Minatogawa Clinics image

Minatogawa Clinics

Hospital Psychiatric hospital

😠 Poor environment, doctors and nurses with no sense of responsibility. Doctors don't care about patients and families. Nurses also don't treat patients as people. I couldn't even communicate with the nurses. Patients are not able to manage their belongings and they end up losing them. And I don't thi... People often mention hospital, doctor, patients, hospitalized, room, Hospital, nurses, body, discharged,


Address

3 Chome-13-20 Minatogawacho, Hyogo Ward, Kobe, Hyogo 652-0041, Japan

Website

www.minatogawa.jp

Contact

+81 78-521-1367

Rating on Google Maps

2.50 (26 reviews)

Open on Google Maps

Working Hours

  • Wednesday: 9 am to 5 pm
  • Thursday: 9 am to 5 pm
  • Friday: (The Emperor's Birthday), 9 am to 5 pm, Hours might differ
  • Saturday: 9 am to 5 pm
  • Sunday: Closed
  • Monday: 9 am to 5 pm
  • Tuesday: 9 am to 5 pm

Featured Reviews


Frequently mentioned in reviews: hospital (28) doctor (15) patients (8) hospitalized (8) room (8) Hospital (8) nurses (7) body (7) discharged (6)
Reviews are sorted by relevance, prioritizing the most helpful and insightful feedback at the top for easier reference.
  • 1/5 プリねこ 7 years ago on Google • 3 reviews
    Poor environment, doctors and nurses with no sense of responsibility. Doctors don't care about patients and families. Nurses also don't treat patients as people. I couldn't even communicate with the nurses. Patients are not able to manage their belongings and they end up losing them. And I don't think it's bad at all. Treatment is limited to drugs with strong side effects. Patients are given only medicine and left alone. In some cases, they are restrained and left alone. If the patient becomes unwell, they are transferred to another hospital and the money is collected in cash. This is not a hospital. This is definitely not a hospital you should go to.
    53 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 中田満帆 2 years ago on Google • 3 reviews
    In February 2015, I was hospitalized through the ward office due to speech problems, breathing problems, consciousness disturbance, and withdrawal symptoms due to excessive alcohol consumption. On the first day of hospitalization, my condition deteriorated significantly, so I asked my doctor, Dr. Madoka Goto, to move me to an open room instead of the closed room I had designated. However, the doctor tried to lock it up, so I tried to escape and ended up being put in a detention room for about a week. During the intense withdrawal, he was not even allowed to drink water and was forced to defecate while still wearing restraints. After that, the symptoms caused by alcohol subsided, but I was never discharged from the hospital, and I was not informed of any plans for hospitalization, so I ended up staying in the hospital for almost 6 months instead of the 3 months I was hospitalized for treatment. Since the doctor in charge was not on duty full-time, we were unable to communicate with each other, and when we did talk, he continued to avoid specific topics and was completely irresponsible. During my stay in the hospital, I particularly remember the arrogant and violent behavior of the nurses, the sight of an old woman tied to a bed and in a weakened state being taken into a detention room, the number of escapes, and the "management" by the office staff. (Management fees are collected every day for "management", and if it becomes negative, you will naturally have to pay the amount). I expressed my intention to be discharged from the hospital and called the mental health center, but they told me that I could not be discharged without my parents' permission, which they did not give me when I was admitted. While I was in the hospital, I requested a meeting with a clinical psychologist, but the person who came was a social psychologist who admittedly was not an expert and charged me a fee for a simple chat. Until the very end, the doctor in charge did not provide any basis for hospitalization. After I was discharged from the hospital, I suffered from deviant behavior, perhaps as a reaction to the long period of confinement, but with the counseling and tranquilizer prescriptions I received at the Koji Clinic, which I started attending afterwards, I have been able to lead a stable life to this day. This hospital has had deaths in the past. If you would like to receive inpatient treatment, we recommend going to Arima Kogen Hospital or Kofu Hospital. This is a hospital with a very low level of human rights awareness. I don't recommend it.
    41 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 毎日星空 6 years ago on Google
    (Translated by Google) Locally known as off-base hospital It's noisy every day, and my heart is sick all the way here (Original) 近所での通称は基地外病院 毎日うるさくこちらまで心が病んできます
    31 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 Gon 4 months ago on Google • 37 reviews
    Doctors, nurses, and caseworkers who speak out against families as if they are inferior to others.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 3/5 まるよしの 5 years ago on Google • 21 reviews
