Octopus was awesome. Food is fresh and delicious, staff was delightful, drinks were strong and good flavor. The bread pudding is a good choice. Staff was friendly and helpful, very knowledgeable and informed. Wonderful tequila selection, drink were on par with quality of food. My only thing I would change is the cheese chorizo were not my favorite. We will be back to try other menu items since the menu to quite large and have lots of exciting things.

The food was delicious. We had 4 different dishes and each one was excellent. Service was spot on and attentive to our needs. Vibrant , but not noisy. Great for a date or a celebration. I’m celiac and I could most items on the menu. Delicious. We will return when we in the area again.

Great local restaurant. Awesome seafood selection, prepared right. Good wine selection. Stop-by give them a shot.

My cousin, best friend and I went to dinner here. The food, drinks, and service all were amazing! We had a fantastic time and will definitely be back!

Milagro is my favorite restaurant in Key West! The service at other restaurants on the island is often on island time, but not here. I love that they have friendly, helpful, and attentive servers and bartenders. They have a great bar with delicious and unique cocktails - not just liquor in a cup like other places, but good, craft cocktails. My personal favorite drink is the cucumber jalapeno margarita with a salt and spice rim - so delicious! And the perfect grilled octopus was the first dish that had me hooked on this restaurant. The octopus is not chewy or too fishy in flavor - it's perfectly tender and made wish a delicious sauce pairing. All the dishes that I've had are good, but my absolute favorite is the beef shank polenta. I've sent many clients and friends here and I will continue to! If I had to offer something that I thought needed improvement, I'd say that the restaurant can quickly become very loud, but that has never kept it from being a good meal nor a good time. I always leave there looking forward to my next meal there. <3

One of the best dining experiences we’ve ever had! The Octopus is incredible! Didn’t even know Octopus could be so PERFECT! Enjoyed every single item! The pork belly, the shrimp cocktail, mango cheesecake and more! Just wow!

Our experience was awesome. The food was exceptional, the atmosphere warm and appealing, the service very professional. Our first visit will not be our last. Bellissimo !!!!

Great decision to move the resturant to Key West. Excellent atmosphere, exceptional cocktails and small plates. Complete menu on double side card. Elegantly simple. Pair the wood grilled octopus with the signature entrees.

We were vacationing in the Keys for the week and decided to eat Thanksgiving dinner out. I can tell you exactly what I had because it was excellent!!! Shrimp and grits, followed by Butternut Squash Bisque (Amazing..btw), and lastly Yellowfin Grouper. Just walking in to Milagro's, you'll know you're not at an average restaurant. The service was excellent.

Nice atmosphere, Waitress was pleasant and attentive. The french onion soup was tasty, but the tortilla soup had no flair. We both ordered the prime rib. It looked delicious, but lacked flavor and was chewy.

Medium-sized venue, upscale yet personal, with incredible food and cocktails. Four of us ate 3 different dishes – the prime rib was awesome melt-in-your-mouth, the mushroom fettuccine was a big hit and two of us had a hogfish special with grilled shrimp, asparagus, broccoli rabe and purple potatoes that we both loved. Our server, Sylvia P., was attentive and perfectly timed. Key West is full of rather informal places to eat – Milagro is the prefect blend of fine dining with Key West flair.

Wonderful experience with my family! We tremendously enjoyed the happy hour margaritas, excellent service, delicious French onion soup, Caesar salad,, Hogfish and shrimp special and also the beef shank entree. Service was excellent and not rushed. Owners are a chef husband and wife team and go above and beyond to make a special dining experience!

Milagro is the perfect place away from the hustle and bustle of downtown Key West. Happy hour is always great with some drink specials and small plates. Their menu has a nice variety of food for any taste. The staff is always friendly and accommodating. Generous portions, a full bar, nice atmosphere for dining with friends or a special night out.

Really nice meal. Wife had the octopus and wedge salad and I had a swordfish steak. The octopus was so tender. I haven't had swordfish in ages. This one melted in your mouth. Would definitely recommend.

Came to Milagro for our dinner after our wedding. Maggie was very open to accommodating us and listened to our needs and wants. The atmosphere and service was so great. No one waited to food or drinks. They were on top of everything. We are so thankful how everything ran so smooth and so happy to have Milagro apart of our memories!

Milagro was our favorite Resturant in key west. The octopus very delicious and it came with a tasty egg like pie like potato like something. No idea what it was but it complimented it well. The steak we ordered medium and it came out a little too rare and we returned it and they brought it back in seconds seared yet medium inside ! I love that they got it right. The staff was kind. The atmosphere was inclusive and trendy. I loved it. Try it if you’re tired of the fried American dinning options on duval.

One of my favorite places in Key West! Everything is delicious and Sylvia makes killer drinks!

This was the best meal we had in Key West. They have lots of reservations, so I recommend making them, but they did for my husband and me for a table of 2, no reservation. Our server was fantastic and knew the menu well, and could make recommendations for us. The cocktails are elevated and sophisticated. I switched to iced tea at the end of our meal, and they make it table side for you. My husband simply went gaga for the octopus starter. I had prime rib and he had a fish entree (don't remember which: maybe grouper) and we both loved it.) This place is very nice, a date-style restaurant. They accommodate groups, but didn't see any children. It's upscale, with well-trained and attentive staff, and prices aren't cheap, but your paying for amazing food and service, and good portions. And bonus: because it was about 114 feel temp the day we went: it's indoors and air conditioned! It's on a quiet end of Simonton St, easy for rideshare pickups and drop offs, with a parking lot 1/2 block in the back if your driving.