup. Absolutely delicious!! Wonderful service from Shanah!!