    The building itself is old. There were a lot of people in the waiting room, so it wasn't very comfortable, but the doctor I met was kind enough to give me advice. thank you very much.
    8 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 4/5 November 1 year ago on Google • 26 reviews
    My family was hospitalized, and the receptionist and nurses were very nice and it was a very nice hospital. Why are the reviews so bad? It is true that the equipment is old, but I think most people who are concerned about such things do not need to be hospitalized. The doctor in charge was also very kind, and if you're worried just by reading the reviews, I think it's better to actually visit and check it out. According to the person who was hospitalized, the food was better than that at Kobe Central Municipal Hospital.
    4 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 3/5 まさお靴下 4 years ago on Google
    (Translated by Google) Such a doctor who denies everything that the patient talks about and wants to end with Naanaa is out of the question. I am in any hospital. Even though my health certificate says that a close examination is necessary, I was amazed at "Is it health?" “There is no reason to remember the words you heard when you were a child ...” Isn't it natural? That's the same as yesterday's memory. Doesn't it matter if your blood pressure is high or when you are hot in summer? I don't care about the detailed expertise. Why do I get dizzy in 30 seconds when I enter the sauna? I came out. Your blood pressure was high even if it was not a direct cause. If you say that you have cured your back pain for 10 years, “You just happened to be cured.” Right now, TV, books, and the Internet are about ways to prevent back pain. After all, chronic low back pain can only be cured with flexible gymnastics and strength training. What do you mean when you don't ask me how to exercise? Do you have a medical examination at another place? I feel like there was a name in the hospital where the doctor said, “What should I hang on a lie detector?” Is it a coincidence that PTSD-related books disappeared from bookstores? I asked a doctor and asked where the bookstore was. Immediately after that, more than 10 books became 2-3 books. I don't have any misrepresentation. Although it is a developmental disorder, the spirit is normal as you say. The correct answer is derived from logical thinking, objectivity and all information. Please know the truth. Now I have a doctor instead. I finally met an ordinary human doctor, but I have no intention of telling anything. It's okay if you give me medicine. That's the doctor's job. I can't trust anyone. All human beings are enemies. (Original) 患者の喋ること全てを否定する、ナアナアで済まそうとする、そういう医者は論外ですね。何処の病院にも居ますけど。私の持ってきた健康診断書に、精密検査の必要ありと書いてあるのに、「健康そのものじゃないですかー」には呆れました。「子供の頃に聞いた言葉をそのまま思い出す訳がない...」当たり前じゃないですか?それは昨日の記憶も同じでしょ。血圧が高い事と、夏の暑い時にシンドイ事は関係ないんですか?細かい専門知識はどうでも良いです。サウナに入ると30秒で立ち眩みし出すのは何故ですか?這って出ましたけど。直接的原因でなくても血圧は高かったんですよね。10年間腰痛だったのを自分で治したと言ったら「たまたま治っただけや。」今はテレビや本やネットでも腰痛予防のやり方とか出てますよね。結局慢性的な腰痛は柔軟体操と筋力トレーニングでしか治らないでしょ。私の運動のやり方を聞いてもいないのに何をいい加減なこと言うとるんですか。別のところでも診察しとるんですか。「何なら嘘発見器にでも掛けましょか」と言った医者の居る病院に名前があった気がするんですけど。PTSD関連の本が本屋から消えたのは偶然でしょうか。医者に訊かれて何処の本屋か答えましたけど。そのすぐ後に10冊以上あったのが2~3冊になりました。私には虚言癖などありません。発達障害ですがあなた方の言う通り精神は正常です。論理的思考と客観性と全ての情報から正しい答えは導き出される。正論を知って下さい。今現在は医者を代えて貰いました。やっと普通の人っぽい医者に会いましたけど、もう何も伝える気はありません。薬さえ出してりゃそれでいいんですよ。それが医者の仕事なんでしょ。誰の事も信用できません。世の中の人間は全員敵です。
    21 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 みやみや 10 months ago on Google • 11 reviews
    I have nothing really bad to say, so I recommend hospitals other than this one. This place was the worst. I got sick and went to different psychiatric clinics, and finally found a doctor (another hospital) that I could trust. I had to see a psychiatrist in an emergency, so I had no choice but to go to Minatogawa Hospital instead of my primary doctor. The teacher is very bossy and speaks in a threatening manner. Interrupt the patient and say what you want to say. It's also clear to say things like, ``I'm going to die if I continue like this.'' Don't use "might" for things that are not certain. Also, they probably think that patients are crazy and that they can't communicate with them. I can't hold a conversation. Or rather, the teacher doesn't have the will to listen to me. I was told that I would be admitted immediately 10 minutes after the examination started. What can you learn in 10 minutes? I declined, though. Is there also a quota for the number of hospitalized patients? In the case of psychiatry, famous and excellent doctors often have to wait three months for their first appointment. I want to be seen right away, so I'm tempted to compromise and go to a hospital like this. Please wait for 3 months or 6 months. Please, everyone, please see a good teacher. If it's a disease and not a congenital disability, it can be cured. Don't choose based on compromise...
    5 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 4/5 Yuz S. 3 years ago on Google
    (Translated by Google) Both teachers and staff are kind and polite. (Original) 先生、スタッフ共に親切丁寧に応対して頂けます。
    4 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 3/5 中村燈 4 years ago on Google
