Mama Mia that's a meal... Homemade deliciousness. Service was great, place was busy but we were seated quickly and food came in reasonable time. Fresh garlic bread, salad with their own creamy Italian dressing. One had Penne pasta with Broccoli Rabe & sausage, the other Shrimp & scallops Fra Diavolo and Cheesecake for dessert. All was good, plenty of food and prices were good for the quantity and quality.

Wow! I went on a Monday night and had the Pasta Night special which included a salad, garlic toast, a huge plate of lasagna, and a brownie with coffee. This meal special was only $13.95 and it included great service. If I'm ever back this way on a Monday, I'll be back!

Cute restaurant! This was my first time in NY. My boss said we needed to get some NY pizza. I tried the most carbalicious pizza I could find.... baked ziti pizza! I also ordered a salad. Very yummy and filling, it was lunch and later the leftovers were my dinner! The restaurant itself was super cute. I recommend!

Went here with a group of 5 people for an early Sunday dinner. One person was in a wheelchair, and they were very accommodating. We ordered fried calamari which was perfectly crisp with lots of flavor. Baked clams were delicious. I had the Veal Saltimbocca, not only was it delicious but I had enough for lunch the next day. My husband had the triple dinner which was lasagna, chicken parmesan and eggplant rollitini. All great, and plenty for a delicious lunch. The house salads were fresh and crisp. Our friends had lobster ravioli which included shrimp in the sauce and the last was a stuffed cod fish. Of course we had to finish with some expresso and Italian Cheese Cake. Everything was delicious. The service was great. We will definitely be back after discovering this hidden gem by accident.

One server for a full restaurant. He did his best to hustle and get to everything and everyone. Food was average. Desert was awful. I had chocolate cake, had NO taste at all, tow bites and I was out. Carrot cake was so so.

Great value! Went for their Thursday Chicken Nite 3 course meal for $14.95. Portions were huge and tasty. Service was attentive. Will definitely return..

This local spot was recommended to me by friends from Long Island, and it did not disappoint. Richie and the staff do a phenomenal job, attentive and make fantastic pizza. Everyone here is personable and dedicated to what they do. You can tell all of the ingredients are fresh, from the dough to the toppings. Great wine selection and fair prices. Will be stopping in on my next trip to NY, keep up the good work!

Been coming here for years and even after moving to Florida, whenever I'm back home in the Smithtown area, I always stop here for a few slices of regular Sicilian or the Marinara style. They unequivocally have the best pizza in the Hauppauge/ Smithtown area. Thier Sicilian should be a benchmark for how to create an unforgettable pizza. Each Sicilian slice weighs at least 8-10oz. The crust, cheese and sauce are the perfect ratio of Sicilian bliss. If you've never been here, it's a must try. I come here mostly for the Sicilian, but have had several of their heros in the past and a few entrees. All of them are stellar in their own right. Service and atmosphere is warm, inviting and attentive to your needs. They make you feel like your visiting the family you haven't seen in a while.

The food was awesome! The salad was very fresh and homemade.The owner was very nice and he was very helpful even the cook himself was very nice. The atmosphere made it feel like very dancer restaurant. Everything was fantastic. I definitely want to come back!

This was a small little place that upon opening the menu we realized it was a huge slice of Italy 🇮🇹. I have no complaints and would recommend this place to anyone & everyone! The food was ABSOLUTELY authentic and delicious - made to order and sizeable portions with complimentary handmade garlic bread!! Oh so so delicioso!!

Met the owner tonight, was an absolute pleasure to speak with even with 2 minutes before closing. Good to know theres hardworking passionate small business owners that care about their customers. Food was absolutely delicious. I would recommend this spot to anyone and everyone who wants excellent Italian food.

Stopped in while in town for business. A quaint place with amazing food. The zuppa di pesce fra diavolo was incredible and filling. My only complaint was the shrimp was slightly over cooked but did not take away from the dish. So much delicious shellfish. I would have liked a wine Menu that they also had peroni on draft. I would frequent this place if I lived in the area for the food and friendly staff. Loved sitting in the front where I could watch them cooking.

The pizza is good, the service was not. The woman on the phone was unfriendly and uninterested. The food pick-up did not improve things. The counter people were bored and unfriendly in equal measure. The restaurant is in need of some serious updating and detailed cleaning. Place has seen better days.

Visit Mama Angelina's for an excellent slice of pizza. They use semolina on the crust, which I love. The sauce is just right. Try the buffalo, or marsala slices, or just a slice of pepperoni. If you can recognize good pizza, you will be very pleased. Kyle is always friendly and helpful. I highly recommend this place for takeout pizza.

