The best Ice cream EVER!!! It is so smooth and feels very nice in your mouth! They have a wide assortment of flavors to accommodate everyone! Their passion fruit and key lime flavors are to DIE for and they taste sooooo delicious! The staff was very friendly and it has a nice ambiance. The outside area to sit is so cute and it has lots of room. 100% recommend going here if you want really good ice cream! Prices are really good too!

I love this place!!! Not sure why the other reviews called it expensive..prices were very fair. Their gelato is homemade & delicious! Lots of flavor variety as well. Do bring cash because cards are not accepted!

Yummy homemade ice cream at an affordable price. Great flavors to choose from. Quick and friendly service.

Every time we go to Key West we HAVE to stop by here. Kids demand it! Even if it's out of our way and it's 7pm and it's another 20 minute walk. That says it all. They have lots of choices. I personally love their Cuban coffee flavor. Kids have tried many others and have always been pleased. There are ice cream places on every corner, not sure how it compares to the others places as we have never had a chance to try them since we all like this one.

I LOVE THIS PLACE!! I got a waffle with 2 scoops and the portion size was so big!! I had coconut with guava. The coconut was delicious with some bits of coconut flakes. The guava was beyond delicious it was superb, tasted exactly like guava and it didn't taste artificial either. They have some tables with umbrellas outside which was nice. If you are looking for local made ice cream come here and you will not regret it!

Delicious! I had French chocolate, coconut and chocolate Kahlua my fiance had mango, lavender and banana. Go big or go home get the three scoops for $7.75. they don't take credit cards so make sure you have cash on hand. Highly recommend trying them. There's also picnic tables outside to sit on.

A pretty average experience. I had 2 scoops of sorbets, one key lime and the other orange. Quantities are good but tastes are whatever, it doesn’t really taste anything… and the texture was pretty icy, hence not nice to have in mouth. The waiter was nice though and smily.

Homemade ice cream and sorbet. Hidden gem in Key West. Love the unique flavors. Cute interior. A little pricey for what you get but so much better than the big brands. Definitely a must try.

This place is phenomenal! The ice cream is homemade and absolutely delicious! There were many flavors of ice cream and gelato to choose from. There are even some dairy free ( sorbet) and fat-free options. I went there for the butter pecan, which is also very good. But after tasting the lavender and pumpkin pie (the October special), it totally changed my mind. The server was very very friendly, I wish I had remembered her name ( from Orlando). Anyway, the waffle cone was also fresh tasting. I would strongly recommend this place, you will leave happy!

Late night sweet treat at Flamingo Crossing Ice Cream in Key West! 🤤🍦 Waffle cones tasted super fresh! Nice crunch and made just right. I had cookies and cream & my significant other had guava. Both were freaking delicious!!! This family-owned business had sooooo many other indulging flavors, too! I chose this place over another when we were walking down Duval Street and I am super pleased. ♡ Will be back for sure! 🤙🏼

Ice cream you must have! I’ve been visiting this ice cream shop for over 20 years. I absolutely love their flavors and the taste of the ice cream. I highly recommend.

It's never a late night in keywest but we got here just in time for their closing and had we not rushed we would have missed the amazing goodness. The staff let us have a taste before we committed to the flavors. We got the Mamey and the Guava flavor icecream and the only gripe we had was we hadn't gotten more of it. The icecream was premium and although I didn't ask but I am sure the overrun in the icecream was really less, making it really extra creamy and rich and smooth. Although, I had never tried mamey fruit but I could tell it was what the real fruit tasted like from the way the guava flavor felt like having real guava. Absolutely loved it. Highly recommended!!!!

Holy flavors! There are so many yummy choices. I was blown away by how spot on the key lime pie ice cream is.

Loved their milkshakes! Also they got so many different ice cream flavors it’s awesome!

I enjoyed chocolate ice cream on a sugar cone while sitting out front under a shade tree ... watching baby chicks and their mom. It was a pleasant end to my afternoon. ❤️ KW I definitely recommend their ice cream. The service is friendly and knowledgeable about their product.

There's nothing like a double scoop of you favorite ice cream on a sugar cone to cool you off in the Key West sun! There are plenty of picnic tables on the patio to enjoy your creamy treat. No debit or credit cards were being accepted when we visited, but I had cash on hand. Don't forget Key West is known for their wandering chickens and they make a visit while you're in the area.

Best Ice-creamery in the FL Keys (same now probably very old people family now have been making this delicious creamy and I'm sure very fattening ice-cream for over 40 yrs or longer) Since I was a kid growing up here would I sneak over as often as possible for local flavors. Try the mangrove walnut, Cuban coffee, rum raisin, and all the fruit flavors are natural and best you will find anywhere. Excellent even on the hottest days of mid-winter you will want to try this place out when visiting the Keys.

Delicious homemade ice cream. The lady who served us let us sample different flavors and we had a nice conversation with her. She was very friendly!

The ice cream is nothing to scream about. The guava tasted good but the pineapple didn’t taste anything like pineapple and the soursop didn’t taste like soursop. The poor employee was working by herself in the peak of summer and they did not have stabilizing things for her ice cream buckets so it was hard for her to scoop! - cheap owners!

Lots of flavors. Great tasting ice cream. Very busy. A little pricey but they got you on Vacation, so you pay. Only cash for payment. Service on the day I was there was very slow, so you must have a lot of patience.

Most expensive ice-cream ever I bought but homemade and really tasty. I had Key Lime and Lavendel. 😍😋

Best homemade creamy light flavorful without being too sweet. Absolutely Delicious! My favorite, blueberry cream and coconut on a homemade waffle cone. I’m the pickiest ice cream lover ever, this is hands down the best in my world!!!!!

Great local icecream shop! Prices are excellent too and there's a variety of flavors to choose from (some that I haven't seen in other shops nearby). Got the French chocolate w/ cookies n cream, coconut with soursop, and i forgot the sorbets but it's good. Lady who served us was really nice as well.

Delicious! They have wide range of flavors, varieties. Absolutely worth to order. Take cash , have an ATM inside. Nice location and great staff.