    (Translated by Google) Facilities and appearance are old, but had you cope with all the staff kindly (Original) 設備や外観など古めですが、職員さん皆には親切に対応していただきました
    2 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 3/5 ぽんポンポン 2 years ago on Google
    (Translated by Google) It was a very old hospital (Original) めっちゃめっちゃ古い病院でした
    2 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 tena h. 5 years ago on Google • 1 review
    Officials at this hospital said that Minatogawa Hospital is the same as a life support center. In particular, Director of Nursing Atsushi Aoki, Chief Nursing Officer Takeshi Shirai, and Hospital Director Yutaka Shirai give instructions and orders to their subordinate nurses, attending physicians, and related personnel, and they are trying to get patients to be admitted for medical protection and get their treatment back. Numerous former patients say that the initial settings for sensors that were not found in various parts of the patient's body caused sudden abnormalities in the patient's body as a result of following him like a stalker, often while walking when going out, and even near his home. It was. Before admitting the patient to a hospital, the patient's body data is backed up on a device by attaching a sensor, transferring pathogens from other patients, using it as a testbed, using the sensor signal as a satellite signal, or transmitting radio waves using wires to a server to destroy the human body. Remotely dizzy or severe breathing difficulties or headaches, speech disorders (slurred speech or dramatic changes in voice quality), difficulty walking, other patients' biological bacteria (leukemia, cancer, AIDS bacteria, sensors, etc.) There are various other things, as there is clear information that they are using the method of injecting drugs into the body, causing irreversible and fatal damage to the body to the point that it is impossible to return to a normal life, and causing repeated hospitalizations and hospitalizations. Since this is a suspicious hospital, I would like more than 100 police officers to get a search warrant and investigate. This is a malicious hospital that uses human experiment equipment to inflict severe damage on patients in order to keep them in and out of the hospital, and they are trying to force them to repeat medical protection hospitalizations, so they have the police follow up with a search warrant and request the Self-Defense Forces to carry out a raid and dispose of dangerous materials. I would like to request that everyone from the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications and the Health Bureau respond as soon as possible.
    41 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 SENA 2 years ago on Google • 2 reviews
    It made me feel so uncomfortable that I didn't even want to give it one star. A year ago, my mental illness worsened and I desperately went to this hospital to be examined, but I will never forget the poor treatment of the male doctor in charge. Instead of properly listening to what the patient has to say, she is always busy taking notes, and her attitude shows that she is too clerical and wants to finish the examination as quickly as possible. He never listens to what his mother, who goes into the examination room with him, says. I end up denying it. He is the worst man with no delicacy and acts like a lecture to his mother. Is he really a psychiatrist? The level of doubt.
    35 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 松本英紀 1 year ago on Google • 1 review
    The building of this Minatogawa Hospital is old and the interior is dirty and dilapidated.I was diagnosed with schizophrenia from the hospital I used to go to in Osaka and was forcibly admitted to this Minatogawa Hospital, but due to the corona virus, I was unable to visit and was kept at the shop. I wasn't allowed to go shopping, so I wandered around the hallways, and I could only watch TV in a special room where everyone could watch. Before I was hospitalized, I had no problems other than auditory hallucinations, but after I was discharged from the hospital, it became difficult to see in both eyes, and my head started to hurt. I felt empty, my whole body was weak, and I felt dizzy and had difficulty walking. I think this hospital must have used me as a test subject. Rather than going there again, I would like to hire a lawyer and ask for compensation.
    5 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 risa Y. 8 months ago on Google • 1 review
    I was suddenly forced to be hospitalized, and although I didn't need psychiatric medication, the nurses threatened me, and I was unable to get the liver and dermatology medications I really needed. Since I didn't know the contents of the medicine, I refused everything except vitamins. My doctor told me he never wanted to see my face again, so I stayed in a room with a surveillance camera until three days before I was discharged. The friends I made at this hospital could no longer understand what they were saying. If you take drugs like you're told, you'll become a loser.


Call +81 78-521-1367 Open on Google Maps

Trends



Last updated:

Similar places



Similar Hospitals nearby

Last updated:
()