I recently dined at Sharky's, drawn in by the numerous raving reviews. However, my overall experience left me a bit disappointed. On the positive side, the service was commendable, as the staff was attentive and accommodating, even staying open late for us. Unfortunately, parking was an inconvenience, with the lot across the road being full and an unhelpful parking attendant adding to the frustration. As for the cocktails, they were enjoyable, providing a decent selection of well-prepared drinks. The flavors were satisfying and added some positive notes to the dining experience.

We stopped by to have dinner because the reviews were so good, but what we experienced far surpassed our expectations. The restaurant was closed due to the down season as they all are, but we didn't know that and we drove over for dinner. The owner, Lowell, was about to have dinner with his family, but when we walked up, he told us to have a seat, shared his dinner and his wine, and we spent the next three hours becoming friends. That is how they do it in the islands.

Words simply do no justice to the delicious goodness that is served at Sharky’s. When we asked residents we interacted with for recommendations on the one restaurant that they would dine at weekly or daily if they could, sharky’s was the number choice. One bite of the highly recommended lobster risotto and cake and it was clear why this business was such a gem. The service was so smooth and efficient; the staff informative abs kind. There is a sense of pride in what they do and rightfully so. The chef makes rounds greeting each patron and getting feedback on dish. This entire dining experience was a treat for us. If we are to pick one restaurant to prioritize on another trip to Anguilla, we are choosing Sharky’s.

One of the best meals and definitely the best service we received on the island. Every staff member we encountered made sure to contribute to a positive experience! Fast & attentive service. One of the few restaurants that don’t have a service charge, which I personally liked. Having worked as a server, I believe this provides more inclination to perform better service and makes me more likely to tip more than a standard service charge as a true reflection of service received.

Hyped as the "must go" restaurant on the island it quickly became a bust for our group. The mussels were overcooked although the sauce was passable with the bread to get some flavor out of the dish, the signature dishes were bland and uninspiring. The red snapper was delivered with vegetables that were prepared well but the rice was dull and hard to swallow and the actual fish needed lots of lemon to make it worthwhile. The shrimp dish of 6 was enjoyed but again lacked in the support offering. Sometimes restaurants get the noise that they are "it" and folks don't realize what excellent other offerings are available. Sitting next to a busy evening traffic road is not our groups idea of ideal location, when you can dine in many locations on the beach of better food quality. It was a nice surprise not the have the 15% service charge on the bill - a first for us on the island. It was nice to meet the very pleasant owner but we did not have the heart to tell him in person that his restaurant fails in our minds against other offerings on the island. Time to change the chef to keep the hype running of being a must go location.

Honestly quite average, food was small in quantity. Got the snapper after having the rave reviews, overpriced for what you get (which we recognise in hindsight from other places). Also got the shrimp main and it was also just okay. Wait time was large for food but not too horrible. Waitresses were very nice and attentive though!! Personally a miss for my family despite all the rave reviews.

Update: we loved this place so much we went back. Had the lobster stir fry, and of course, the lobster risotto again. Didn't disappont! Kyla was our server, and Virginia came over to chat. Met Chef and night was complete. Terrific place! Fantastic food and service. Everyone is so friendly and always happy! Virginia was terrific as our waitress and made some great recommendations. Lobster bisque so richm. Shrimp and lobster risotto was awesome. And the red snapper was delicious . A must go!

Surprising Vegan options in the prime Hotel strip. The options did not disappoint- an amazing Spicy Pumpkin Soup followed two down home excellent perfect salads- my wife had the Goat Cheese rated phenom and I had Sharky’s house salad I licked the plate. Yum on 💯 the Vegetable Risotto I wish I could have a couple times a week.

Our family of five had a great dinner at Sharky’s during Christmas week. The food was varied and delicious. The service warm and friendly. Our food server, Gina, was an energetic blast of friendliness and hospitality. Highly recommend.

We loved, loved, loved, loved, loved Sharky’s. The food is flavorful and the service was wonderful. We loved the mocktails and the simple and sweet Caribbean ambience. Congratulations on this beautiful restaurant!

