Just curious about raw dough in a pizza: is it something I should be eating? Three of the last well-done pizzas we've ordered had raw dough. Any comments will be appreciated!

I was really disappointed in how I was treated at this establishment. last night I placed an order over the phone and when I went to pick it up I was ignored by the cashier. I stood in front of the cash register for five minutes waiting for her to offer me service; the whole time she ignored me while she continue to have a personal conversation with a male coworker. She was completely unprofessional (actually they both were). I find the customer service here to be horrible and the staff to be unfriendly and unprofessional. I would not recommend this place to anyone.

I was in the mood for some spaghetti and meatballs and I have passed this restaurant many times over the past year and it also looked interesting. Today I stopped in by myself and they say me very quickly and took my order as soon as I sat down. So service was excellent, very attentive, fast and very polite. The food was amazing and the portion I had received was well worth the money👍😁 I also ordered a drink as well which also was delicious, unfortunately I was so full I could not drink the whole thing . I will be going back and can't wait to try dessert and will definitely get pics and videos.

We ate dinner at this restaurant last night and really enjoyed it. The ambiance was nice and the service was great. We both enjoyed our food. I had the seafood FraDiablo over spinach (low carb)and my husband had the veal cutlet parmesan. The portions were large and the food was good. He also got the baked clams as an appetizer and said they were good also. The only thing I could complain about was the muscles in my dish. I thought they tasted a little off so I only ate the shrimp and the calamari. I would order the same dish again but without the muscles. The food is reasonably priced and you got a soup or a salad with your meal. They have an outside dining area which also had couches for having drinks. They have live music on Friday and Saturday night outside which is very nice.

The food is great. They have many pizza varieties. The staff is always nice and accommodating.

I will always tell you the way it is. Been going to them since day one. there quality has been declining really bad. the other day the pie was a 2 on a scale of 1 to 10. so sad I will have to look for another go to place.

It used to be great. Seems like new ownership and the food is sub-par. Definitely not worth the trip. So many better places.

Great restaurant! I ate here with my family the other day and the Staff and Food were all fantastic! our Server, Danielle was extremely nice and such a sweetheart! I highly recommend this Restaurant and I will dine here again.

Definitely the local pizza place everyone in town comes for pizza and pasta. The crust has sesame seeds which some people love and others not so much. Foods usually always warm the service is very fast.

We did take out this time. All good including the Lobster bisk, delicious just a touch too much salt but ate it all. I will keep going when I'm in the area.

We came with a group of about 20 after a funeral . They could not have been better, food delicious, service attentative but not pushy. Although I called only a half hour before we came, they were prepared for us. During a difficult time we felt pampered.

First time here. I had the spinach and artichoke slice and it was fantastic. Had a regular slice as well and it did not disappoint. I will definitely be back to try their meals. Its a nice restaurant and the staff was helpful and friendly. Prices are reasonable.

Service was EXCELLENT! Everyone was so friendly and attentive. Food was delicious! Rice balls were sooo good. Portions ample with enough to bring leftovers home. Thoroughly enjoyed the Cucumber Spa Water cocktail. We'll definitely be back!

Mary's food is so delicious. Their mac and cheese pizza is really really delicious. I'm not the biggest Mac and cheese fan but this was the exception. The eggplant parm pizza was also the bomb.

Amazing penne Ala Vodka, and grilled chicken Caesar slice! Clam sauce with linguini is another amazing dish! Always nice portions

Just very nice people,serverice great good food and reasonable prices. I come from BV to dine here that's 15 miles 1 way

I have not eaten here in person yet, but I ordered through an app. The slices were delicious that I had, and this time, I also received calzones. So far, I enjoyed all the slices except for the pasta stice. Just pizza and pasta don't feel like they are meant to be together, in my opinion.

Ordered a Chicken Parm pie and it was amazing. It had thin crust with sesame. Everything from cheese to chicken tasted very fresh and tasteful. I will definitely be ordering again from here in the future.

We used to go all the time, but recently. But recently, I found the menu has changed, and I got charged for extra cheese on my eggplant rollatine. I thought cheese always came on dinners at itlain restaurant! Don't get me wrong, the food was good . But eggplant rollitine with no mozzarella!?