Good food, nice restaurant and friendly staff. The house dressing is some of the best around. The salad slice is a hidden treasure. Its bigger than a small salad and you get it on a slice. They have special nights like pasta night, chicken night and others so there is never a bad time to go.

We order pizza here quite often. The pizza is always good. The crust has a good flavor, as most other pizzerias around taste like cardboard. The sauce is well seasoned and won’t disappoint. The cheese to sauce ratio is good as well. Atmosphere is a mixed bag. My family mostly takes out. We have eaten at the restaurant which is quite nice, but I would say casual dining…The drawback is that the takeout and the dining are not separate, which I think takes away from a more formal dining experience. But I think that is the point here. That said, it is a great casual restaurant. One I would take my family to for a nice dinner. Service is good.

Cute little place with great service. The food is very good with huge portions. We thought it was missing some salt, but that might not be the worst thing.

Ordered regular pie. Absolutely horrendous. Taste like an upscale dominoes. Garlic knots were cold ,sauce tastes like jar sauce. Not cheap either.

We are in town for a softball tournament and I was charged with planning the team dinner. Richie was wonderful to work with from the start. He helped plan a menu that worked well for the kids and adults. The amount of food he calculated was spot on and the price was very reasonable. Food was delivered on time and was hot! Everyone loved the food especially the penne ala vodka and meatballs. Highly recommend!

ARE YOU FREAKING KIDDING ME! Probably the best I have ever had! We got the Shrimp and Portabella with sherry white sauce! Super creamy, perfectly balanced. No added cheese needed. Tera miso drove my date crazy! Thank you thank you!

What a surprise! The food is amazing, service is great and plenty of parking. Go back for there seafood nite. I had shrimp Pam with zita (sauce abit tangy) and the wife had grill chicken hero. Great date!

Met the owner tonight, was an absolute pleasure to speak with even with 2 minutes before closing. Good to know theres hardworking passionate small business owners that care about their customers. Food was absolutely delicious. I would recommend this spot to anyone and everyone who wants excellent Italian food.

Really nice place. The food was very good, and the prices were less than I would have expected for the sheer amount of food I got. Further, the inside dining area was very clean and well kept.

Good pizza selection. Lunch specials are good value. Mid afternoon special pizzas did look like sat a while. But to be expected. Clean and good service.

Great pasta night. Big portions....salad, entree and dessert for decent price.

The food and service here is beyond amazing! We came on a busy Sunday night/Memorial Day weekend but they were able to get out party of 8 in. The quality of the food was beyond delicious and the service was matched! We will definitely return!

Went to enjoy the great New York pizza I hear so much about. I'm visiting the area and this s close to my hotel. I walked in and nobody greeted me so I sat down. I waited while I watched the staff clean. The hostess walked past me 3 or 4 times and never acknowledged me. Them a family of four walked in and were immediately greeted. I thanked everybody for their help and left. That is10 minutes of my life I'll never get back. First impressions are everything and apparently my money wasn't good enough.

Went there today for Pizza and Peroni. I ordered a slice of regular pizza. The cheese tasted so-so. The beer was good. This is an ordinary pizzeria. It is not worth the effort to come here and buy a slice, considering that the amount of pizzerias are a dime a dozen on the Island.

Oh how the mighty have fallen, I went here for years regularly, but sure to diet change I stopped. I couldn't believe how empty the place was, it was hard to see. We walked in and no customers were there. It was weekday afternoon and the place was a ghost town. There used to be a line on any given day especially at 1pm. So we walk up to the counter, the person can help us right away since there are no customers. I was shocked how all the pies looked, so small and sad looking (think congealed cheese but not). I was looking forward to a chicken parm or BBQ chicken slice, but they simply weren't appealing to the eye. I know they just needed to be reheated but still. We eat with our eyes first. I opted for a Greek salad pizza slice, which was delicious, looked fresh and I absolutely loved the all feta cheese, a bit of a messy eat, but that's what I get for eating salad on a pizza crust. I wish they would have used kalamata olives instead of boring black olives, but that's a preference of mine. I used to love this place but it simply isn't the same anymore. I likely won't be back, there are so many other places doing the same thing and the food in the case that is supposed to entice me actually turned me off. We sat down to eat, and could have sat anywhere. For the roughly 50 minutes we were there, there were 3, maybe 4 other customers. Hopefully, for their sake, they figure out how to right the ship and fast. Maybe pasta or chicken night is better, I don't know, but for a pizza lunch it's a pass for me.