Very tasty food , a must restaurant in Anguilla to visit, we had 1 appetizer and 2 entrées and sparkling water total 118$ plus tip. Not a cheap place but those are the prices in Anguilla. Definitely recommended, suggest to make a reservation as we are arrived around 8:30pm Friday and place was almost full. ( we had reservations done in advance).

I am visiting and this restaurant was recommended by my host. I will tell you the service and people were so friendly! The lobster cake will have you smack your momma! Don’t forget about the red snapper,will always come back here when in Anguilla!

We went to Sharky's this week on a Monday. Noy a busy evening. We did not have reservations. We waited while we were told whether we could get a table or not. almost no one there so not sure what the fuss was about. While we are dinner, three more parties without reservations who were seated right away. Facing the front reception desk in the kitchen all throughout our dinner, there were at least a dozen people working in the kitchen and standing around by the front reception area. Not sure what most were doing. None smiling or looking friendly. We ordered our appetizer which came long before our drink. A gentleman came to the table and asked how things were going and I said we hadn't gotten our drinks. He got them immediately as it turned out he was the owner. When we did get out food my fish was overcooked. Drinks were not very good. We stayed for a couple of drinks and dinner. The owner checked on a several times while the employees did little. So I was very disappointed after I'd heard a recommendation from someone who lives on the island to go to Sharky's. Service was not good as I had expected. So I don't recommend this restaurant.

Sharkys is a must do! The owner Lowell came out to ever table while we were there having dinner tonight. He made us and everyone feel like the place was ares. We had the chicken curry as an app. It was unbelievable.My wife had the pork tenderloin and I had the Lobster and shrimp risotto. Both dishes were 10+. Gina was our waitress. Best waitress in a long time a real sweetheart. Like I said a must do! Murdoch Macpherson

It’s a well known place in the island and I can say it’s pretty good for the island standards. We ordered fish , vegetable and rice and some desert. All were tasty. Wait was longer for a person that lives in a city but for the island it was good. We enjoyed our meal overall.

Best grilled lobster I’ve ever had!

Great food, and service. Make a reservation early. Lobster cakes are amazing.

We were able to come out the first night to this joint. This used to be a small little deck but it’s neat to see what it’s grown into. Ordered the lobster and mojito and both were amazing! Friend got the risotto and it was exceptional. Love the vibes. Parking was easy across the street. Can’t wait to come back!

Beautiful people and amazingly tasty dinner

Das beste Restaurant auf der Insel.

Lobster was cooked perfectly and full of flavour. Service was a bit on the slower side but the restaurant appeared to be almost at capacity; which in itself is a good sign. Super popular place with tourists and locals

Sharky's has a nice, relaxed atmosphere. It was full when we were there so things were a bit loud. That being said, the food was superb. Tasty, on time, decent servings - I have to come back here for the food. Even if I have to order take out! Yummmmmm😋 The service was ok. The owner spent time ensuring that things were alright and chatted with us a bit.

O risotto estava com um tempero sensacional, a lagosta até assustou o tamanho. Ficamos muito satisfeitos.

Amazing food and vibe. Owner works the tables alongside the staff. Amazing attention to detail! Lobster risotto is a must try!!

Simple great!!! Espectacular servicio!!

What’s nice little local spot. You’re literally eating in the chef’s home with his family helping with service. They truly know hospitality here, and are so friendly and happy to share their place with u. I recommend the carpaccio and the lobster stir fry. Don’t let it intimidate you. If lobster isn’t ur thing, the grilled shrimp is amazing in the creole curry sauce. Solid wines here too!

Ordered the $70 Lobster only to be served a stir fry of rice and veggies with minimal lobster. Not sure where the lobster went....

So far, our favorite dining in Anguila. Reservations required. Come early if you want the snapper! Lobster and shrimp risotto was amazing. Great local cuisine and the vibe is great!

Def. Recommend. Food was really good and atmosphere was great! Got some drinks and had a good time listening to the singer. Thought we were hearing Louis Armstrong on stream, but this guy was just as entertaining and so good! 😊 Those with stage fright be prepared to sit in the upper deck where you’re less likely to be called upon to spontaneously sing when the mic gets offered during a song. Bring cash tip $. Didn’t like that the ONLY option was to use the valet, as we usually like to park and walk but as it was a busy night, it may have been best. Reservations needed. #louisarmstrong, #”L.O.V.E.”, #Anguilla

One of our favorite restaurants on the island. Everyone is super attentive, Kieran and Lowell , the owner continually checking in with all the tables. Our meal was superlative. And we really enjoyed the music.