Came here for a surprise party. I ordered ther personal pie and asked the waitress how big it was and the size she described was not what I got. The pie was HUGE. Definitely couldn't eat more than two slices. I got the chicken bomber . It was good but had so much chicken and not a lot of anything else . I would recommend but def ask for extra sauce

Let me start off by saying that the food still taste the same. Marys is my go to place in long island for many years now. Over the past 2 years or so the prices have increased. However we never wavered because the quality and portions did not change. The quality has been definately downgraded, within the last few orders. the pizza is now more of a thin crust pizza and it no longet comes with the special crust that they would use. They use to give you a 5 topping price but now your charged per topping and served an inferior pizza . The pizza was half pepperoni and sausauge and half ham and mushroom all with extra cheese. All of the toppings seemed to be chopped smaller or something like that, like mini toppings . 40 dollars. The side portions were still 8 dollars but also noticibly difference in the usual portions. Again what i ordered still tasted good. Just downgraded from what Marys was well known for.

Love the food. Great service and friendly staff. I only have 2 complaints. I often order the same slice as a friend of mine. The sizes are hit or miss. One time my slice was less than half the size of my friends. It made for a good laugh. I suppose I got the diet slice. Also, very minor, the cups they give you when you ask for the free water are comically small. I think they want to discourage you from getting the water. But soda is so expensive lately. I just can't see speeding near 3 dollars for sugar water. But all restaurants are like this, so do I understand. And I get more exercise having to get up to refill my cup. So win win for me.

I mean what kinda place goes above and beyond like Marys? Always willing to help and the food is amazing. Service here is second to none. Someone new starts, doesn't matter. That person Is instilled hard work and amazing service. Thanks for being the best, always.

Mike is awesome, even though he forgot to cut my kids pizza in squares🤣🤣, They still approved! Need more pleasant ppl like him!

I love this place! The food is top quality, every time. The service is great and I highly recommend it.

Delicious creamy chicken soup. We sat down and ate here for lunch one day. You can rither take out or dine in and we had a nice experience.

They are very nice here. This will be the only pizza place I eat at in this community all the rest have nasty attitudes. I spend my dollars where I am welcomed.

I ordered a large cheese pizza and a grilled chicken Buffalo wrap on whole wheat with avocado. However the Buffalo wrap was absolutely disgusting!!! They never put the avocado on at all and charged me for it, the grilled chicken was Drenched with Frank’s red hot sauce and came with no cheese and forgot the blue cheese dressing. Never going back!!

Just the best. We had a fabulous dinner and our waitress was fabulous!!

The food was outstanding their service was excellent and the whole staff was very cordial!

Chicken dinner -was difficult to cut and thin as cardboard. Gnocchi was in a white sauce and we sent it back- tasteless They sent it back to us with a red sauce. Salads were good thank God. Probably will not return to restaurant in the future.

Everything is great. We have been eating here for years and love the food and staff! The best pizza! The Mac and cheese burger is amazing as well!

Delicious! First time there. I had the chicken Cordon Blue. I wanted to finish the entire thing and then some. I messed up and didn't take a picture but definitely next time.

I come here frequently and normally get pizza slices which are amazing but today I got the Eggplant panini and it was delicious! 10/10 would continue to recommend coming here for lunch!

Great cheese slice, nice and thin! Also had the Thai chili (might be getting the name wrong) but delicious and very generous with the topping. Was lucky enough to be treated to the meal so I'm unsure of exact cost, but seemed more than reasonable.

Waited was supper nice it was four of us I had ordered the stuffed shrimp but find it to salty. Cut down on salt we could alway add salt but we can't take is away. Thank you and yes I will try it again.

Beware…. Check the bill carefully, we were a party of six and the tip was added to the bill. We didn’t know that, we left $30 cash on top of the $25. Yes, we should have checked the bill more carefully but we also should have been told.

There were so many great speciality slices, it was hard to choose! The vodka grandma was to-die-for! Great selection of lunch specials in the dining room as well. The staff are friendly and helpful.

Very expensive 🍕 pizza. I think I'll learn to make my own. $9 for an egg plant slice and a regular slice. I could have ordered a hero for that. Food is good but I eat out less frequently now since covid and higher prices. Just not in the budget.

Very skimpy on the seafood. Used get a salad with the dinner, now you don’t even get a glass of water. Flies all around our table, just not a place for dinner anymore….!!👎