Great service and food!! We enjoyed meeting the chef/owner.

The food was exceptional, My family and I had a lobster stir fry, steak stir fry, and the mango snapper. There was also a singer that we could request a song to which was really cool. Again like most of Anguilla, the food was a little overpriced.

Amazing spot, great service, ambiance was welcoming and food was outstanding! I highly recommend the lobster stir fry and lobster cake! You can’t go wrong!

Absolutely delicious place - much better than the fine dining options at the best hotels in the island. A must visit.

Excellent location from the beach and resorts. Great night for a date night, anniversary or even a family group. Food, service and live entertainment were on point.

Accogliente e davvero caratteristico

Never disappoints! This island favorite, local et all, is the place to dine! The food is absolutely incredible, the staff is the kindest and most attentive on island and did I mention the food is absolutely amazing!!! I have celebrated a couple of incredible birthdays here as well as just regular dinners, and let me tell you, Sharky and his staff are always there to make us feel at home and extremely special! Thank you for opening, operating and keeping such great people around your incredible restaurant! Here’s to many more years! Don’t forget to try the Lobster Cake! Caesar or Chicken starters, and finish with either the Lobster Stir Fry, Rack of Lamb, the Pork - or of course - the Shrimp and Lobster Risotto! Who get’s Chicken at a restaurant, well here, I Do!!!! Don’t forget Bread Pudding for Dessert!

Service was terrible. They didn't have enough help. The bar tender didn't know how to make certain drinks and didn't care!

THE FOOD! The Workers! The Atmosphere! Did i mention the food?!? The jalapeno lobster shrimp risotto is simply to die for! From the very first bite, the flavours explode on your taste buds! There are so many wonderful dishes to choose from! A trip to Anguilla is not complete if you did not have dinner at SHARKY'S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

We always try to eat local when on vacation and Sharkies came highly recommended. The food was amazing and they had a fantastic musician there that night. We loved the mussels (they were the best we had on this trip), the snapper and the lobster risotto.

Amazing! Shrimp and lobster risotto belongs in the pantheon of great dishes. Service was great. Chefs comes around to say hi. A great experience all around. A must eat.

Amazing pumpkin soup, swordfish, pork, rum punch! Need reservations for sure. Also live jazz sax musician Allen was fantastic classic jazz. One of the top two meals we had on Anguilla!

Excellent food and atmosphere. Best meal we had on our trip!.

Visiting the island and having a hard time finding the amazing dining that Anguilla is known for what was able to get to Sharkeys on the last night before they closed for the season and the food was amazing! Had the snapper and the tuna plus a serenade from the live musician and greeting from the owner himself and highly recommend this location to anyone visiting. Far better than any overpriced hotel food.

Great food and great service. Get a reservation though. They are popular.

There were no complain. All things went well. The service was great. The food was real mom's kitchen style, just great home made style , taste and flavor. Just the way my mom cook . It was well done. The staff and table attendance, first class. The music was well chosen for a Sunday night. The dj. Top of the class. Night well spend. I am in couraging you to check it out. U won't regret the experience.

Their food is amazing!! I had Jalapeño Shrimp and Lobster risotto. Mussels for appetizer. Amazing!! I highly recommend

LIVE Music on a Sunday night and it was SUCH a great vibe!! The food for MOUTH WATERING -- had the lobster cake for an app-- yum and the spicy lobster risotto for a main and wow just to die for. The grilled lobster also delish and FYI if you request it they will take it out of the shell.

We were blown away by the food here. This was our favourite dinner in the island. Service was great also!

Our favorite meal on the island yet! We made a reservation a few weeks prior to visiting. Absolutely phenomenal lobster and risotto dishes. Topped it off with chocolate mousse. Blown away with how genuine and kind the servers were. Loved our meal and can’t wait to come back!

Meal was the best on the island 2 appetizers 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 Lobster cake Fried calamari Main 👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻 Lobster risotto Mango glazed Red snapper Dresert⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 2001 Bread pudding All of this was excellent! Highly recommend

The food is amazing